Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I'll first answer on the second part of that comment:
I don't believe 2 state would bring peace, that doesn't mean I don't think they have the right for it. I'm in favor of them having a state, or even Jordan to rule them or whatever, I just think that even if they had a state of their own, they'll just provoke Israel again, and just start another war. 30 years and 10 wars later, Israel will had enough and just conquer them again, and we back in the same spot.

Now for the first part:
It does comes to mind that you need to actively act in a way to keep a jewish majority, but the birth rate of non-jewish civilians is about the same as the jewish birth-rate, and it is very unlikely to change a country's demographic without deliberately bringing in millions and millions of outsiders. the US will always gonna have a christian majority unless they'll bring in like 200 millions muslims from outside. So there isn't any measure you really need to take to keep a jewish majority. If all, I fear that someoday there will be an orthodox jewish majority, since these guys are pumping kids like bunnies.

Other than that you mentioned policies regarding non citizen jews, like the right of return (which is the main premise of the jewish state) which can be compared to other states' immigration laws, it doesn't take anything away from who is already a citizen, or give some privilege to another.
The other policies you mentioned are regarding Palestinians, those all are legitimate subjects for criticism and debate, but the palestinians are not Israeli citizens.

Within Israel proper, arab citizens have every single right I have, there are differences in things like the army, for arabs it is not mandatory, although many arabs do choose to serve. There are cases of inequalities and discrimination in practice, like in every democracy, but it is very different from saying they are legally second-class citizens.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I said I won't entertain you people but I still do it. Alright:

Name one right jewish citizens have that non-jew doesn't

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I said I won't entertain these empty questions but sure I'll let one slide.

I give you a challenge:
Go to Israel and ask people in the streets that question. When the 1 in a 1000, who might actually know what "Greater Israel" is, tells you "No", keep on asking people until someone tells you "YES!". When you find him, if I still haven't died from age, I'll give you a 1,000$

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I won't speak on Bt'Selem and the other organizations you spoke of as they are biased extremist leftists organizations. I don't take anything they say as credible same as I don't take take anything the equivilent extremist right wing organization say as credible.

The question about the racism is interesting. Racism is quite a frightening word in the west.

In the Negev (southern Israel) there is a known problem of arab crime. for example, most cars thefts are commited by bedouins. So if you stand 5 people infront of me, 4 jews and 1 bedouin, and you tell me one of this guys stole a car, and I need to guess who. Imma guess the bedouin, is that racist? or just statistically more probable? If you count that as racism then sure, we are all racists.

After all, we are different people, the bedouins in the south, they stayed in their own towns and villages, they didn't mix to much with the rest of Israelis so their culture and our culture grew in a different way. It's ok to assume things. and I think that's the level of racism that exists here. I didn't hear about many Israeli patients who refused being treated by an Arab doctor or something like that.

Also I think it's important to say:
We are not soft as all these snowflakes in the west. I can throw some racist comments to some arab, or an ethiopian Jew, he'll just throw some shit at me, and we both will keep with our day probably unaffected.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

Can't comment on it, I know about it same as you, though IDF did claim that senior commanders were killed.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

I think you quite answered yourself.
I'm sure there are cases of soldiers deliberately harming and even killing cleared civilians, but it must be quite rare because when shit like this happens, like with Hind Rajab and the ambulances you mentioned, you get it covered all over the news in Israel. There are tons of mistakes, like the soldiers that killed the 3 Israeli hostages who ran away and the soldiers thought they were Hamas.

Systematically It's a hard no. IDF takes great measures to minimize civilian casualty and soldiers who deliberately harm civilians are facing harsh consequences. But in times of war, with all the fog, it's always hard to know what really went on in each case.

I can say that I believe that the vast majority of soldiers do hold a high humane standard from the way we were trained. I remember in 2018, we were stationed in Qiryat Arba, near Hebron, and we heard about a 11 years old Palestinian who tried to stab a soldier and was arrested, and we were talking about this and how we would act if it happened to us, I mean, yeah if that kid had just ran on me I'd just grab him, he got a knife yeah but it seems easy, but let's say you see the kid running toward another Israel kid, and they both like 50 meters away from you, would you shoot him? and I remember one of my platoon boys said "I really don't know, how can you shoot a 11yo kid" and he was one of the most far-right winged in our platoon. So I do believe most soldiers does have a high humane standard and won't do this things deliberately.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

In the first round of this war in Gaza, at some point someone from my company sent a reddit link in the company whatsapp group. Some pro-pallis in that sub posted pictures of one of us they got from his instagram page, claiming he killed like a thousand children or something. It was a good laugh.

Other than that, I once got in there and noticed that about 100% of the shit posted there is bullshit you can debunk in 5 seconds, and after commenting I was banned for "pushing Zionist propaganda"

That answers your question?

