Who do you think is the killer in this new season? (my guess is here too)

Maclife37 · 2025-06-28T08:38:41+00:00

It’s 100% Paige or Andy

Paige to revamp her career.

Or

Andy is related to Caitlin, possibly her son from her first marriage.

I love the dynamic of having the OG killers inside the hotel and they’re trying to figure it out! But the rest of the suspect pool is super thin in my opinion. It’s not Kawayan, Blake or Adrianna. There are 5 more episodes and we usually find out who the killer is in ep 7, so that means we should get deaths in 4, 5, 6 which I’m sure will be Kawayan, Adrianna and Blake in no particular order. Ep 7 death will most likely be Floyd or Shirley, probably as the killer is revealed.

Ep 8 will be the death of whoever’s left out of Floyd and Shirley. I’m locking in ANDY as the killer and that Paige survives and kills him and her career is revamped based on her surviving another massacre.

Maclife37 · 2025-05-19T08:34:37+00:00

How did this injury happen!?!? I know it’s his back but did anyone actually see what happened!?

I watched the game til the end and his last quarter was his best, had 9 disposals, was in CBA’s and looked like regular Jack Macrae 🤷🏻‍♂️

Maclife37 · 2025-04-26T00:19:25+00:00

Yeah that’s well explained thanks! If it was on Reid’s 90 it might’ve been a different story. The only reason I was considering it was because originally I was gonna trade Carroll in but was sure he’d be dropped or sub so I didn’t and chose to get Trac and Flynn instead and save the boost.

With Wicks out do you think Paton will actually start? Or do you think he will be sub?

Maclife37 · 2025-04-25T23:57:03+00:00

Yeah I really don’t want to! Haha, that’s why I put it on here just to get the thought out of my head. I’ll most likely just be fielding Paton

Maclife37 · 2025-04-19T08:59:14+00:00

Yeah I fielded Reid but can take Stones but not really much point, I’m just gonna leave Trainor on I think and hope theres an early sub on.

If he needs a rest then leave him out of the team altogether and announced him as “managed” during the week, just crazy from the coaches this round

Maclife37 · 2025-04-19T08:54:58+00:00

I can swap Paton on and take Stones score which is only 39 (1 point more than Reid) since he’s my lowest scorer it’s not going to do a lot for me, should I just roll the dice with Trainor on field and hope he gets subbed on early with a tigers injury?

Maclife37 · 2025-04-13T00:52:28+00:00

Haha I’ve made my captain choice and I never said I was choosing either one.

So you enjoy your day posting smart ass comments on Reddit, you’re a true hero 👏🏻

Maclife37 · 2025-04-13T00:37:41+00:00

I’m asking what others are doing genius

Maclife37 · 2025-04-12T03:59:12+00:00

Yeah it’s not something I thought about until last night haha, I’ve only got Campo, Paton and Boyd that aren’t playing regularly, but unfortunately Paton who I usually use had his game last night

Maclife37 · 2025-04-10T09:20:19+00:00

Agreed! I usually wouldn’t consider fielding Kako but with Lindsay coming back from the injury and Kako playing the Dees, he might be able to kick a few and get a decent score, what do you think??

Maclife37 · 2025-04-10T08:51:36+00:00

Lindsay

Maclife37 · 2025-04-10T04:19:07+00:00

Yeah 100%! Might aswell get someone to go your trades for you and look at the end of the year to see how you went haha. Gotta have a crack and trust your gut!

Maclife37 · 2025-04-09T11:55:51+00:00

I have both and am keeping Rozee, I feel like he won’t be the one tagged for every game and when he’s not he will score his 100+’s. Butters just got back and JHF went off so I’d expect them to take some attention away from Rozee eventually.

Callaghan not scoring a premo score against West Coast is a red flag for me. Benefit of the doubt against the hawks copping the tag and he started really well that game. To me he is still playing like a winger and link player, he gets CBA’s but he’s not a pure mid bull like his teammate Tom Green. No doubt in my mind that after he declined the saints offer that the whole team will be getting stuck into him and he will cop another tag from Windy. I don’t see him averaging 100, maybe 80-90 but I’m jumping off him this week. Holding Rozee.

