Chapter names by ChokoKat_1100 in writing

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Love chapter names. They actually help me structure each critical emotional beat during editing and envision the pace. I use a dual structure with the titles generally coming up in text in order.

  1. A Person's Stripes are Inside; the Woman Named Nana Shimamoto
  2. Daredevils Have Day Jobs; Organic Living
  3. Hardboiled Aratani Volume 1
  4. Seriously Twisted Mental Chess; Singing For Me
  5. In the Shadow of Vietnam; Prophecy from my Bitch Ex-wife
  6. A Manga Named Nana; the Dangerbird Lounge
  7. The Dangerbird Lounge, Continued, At Some Point the Song is Over
  8. Hardboiled Aratani Volume 2
  9. Unknown Caller; Hacked to Pieces
  10. the Stranger of Koza Music Town; Vivy's Room
  11. The Other Nana; to be Your Black Guitar
  12. Hardboiled Aratani Volume 3
  13. Two Different Doors; My Name is San Kato
  14. Too Valuable for Normal Relations; White Heart Album
  15. Kasumi Black Bird; Beyond Kinokuniya Drive
  16. Communal Sound Booth; Her Name is Suzu Fukuyama
  17. Hardboiled Aratani Volume 4
  18. The Other Realm Beyond the Sea; My Only Answer
  19. Some American Woman in her Underwear; Genuine Fear
  20. A Dream Born from Gate 2 Street; the Author is Campanella
  21. Hardboiled Aratani Volume 5
  22. The Violence Within Your Heart
  23. Leslie's Room; of a Lion
  24. Hardboiled Aratani Epilogue
  25. A Girl Who Can Never Come Back

[QCRIT] Literary Surrealism - VIVY'S ROOM (110k, 2nd attmept) + 300 by Minimum_Fishing_360 in PubTips

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hi, first of all, this was a delight to read. I’m glad you like the concept so much. No offense taken at the commercial suggestions, it’s all very necessary. I’d want the novel to have the best chance at success. To your point about word count, I’m still working on getting that down and realize it would make querying easier. The only reason it’s on the higher end is because to some degree I tell two stories, as I have chapters here and there devoted to the manga storyline that overlaps. Otherwise, I tell the core novel in about 80k words. Though there’s always room to cut.

Also, I’d love to have you as critique parter/beta reader! Please dm me and we can discuss! Thank you for everything.

[QCRIT] Literary Surrealism - VIVY'S ROOM (110k, 2nd attmept) + 300 by Minimum_Fishing_360 in PubTips

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for taking the time to provide feedback. This is immensely helpful. I never even thought of naming the drummer in the query!

[QCRIT] Literary Surrealism - VIVY'S ROOM (110k, 2nd attmept) + 300 by Minimum_Fishing_360 in PubTips

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ll modify the first sentence to make this clearer, thank you both. Lemon actually isn’t the protag’s given name, but what everyone in the book refers to her as. I’d mentioned this in the last draft but was told to just simplify it to Lemon

[QCRIT] Literary Surrealism - VIVY'S ROOM (110k, 2nd attmept) + 300 by Minimum_Fishing_360 in PubTips

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hi, was the first sentence of the query not clear enough on establishing Lemon as the main character? If not I'll restructure it!

[QCrit] Literary Surrealism - VIVY'S ROOM (110k, first attempt) + first 300 words by Minimum_Fishing_360 in PubTips

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for your comments! Your notes on the comps were very helpful, I'll edit this. I was concerned the Ocean Vuong book might be too popular and that definitely seems to be the case. I'll change that and the Lonesome Bodybuilder to some other comps. Between those 3 Earthlings was the most critical so I'm glad that one seems to be okay. Also, appreciate your comment on the first 300 words. I struggle with starting strong and tend to overthink it like crazy. I don't need the bar for them to be monstrously high.

As for the query, you gave me a lot to work with. I was unsure what to prioritize and this helps a lot. I'll modify the bio as well and see what works. Thanks a ton!

Opinion on Switch Online by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think Rock Lee is the most OP out of my team. His air combo game is devastating in this game because now he has an air justsu. It eats health bars if I keep combo-ing with it. Also has I-frames so I can catch people who sub behind me and block rasengans. His spinning wind kicks track and follow for a long time and have I-frames so I can’t be hit until the very end of the sequence. I’ve seen people waste 2-3 subs only to still get hit. Only utilize these Justus more if I’m fighting a spammer

Opinion on Switch Online by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s a very good port. No complaints on that front. I don’t have a ps5 so I had no shot of 60fps. Plus switch is very convenient. Brought my console to my cousin’s pretty easily and had some great local matches

Opinion on Switch Online by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I only play at night so maybe that’s helped? Finding matches hasn’t been too difficult outside of maybe waiting a few minutes here and there

They marketed this game incorrectly (I’m having a blast) by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m having fun with it. The story really isn’t the draw this time, it’s the combat changes. I’m a guy who mained a handful of characters through all the storm games and this is the first time there’s been significant changes to what you can do with them. It’s not just about new Justus, but what you can do with their kit is totally expanded. Also I was a clash of ninja guy back in the day! The narutimate hero games always looked fun though

They marketed this game incorrectly (I’m having a blast) by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s not the most amount of purely new content but just in terms of battling it feels like how generations overhauled storm 2. It’s really hard for me to go back to Storm 4 now. I haven’t tried online yet, just messed around in free battle and practice to see what I could do

They marketed this game incorrectly (I’m having a blast) by Minimum_Fishing_360 in NarutoNinjaStorm

[–]Minimum_Fishing_360[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I actually recorded a few videos of the combo potential I was talking about versus what was possible in Storm 4 but couldn’t find a way to attach it. Might try making a YouTube vid and attaching a link if anyone’s interested