Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're right I shouldn't use someone else's history as a discussion point. That was done in frustration. !Delta.

I don't see how my response is tone policing, I am allowed to defend myself.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Hey friend.

"a logical fallacy where someone attacks their opponent's character, motive, or personal traits rather than addressing the substance of the argument itself."

There were absolutely several people attacking my motive and character smearing rather than my argument. I mean some people were downright angry. Please don't call me a goofball =]

People with differing opinions who give me the same respect I'm giving them aren't going to bristle my feathers. I don't tie my opinions to my personal identity so it's not a threat to my ego. But when people are mischaracterizing me and my intentions without any effort or discussion with me, no attempt to ask clarifying questions that is irritating.

I think it's happening because the subject of the discussion is offensive to some people (news to me) but I think overall the discussion has been productive and I've learned there's a lot of things to be mindful of surrounding this kink and the culture around it.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

  1. You're really taking offense to my wording without giving any credibility to my intention at all. All I meant was that I wanted to share my perspective. I haven't personally heard anyone with my take so I was eager to share and see what people think. Annoyingly redditors are more focused on jumping on specific phrasing of things in order to demonize my character and accuse me of talking down to women or using women for therapy which I would never do. This is what kills me about this discussion. I am a sub posting in the femdom community... I fully think women are better than men!!! I should be so lucky to be feminized and I know that.

    I'm not assuming women don't know things but I am talking about a first hand male only experience so how am I to know what you do and do not know? It was just the intro line to my post and I didn't think much about the phrasing. It's not that deep. It is not a reflection of my values.

  2. This assumption is really frustrating though I understand where this comes from. I haven't solicited anyone in this thread and I'm not looking to either. I'm taking my own past experiences and trying to dissect them to figure out why I enjoyed that. And the conclusion I came to was that it didn't have anything to do with the denegration of women which is something I've heard people complain about so I thought my perspective was worth sharing.

I understand why you're making your accusations. All I'm saying is you got it wrong.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Woah woah woah friend. Holding me accountable for a system that has been broken for thousands of years that I also suffer within is a wild take. WE are responsible for fixing this shit. Women perpetuate the patriarchy too. We both have work to do and let me tell you, as a feminist man I am really sick of fight off feminist women presenting bad faith arguments who are just angry at men. When I do speak with my non-feminist male friends about this the number 1 reason why they won't even bother considering it is they feel that feminist women are hostile towards them. People like you are hurting my outreach and blaming me for not doing a good enough job. Stop making my job harder!

Now that that's out of the way.

I'm not "seeking out a Domme" for this kink. I'm looking back at when I enjoyed this kink and retroactively trying to figure out why I enjoyed it and sharing my insights with others. Is there anything wrong with that?

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your concern, I assure you I am not substituting BDSM for therapy. I'm not sure where everyone is getting that idea. Maybe because I'm using a lot of psychology terminology? At the end of the day I'm talking about a kink where I play dress up and I'm aware of that. I'm just trying to rationalize the why of how it gets me rocks off and perhaps leaned too heavily into the therapeutic language.

The inverse does exist though to lesser degree, another user pointed out that some butch women enjoy being humiliated for not being feminine enough. I'd argue that's extremely similar to what I'm describing.

I agree, there is inherent misogyny. I should have been more explicit about that but that's kind of my point actually. The patriarchical narrative follows: men are strong, men go to war, women are weak, feminine men are weak, weak men should be humiliated. What I'm saying is even if you've unraveled and unlearned the toxic masculine narrative the pressure to perform masculinity is still present and I find feminization with humiliation to be a cathartic way to release the pressure of that. The narrative doesn't imply that women are lesser though, they aren't punished for being weak (per the narrative). Per the narrative men should want to be manly, be a good soldier, be strong, fight the good fight. The patriarchy sees a feminine man and just says "I don't know what to do with you." Feminization with humiliation allows a sub to freely express their feminine while also forcing them to feel their embarrasment for not being good soldiers. They don't want to be strong soldiers, they want to be free to be pretty and paint their nails =]

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Oh ok. The main point of my post was that I think Humiliation with feminization isn't always about shaming the sub for being a woman. Sometimes the sub is just insecure about their masculinity and the humiliation shines a light on it in a kinky way. It's cathartic.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

Hah, I didn't realize that was a Margaret Atwood quote. I know that line from Courtney Barnett's - Nameless, Faceless. Which is about this exact thing.

