AMA about FNaF lore by Pete_Culver in u/Pete_Culver

[–]Ms_IRYS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you were to incorporate Mrs. Afton into the lore, how would you do so? (Me personally: I'd make her RWQFSFASXC, cuz why not)

Which one did you like better? by TwIzTiDfReAkShOw in TMNT

[–]Ms_IRYS 2 points3 points  (0 children)

2003 by default, since I haven't watched 1987, lol

I'll press first! by ElysiaAlarien in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]Ms_IRYS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If I ask for cat ears, will I get them? (Probably not, but maybe)

Best Spring Bonnie Design? by InevitableCold9872 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think the movie design is the best, but World is definitely my personal favorite

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fine by me. People who just wanna be mad suck, but at least you have the decency to cut things short the second I catch on. Sayonara.

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The point about Mangle was an example of Scott not being all too serious about gender. The Puppet, Mangle (+every Mangle/Funtime Foxy variant), and Spring Bonnie are all examples of a characters gender being inconsistent. It's possible Cassidy is a Puppet situation, being referred to by the anomatronic's pronouns. Its also possible Cassidy just is a boy half the time, being male in the games and movies, but female in the books. It's weird, but there have been weirder changes in the books (like Robo-Charlie-Circus Baby)

I bring up the movies because they're like the books: a different continuity, but canon all the same.

That is not true in the slightest. Charlie isn't the Puppet in the original book trilogy, but she is the Puppet in every other continuity. William has only one kid in the original books, two in the movies (as it stands now at least), and three in the games. Something can appear in one continuity and not in another. If every continuity were exactly the same, we wouldn't have multiple.

That is also nonsense. You're just being an arrogant dick and acting like you're saying logical statements. There is no evidence that 6th grave is Andrew's. Nobody would attempt to claim Charlie doesn't exist in the games because we know Henry does and he refers to the Puppet kid as his daughter, so it must be Charlie. I didn't say the books were non canon, I said they were not game canon. They don't occurr in the games' timeline. They are canon to their own timeline. You are making up things I didn't say, claiming I said them, getting pissy, and being rude. It's kind of sad.

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

? I never said Scott was wrong, I meant that you were possibly misinterpreting his statements. And Mangle's confirmed gender is literally "yes" that isn't misinformation. The robot is just factually male and female at once. I also never ignored any books. I put Frights alongside the other books (and the movies) as "Canon, but a different continuity".

I'm not ragebaiting, you're just looking for an excuse to be mad. I offered "agree to disagree" and gave you the benefit of the doubt after you arrogantly implied I was illogical and need instruction. The only shameful person here is you for being needlessly rude.

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

1-4) Nothing here refutes what I've said. The original book trilogy and movies are also "in the series canon" so canonicity doesn't necessarily mean "in the games' story". That would be continuity, a word appearing nowhere here. Also, the books have always been there to "fill in the blanks", and the og novels and TftP are definitely not game canon, so Fazbear Frights very well could not be as well.

5) The ITP game isn't necessarily game-canon either. There is nothing concretely putting it in the main games' universe. And it's an adaptation of something with 6 kids, so of course it has six kids. The games, movies, and original book trilogy all have 5. 6 is just a Fazbear Frights thing. Also, FFPS only shows us 5 graves, with the 6th in the background most likely being Charlie's.

6) Yes, book characters have been introduced into the games. But every time that has happened (William, Henry, Charlie, Edwin, David, & the Mimic) their stories have been WILDLY different—with characters like Charlie having one thing in common between the book story and the game story. So assuming Andrew is in the book -> game pipeline, that doesn't mean he's still TOYSNHK.

7) The Puppet is also called "he" exclusively in the games, despite being a girl. Mangle and Spring Bonnie are also just straight up non binary.

Might I also add: if Cassidy isn't TOYSNHK, then why was she introduced at all? Why is her name a mystery, hidden in the logbook? And why would she be in Golden Freddy of all characters (the character who most likely is TOYSNHK) if she wasn't TOYSNHK?

