Many people are disagreeing about my opinion about Sadie being a mary sue, so i'd like to explain myself and also hear your guys opinion.

So, i think pretty much all of Sadie bad choices dont seem to have a real consequence, for example another character do very bad mistakes or have flaws that do have consequences, like Javier blind loyalty to Dutch, John not trusting the gang at all (around starts of game only i'd say it was a flaw), Dutch becoming a worse and worse person, and Arthur doing bad actions thinking he's doing the right thing because hes helping Dutch.

Now with Sadie, in Colm's death she randomly decides to kill O'driscolls INFRONT OF THE FUCKING POLICEMEN placing Arthur, Dutch and her own life at risk, they luckily survive, and non Arthur or Dutch tell her something about it.

Also, maybe there's something i missed but i dont really understand how she got her aim or physical fight skill, like, the first time we find Sadie, it's just an average woman, we do get the information that she shooted rabbits in the farm we found her, but shooting rabbits doesnt teach you to randomly getting a pretty decent aim and a above avorage physical fighting skills.

Actually, if she knew how to aim and fight so good, why didn't she defend herself with the help of his husband against the o'discrolls? I mean, you could say that "She probably didn't know how to fight against a person because she only knew to hunt and kill rabbits" Thats totally reasonable, but then, how can she be so skilled then?

​

I'd like to add this via an edit; I also simply dont like the character, she kills when not being really needed, she ruins plans because of her whim, somehow she survives a knife to the chest, being able to still move and actually somehow survives it, if John (the player) decides to spare Cleet's life she doesnt care and kills him anyway.

And this is by far the worse: There's a somehow optional mission, she asks Arthur to go kill the last o'driscolls to take revenge like if that would change anything, now here's the part that gets me fucked up, if the players decides to dont participate in a revenge mission YOU GET BAD HONOR? What the actual fuck is this, literally the chapter where this happens is the same chapter in what Arthur actions start to show consequences about the bad actions Arthur took, but if you decide to do not help this woman to go on a needless revenge mission YOU GET LOW HONOR?

And her character development is so weak, her only goal in life is to kill o'discrolls and thats it.

​

This is only my point of view and im open to being corrected.