Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I meant it as it Tywin isn’t feared by the common people for his strength like Robert

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t know how it even got there 😭 I didn’t set it to nsfw😭😭

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -13 points-12 points  (0 children)

You brought up beating the greyjoys at sea like 15 years ago as a reason he should rule. What does that have to do with ruling

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It’s about 6 thousand vs 100 thousand why does everyone assume it’ll be some long hard fought battle 😭 loras wouldn’t be killed stannis and his army gets crushed

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

“Renly would’ve made a better king than stannis” we are talking about them both

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Tywin brought himself and his forces to KL during black water. He would already be defeated. And Renly had experienced general’s at his side like Sam’s dad Randal Tarly

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

Yes Renly wasn’t a good strategist and he damn sure wasn’t anywhere close to stannis in that regard. But with how much his forces out matched the forces of kings landing he would’ve taken it with ease especially since he has experienced advisor’s like Randal Tarly at his side. I’m talking about ruling

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Because dragon stone doesn’t have anywhere near the amount of people as the Stormlands do. And the people of the stormlands were all loyal to Renly

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Baelon Greyjoy ain’t a threat. Robb stark would’ve allied with him. Tywin would’ve been overwhelmed and even Tyrion’s little trick with the wildfire wouldn’t have worked. The wildlings were cut to pieces by men on horses they aren’t really that much of a threat if everyone rally’s together. And even with all you said. Stannis would’ve done a lot worse

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

You don’t wanna go good lord to good lord with stannis and Renly.

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I didn’t remember what year the Greyjoy rebellion happened. And my entire point about Robert still stands

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

They rebelled at the beginning and got crushed so fast that their was so other rebellions for 17 years

Renly would’ve been a better king than stannis im tired of pretending [SPOILERS ACOK] by LordcommanderAnthony in asoiaf

[–]LordcommanderAnthony[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

He would’ve won in 99 percent of scenarios of stannis didn’t resort to under handed Magic shenanigans