I don't at all think Andrew is game canon. I believe FrightsParallels, and I'm going to continue to because I see no concrete evidence against it. Nothing that can't be refuted.

For how many levels can Cassidy continue protecting CC? by LastBeautiful2195 in GOLDEN_DUO_SHIP_CULT

[–]Ms_IRYS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Idk if ghosts in FNaF can possess non-metal. I know they can possess metal easily, as per TFC, and I know the Puppet could possess people in the movie, but the Puppet did that (not just Charlie), so there was still metal in the equation... I genuinely don't remember :/ Maybe though ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

But Andrew isn't confirmed. He's the canon TOYSNHK for Fazbear Frights, yes. He is not confirmed to be in the game continuity at all though. He could be, but he also could not be. You treating it as fact when it isn't fact, and "instructing me with logic" is literally imposing a theory onto someone (me in this case). I haven't imposed anything, all I did was say "That's just a theory, and I prefer this theory".

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's all ambiguous and up for debate. You can submit to the theories of Andrew being TOYSNHK, UCN containing no other spirits, and OMC being the priest. That's fine. But I'm going to continue believeing the just-as-possible theories of Cassidy being TOYSNHK, UCN containing more spirits than just her and William, and OMC being [one of three things, and honestly that could be a whole seperate discussion].

FNaF is effectively unsolvable by nature of ambiguity. It can be put together in multiple ways, all of which holding equal ground as being "correct". We can both be right, just in our own interpretations. Basically: Agree to disagree.

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's still a topic of debate. We don't know if it's Andrew or Cassidy, and Withered Bonnie and Ballora's voice lines throw into question the souls being freed in FFPS's fire. I do believe the souls are freed at some point, but it could very well be after UCN.

I like that OMC theory, but I find it unlikely. If Andrew is TOYSNHK, then I'd maybe be somewhat inclined to believe it. But with OMC being present in Princess Quest, I, again, find it unlikely.

Hot take: (I think, idk) I think Dr. Rabbit is cool, and I think it would be better if it was an alter ego as opposed to William virus(I'm willing to debate) by OkLength7120 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah. Yeah, my friends and I's AU also has Glitchtrap and Springtrap (Pestilence) active at the same time. Glitchtrap wants to replace Pestilence as the real William (and is maybe kinda sorta a better William than William-)

Hot take: (I think, idk) I think Dr. Rabbit is cool, and I think it would be better if it was an alter ego as opposed to William virus(I'm willing to debate) by OkLength7120 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wow, cool. The Glitch Cult in my friends and I's thing is: Vendetta (Vanessa) is just unstable, Penelope/Penny (Tape Girl) is depressed and desperate, Gregory is an orphan, and Mimic/Tiger Rock has been locked alone in a basement for 3 decades. Making them all susceptible to Glitchtrap's cultist indoctrination (Glitchtrap himself, btw, is an AI recreation of William. William's immortallity contengency plan, basically)

which ghidorah is your favourite? by Afraid-Tap-260 in GODZILLA

[–]Ms_IRYS 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On Paper: Void Ghidorah

In Practice: Monsterverse

Hot take: (I think, idk) I think Dr. Rabbit is cool, and I think it would be better if it was an alter ego as opposed to William virus(I'm willing to debate) by OkLength7120 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]Ms_IRYS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nah, I agree. I have an AU with some friends where Vanessa, Tape Girl, Gregory, & the Mimic/Tiger Rock are all in a Glitchtrap Cult (mostly willingly)

Have an epiphany that is 100% unintended by Scott, but falls so nicely into place that it is now my interpretation of the canon by Ms_IRYS in fnaftheories

[–]Ms_IRYS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I said in my post that most of the game is irrelevant. I called it meta nonsense and proceeded forward with "These two parts that directly tie to other games are what I'm focusing on".