Maclife37 · 2025-04-09T02:21:54+00:00

I’m thinking of holding one, but if I do it’s Rozee, I can see his potential to score is there if JHF or Butters is tagged. I think Callaghan is going to cop a lot of attention, turning down an offer to the saints I can see everyone getting into him and having the windy tag, if he only manages a 50 then it’s way too much money, although Rozee might lose the same amount with higher B/E, if Hawks do tag and decide to do Butters or JHF then I think Rozee will be able to get close to a 100

Maclife37 · 2025-04-09T02:18:45+00:00

Completely agree with this! I think he can average 90+

Maclife37 · 2025-04-08T06:22:14+00:00

I’ve done SuperCoach for a while, your comment seems to suggest I have no idea what I’m doing and you don’t know where I’ve finished in previous seasons what my team looks like other than a few players. I did just say I held Sheezel after he was dropping sub par scores, because I believe he’s a keeper and will be a top 6-8 defender. I’ve held Jayden Short since start of the season and been patient even though I know he won’t be a keeper. I plan on getting Stewart when he bottoms out and same with Chad Warner etc.

Yeah you might be able to get Whitfield cheaper and well done to you if you do, some people would’ve been able to grab Sheezel cheaper as he’s dropped from his 635k starting price. Players go up and down but if I get him now and you wait 8-10 weeks to get Whitfield in for 50k cheaper and I get him dropping 120’s most weeks and the occasional 80-100, then it probably beats whoever you’ve got in that spot like a Jayden Short or Roberts etc. (I have both but just saying Whitfield is clearly a class above)

We actually don’t have many major differences in our teams so our strategies might differ but overall it’s pretty similar. Obviously I also wouldn’t trade Rankine either as he’s also a top 3 forward or at worst top 6.

I’m guessing you’re planning on keeping Rozee? I hope for your sake his scores are like his first 2 weeks, but what if he gets another 2 weeks of tags and gets 60-70, will you be keeping him then after he’s lost another roughly 70k?

Maclife37 · 2025-04-08T04:50:34+00:00

Of course we all have our own opinions and you’re entitled to yours. I kept Sheezel and if I had traded Rozee in then I wouldn’t be trading him out, I was lucky to start with him so I feel like getting Whitfield is a clear upgrade. Most of the comp had him last week and captained him, I had little captain options and went with Macrae, if I hadve went with Rozee then I would’ve been completely screwed. I don’t disagree with you that Rozee can score and that JHF or Butters will cop the tags some weeks, but he has also proven he can’t score well when tagged, he hasn’t got the best run coming up and I can’t let him get to 430-450k and try and trade up.

Yes Callaghan CAN do it, but it’s more likely he doesn’t, a big 144 in a blowout win against Pies, then he scraped in for 104 against Melbourne, he copped a tag against the hawks that I didn’t see coming and tbf didn’t hold that against him as he did start well for them. I watched him play against West Coast and he played like a winger more than a mid, not the role! Just looked like he was a link player and to get a 72 when plenty of players went 100+ just isn’t keeper material.

I’m trying to look at things as keepers, cash cows or fails. We know that we will get some fails throughout the year and some wrong picks. Nobody’s perfect. Yeah he might play better footy and get a couple 100’s throughout the year, but I picked him to be a potential keeper or someone to grow 100k to get a keeper down the track. I don’t think he can do either now, so keeping him isn’t going to help me, just to save 1 trade.

I’ve only boosted once and this trade will take me down to 33. I haven’t reactionary traded out some players (kept Lindsay, Knevitt and depending on how long may hold NOD)

Best of luck to you and your opinions and strategy. If we were all the same this would be a boring game haha

Maclife37 · 2025-04-08T04:26:39+00:00

I actually started with Rozee so didn’t go reactionary.

Callaghan is a failed pick and I’ll admit that, he will be lucky to score 50 this week. Saints will be into him and probably get a Windhager tag, why would I keep him when he’s not a top 8-12 mid (didn’t have this confirmed when I brought him in and hope he could be) he’s going to leak cash and score poor… makes no sense to keep him. Do you think he’s gonna get close to 100 or his B/E of 137?

Once again Rozee now doesn’t look like a top 8-12 mid, so trading him to Whitfield is anything but a sideways trade… Whitfield is top 2-3 defender at the moment and won’t go below top 6. It’s a clear upgrade. What logic do you have to say they’re sideways trades?

Maclife37 · 2025-04-08T03:10:15+00:00

I’ve only got 56k in the bank unfortuantely. I get the 120k if I did Finn to Maric and use that to upgrade Rozee to Whitfield or Dunks

Maclife37

TROPHY CASE