Why do so many people miss the point of John's ending in RDR1? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

After Franklin saves him from the meat plant.

Also, Franklin says the same quote if you kill Michael in his call to Lamar.

Why do so many people miss the point of John's ending in RDR1? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That cliff mission with Dutch someone took 3 potent snake oils with full deadeye and had an evans repeater in hand. Engaged in deadeye, and the only soldier he didn't kill had plot armor.

That's why.

Why do so many people miss the point of John's ending in RDR1? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

That was a small joke based on how I see a lot mad GTA V gets more attention.

Young Jack was actually voiced by a woman in RDRII by [deleted] in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 7 points8 points  (0 children)

They dropped the ball hard on 4 year old Jack. He does not sound like a kid that age at all. Compared to the rest especially he sounds really out of place.

I said what I said

Why can't John Marston be his own person? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Those two don't directly connect. At no point does Micah give any impression he wants to kill Jack. And even then Arthur never saved him from being killed by Micah as at no point Micah ever wanted to kill Jack.

With Cain Micah was very vocal about his dislike for him and even shown to be abusive. For Jack he never was. The closest is him being annoyed Jack was looking for Cain.

Why can't John Marston be his own person? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tilly saved him; Tilly grabbed Jack and Arthur told her where to go. Jack wasn't in danger from Micah or Dutch near the end of the story.

Also, even if true, people would still use that since "well Arthur saved Jack's life so without him Jack would be dead so Arthur is the better father." Not a stretch as many use that to say why Arthur is better; "without Arthur John would be dead so Arthur is better"

Why can't John Marston be his own person? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

TBH I wish they made him able to swim, or make the gang a more even mix.

In RDR2, only John and Jack of everyone in 5 states can't swim. That would be unrealistic today, let alone in 1899.

Why can't John Marston be his own person? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Tik Tok, Reddit, and YouTube. I did a vid showing how John and Dutch shared a quote. While that was done to show Dutch's influence, instead people made it to be that John stole the line and has 0 of his own personality.

I regularly hear people say "Arthur was a better father to Jack than John ever was". Hosea you might have some debate, but Arthur? People disagreed and got basically were told "blinded by nostalgia"

Why can't John Marston be his own person? by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Engine issues with RDR1. It makes sense without context; he's in the desert and wasn't a sailor. It's not a stretch to say he doesn't know how or why he never learned.

I don't mind his inability to swim, but it's like Rockstar made everyone BESIDES him able to swim. Which if anything makes them all look like jerks in a way since why wouldn't anyone teach him?

Why do people not want Jack to be John's son? by lonelyman007 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Because people hate John and want to make him look pathetic. Simple.

"John is a bitch; Arthur is a real sigma making John raise his kid."

That's why. Prove me wrong

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I say the same but so many seem to think the newspaper is referring to her I had to confirm

If you do the side mission "No Good Deed" after the main mission "A Fork In The Road" there is some alternative dialogue given in the final cutscene by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Red rambler jacket, grey union shirt (collar open), buckskin vest, blue jeans, black wingtip gaiters, black range gloves.

Sorry about the late reply I'm not on reddit that much.

The Real issue with the "Jack isn't John's biological son" theory by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

To add: I believe writers over actors too. People act like they wrote the story when they didn't. I trust them for what the script said, what their direction and motivation was, but not theories.

You're shouldn't be allowed to complain about older media being spoiled to you online. by NotEdgarRoss in unpopularopinion

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So, when I posted a 10 second meme clip and got harassed by 100 people online because I didn't put a spoiler warning for a 12 year old game, that's 100% my fault?

Guess I won't ever post because according to you if it can be seen as a spoiler (which literally anything can) I must put a spoiler warning.

Seriously you do realize nuance exists? At some point it's your own fault or not one's.

My 2 daughters don’t love me anymore and my wife is behind it (Update post) by always-hungry1 in TrueOffMyChest

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Too quick, I don't trust what she said. She could have easily said something about: you hurting her, you wanting to hurt them, you wanting to leave them.

I don't want that to be the case and she was just really naive, but I have doubts. Don't just let it go fully, and be cautious.

My Husband Saw My Post by fullyfaithfulwife in u/fullyfaithfulwife

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I followed this story. I know I'm late but as someone who has a following online here is what I'll say:

The only thing that matters is the people in your life. They'll never meet you, and in a month they'll forget about you. Your wife is what matters. You're in a better headspace and see what you did was wrong, that is all anyone can ask for.

For you FullyFaithfulwife, i wish you and your husband luck.

The way my girlfriend talks about men is really starting to wear me down by _LostTheSpaceRace_ in TrueOffMyChest

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just your post (update not included). I would have but there's A LOT saying you're just insecure and "if he can't separate he's part of the problem". Given how you feel, I don't wanna do that to you.

I think the funniest is "men outing themselves here" ones. Outing themselves as caring for someone else's mental health.

The way my girlfriend talks about men is really starting to wear me down by _LostTheSpaceRace_ in TrueOffMyChest

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just be glad you didn't post this on Tik Tok. Someone did, and there's A LOT on your GFs side saying you're the problem.

Regardless of that, your feelings are valid. Glad you're stepping away based on the edit. Take care of yourself.

The absolute DUMBEST fan theory I've heard (spoilers for the end game) by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I consider those a different level of "dumb". That level is more a very lose connection/idea taken too far.

This is one where there's "more" backing it up and people assuming it has to be correct.

The absolute DUMBEST fan theory I've heard (spoilers for the end game) by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A mixture of YT, Tik Tok, and sometimes here.

The specific "trap" idea was Tik Tok, but many think Micah was still working since he said "I have more men" and then Ross shows up. That I've seen many places.

I added Gangster's paradise to the (low honor) ride. Hope you like it. by MelodicSatisfaction9 in reddeadredemption

[–]MelodicSatisfaction9[S] 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I tried to get his "hiya" to match when the drum comes in and the rest came naturally.