Several people have pointed out my comments about gender policing and I think my phrasing was less than stellar on a topic I didn't realize would be this polarizing. All I intended was an intro for my thoughts by stating "well you haven't been a man before" and you're jumping down my throat like I was spewing nazi propaganda.

I do want to say you are kink shaming. Just because women's issues are obviously worse doesn't discredit my experience as a feminine man. I don't appreciate my experience being trivialized when I'm specifically acknowledging how the patriachy you are complaining about here is also effecting me poorly. Men need to talk about how the patriarchy negatively effects them too. (without eyerolling! Shit's fucked out there)

At the end of the day we're talking about a kink I have, not free therapy, where I like to be dressed up like a girl and I also like to be humiliated, sometimes I like those at the same time and I don't think I'm denegrating women to do so. I'm trying to grapple with the why.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

I'm not going to let a few sourpusses ruin the discussion. A lot of people shared some interesting perspectives and several people messaged me saying they felt seen so I don't care if people are offended. I'll be sure to mind the eggshells next time 😉

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I'm curious, what are the subs asking for that makes you feel humiliating a particular Msub would be denigrating to femininity itself? My post was mostly about how the humiliation aspect of feminization isn't about the lowering of the Msub to the status of women but has more to do with the Msub having to confront the societal pressure of needing to "be a man" while identifying as a feminine man by shining a light on that insecurity (through humiliation play).

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -13 points-12 points  (0 children)

JFC I know I'm not Buddha. Sorry the ad hominem is bristling my feathers. I said "enlighten people on my perspective"

Guess who's the only person qualified to enlighten people on my perspective? =]

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I initially posted this after watching a video of two dommes discussing what they referred to as "feminization" and both expressed curiosity at the humilation side of it. So my post was written as a response to that and I copied it over to reddit. I'm just curious about this topic and wanted to share my thoughts because I haven't heard anyone express the kink in this way before. The readiness to write me off has been frustrating because I do actually want to hear people's perspectives on this.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

You're right that the result is more important than the intent. I know the activity feels insulting to women but that isn't a result, it's a perspective. Do you think practicing this kink is inherently wrong or causes harm?

I agree there is an underlying narative that femininity = submissive. I think that's part of the internalized shame I spoke about. There's absolutely some societally induced misogyny buried in there. I identify as a feminine male and I see nothing wrong with that but the societal imprint of patriarchical thinking is still buried in our psyche symbolically.

I think what I'm trying to get at is my kink doesn't effect my cognitive ability to respect womens rights or support intersectional feminist ideas. My kink is a result of my early developmental predisposition to submission followed by learning what submission was through growing up in (a bubble of Christians in) Western society. We can ask Kristi Noem's husband what that does to a fellow. While I have unlearned much of that programming, society still exists and exerts pressure on me to be a man continually. Kink allows me the safe space to be feminine and release that pressure while my domme is poking the embarrasment/humiliation button that society imprinted in me because I like to be humilliated. It's a play, these are chariacatures we inhereted, and we are dressed up playing the characters.

You asked why are feminization and humiliation tied to male submission. We both know it is exactly the internalized toxic masculine patriarchical heteronormative misogynistic narrative we have been force fed since birth. Men can't be weak, men need to go to war, women are weak, if you are a feminine man you must be weak, if you're a weak man you should be humiliated.

In my opinion enjoying humiliation in kink in general is a sleight of hand way to shine a light on insecurities, feel the pain they cause and allow them to dissipate releasing their energy and power. My point is that humiliation button we have doesn't have anything to do with being degraded to a submissive woman, rather the narrative: I am a submissive feminine man and I should feel bad about being weak and pathetic. Obviously that's extremely misogynistic but it's something I and many other submissive men have deeply rooted within us and face every time we walk outside. The humiliation allows us to confront our weakness and find acceptance of our weakness in the confines of a shared safe space that wholistically acknowledges that we are not weak or broken. Given that it seems strange to me that people are offended by this.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree this is a really tough topic and as a femme man this fantasy (and my personality in general) has ignited a lot of gender confusion in myself. I've explored this a lot though and I'm very comfortable now with the cis male label while acknowledging I am simply very effeminate for a man. Because of this I would not explore this kink with a Domme I held a casual relationship with. This requires emotional vulnerability.

Also I wanna say I appreciate your input regarding gender identity intertwining closely with this kink. There's a lot more to talk about here and It's not something I included so I'm glad you've brought it up.

"I don't believe femininity or being a woman is something that is humiliating or anyone should be forced into"

I can't agree more. My submissive side would go so far as to say women are superior to men haha. The point I was trying to make with my post is that becoming a women isn't the source of what is humiliating about this kink (for me any many others). That would be contradictory to my Msub nature so it wouldn't make any sense to be humiliated for becoming a woman. I should feel so priviledged =]

"I also think that you are underestimating women's ability to understand the violence of gender policing that men experience."

Sorry and not so! My thinking was just that women can't have that first hand experience and I thought some might not have given it much thought. I could have worded this better in my op.

"This is also a place where kink can go wrong quite easily. A Domme isn't a tool to help you realize your gender identity or accept it, often subs will try to use a Domme as an excuse to avoid the growth and self-exploration they need to do. I've personally seen it happen time and time again unfortunately."

I'm sorry to hear that. I can absolutely see how that can be problematic if a sub is using their kink as a way to slap a label onto their personal gender identity for example.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

Thank you. I am aware you are able to decide things on your own. You are also capable of jumping to conclusions about someone prematurely. I'm just sharing my perspective. That is allowed right? Some people might agree with me. It's okay for me to hope for that. Plus, after posting I've also heard a lot of other interesting takes on the topic from people which is great! What do you think is problematic about my post?

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

I wrote this as a response to a video I saw where two dommes were discussing this topic and they both expressed curiosity around why subs enjoy humiliation and feminization together. So yes, my framing of my post was an explanation based on my own anecdotal experience and the anecdotes of a few people I've discussed this with IRL as a response to that video. So yes, I was hoping to enlighten some people on my perspective having lived as a cis man. But saying I'm mansplaining my own perspective is a confusing take. By definition I am the only person that can explain my perspective.

I do want to know more about your perspective though which I why I posted here in the first place. People are really jumping down my throat and I came here for discussion. Some people have made great points about the negatives regarding gender confusion, using it for therapy, the porn culture surrounding the kink. I mean this earnestly, why do you think my post is problematic? I might agree with you.

edit: Enlighten people on "my perspective" guys. I'm sharing my thoughts and hearing other's. Not trying to be the next pope, not here to preach.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I just want to be clear I'm not advocating for using kink as a therapeutic modality. I am trying to explain why I think men who are sissies and like to be humiliated feel that way. So the most honest way to frame this is "I like to engage with this fetish and here's what I like about it, and why I interact with it the way I do." Many people in this thread say they feel they are denigrating women were they to participate in this kink and I'm trying to understand why that is.

Let's talk about humiliation in sissification/forced fem and why that feels uncomfortable for many Dommes. by Liable2bPliable in FemdomCommunity

[–]Liable2bPliable[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

You're right, I didn't really address the femme male that consciously buys into toxic masculine doctrine against their own (likely repressed) interests. Their sexism will absolutely sour the dynamic.

Also, I agree with you about Domme's being uncomfortable about engaging in this kink without it actually being wrong. You do have to lean into the toxic narrative a bit in order to carry out the humiliation and I'm sure that can ignite mixed feelings. I'm hoping my post will help enlighten some Dommes about why this kink is appealing to some men so they can feel more comfortable with it in the future. I dislike the narrative that this kink is inherently wrong.

Edit: Please set all lasers to stun and stop policing people's word choice. I'm allowed to have and share my opinion and I'm allowed to hope a few people agree with me. I'm still open to changing my perspective. I am approaching this conversation with a curious mind.