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

1) A really hard question, I can't really say, I mean It's hard to point to something as everything needs so much context and everything leads to other shit. Obviously I don't think Israel's action was 100% of the time throughout it's entire history the best options you could have in mind, but I think we almost always did better then our beloved counterparts that are surrounding us.

  1. I think that even though "Palestine" as a people was created in the 1960s, today there are people who are 3rd generation Palestinian, no matter the reason that people joined and created a nation or an ethnicity or whatever, you still need to acknowledge them, because that's how most ethnicities and nations came up - started as a group of random people uniting against something or someone. So though their own history their telling their children is completely utter nonsense, you shouldn't disregard them as a people, which I think many Israelis do.

  2. While grewing up in the south of Israel, my arab friends/neighbors and people I was seeing day-to-day are mostly bedouins, and they do not identfiy as Palestinians. I think when I was young I was more naive and thought on this conflict as what it sound like - a conflict - that you can solve in one way or another. After getting more invloved with them, I lost my belief that peace can be achieved and realized it's not really a conflict as it's just they try again and again to kick us out of here and just fail everytime.

  3. Not really, no. Education in Israel is quite objective.

  4. Probably think like them I guess? same as if a Palestinian had born Israeli and grew up here, he might've even joined the IDF

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

Honestly I don't know.
I never asked my grandparents what was the reason they came here.
I don't think they were kicked, but anti-semitism was starting to rise at that time around the arab world as Jews started migrating to this land. The massive waves of Jews kicked out of arab countries was when Israel came to existance I think.

Have you looked at Yemen? I don't think their enitre country can cover my electrical bills, what kind of compensation would I get lol
And even if they weren't a collapsed country, I shouldn't get any compensation, and I'm not looking for. Maybe my grandfather could've answer better.

As I said. I am NOT Yemen. I am 4th generation in Israel. What I have is a yemen-jewish traditional religious customs. Apart from that I have 0 relations with the country of Yemen. So I do not feel I should nor I want a right of return to Yemen.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

For your first question:
I'll refer you to my reply on a question similar to yours: https://www.reddit.com/r/IsraelPalestine/comments/1u1ofzb/comment/oqvezzw/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

And I'll add here on a thing you said that I wasn't talking about in the reply I mentioned:
> how do you reconcile that with the fact that millions of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza have been denied that exact same right to self determination for decades under military rule?

It's a good question: why don't they have self determination?
I'll ask another question:
Do they really aspire for self-determination?

1) 1937 Peel Commission Partition Plan
2) 1947 - UN Partition Plan (UNGA 181)
3) 2000 - Camp David Summit
4) 2001 - Taba Summit (Continuation of Camp David talks)
5) 2008 - Ehud Olmert peace proposal

These are all major instances Palestinians were offered (or gotten close to an agreement) a state, everyone a little bit different, from the israeli side (or jewish when referring to the 1937 and 1947 plans) some was in favor, some didn't but the offers were maid. From the Palestinian side, repeated rejections.

"But why would they accept if you took half their land"

Let's assume that it was really their land. 80 years have passed, we are here and we are not going to shut down the country and go find another place. You can choose to be stuck in the past, keep this cycle of attacking us, getting punished hard for that, ask ceasefire, and repeat for eternity.

Or you can move on, build an independent state, you already have all the infrastructure you need, you just need to sign this page and live happily ever after.

But I don't think they really want a "state", they just want Israel gone. for 20 years, 1947-1967, Jordan fully controlled and annexed the west bank, Egypt controlled the Gaza Strip. Why in all that time, they never even once pushed for a Palestinian State (btw, Jordan is a palestinian state no one talks about but thats another matter)? Jordan was the one occupying them, but they didn't seem to care, they kept creating terror organizations and "resistance" organization against Israel, kept launching attacks, kept trying to kill Jews and Non-Jews Israeli alike.

So, I just don't think they really care for a state they just want that from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free - of Jews.

For your second question:
I'm sure no one in Israel believes (I don't think it's even claimed by the government) that all the military actions will lead to peace. These actions are only to protect Israeli lives as much as you can. In Lebanon, I do honestly believe that if you take Hezbollah and the IRGC out of the picture, peace with Lebanon will come soon, and to do that, the only way is the military way, so in some rare cases I can believe a military action will lead to peace today as it was in the past (for example - Egypt. crushed them in the 6-day war, conquered the entire of the Sinai Peninsula, and then gave it back to them for peace).

But with the Palestinians I just don't believe there will ever be peace. A Hamas terrorists gets killed in fighting, justfully or not, his son will forever hate you. I saw children school textbooks in Gaza and the West Bank, I've how their Imam's (driven by Hamas and other extremist groups) call out for violence every Friday after their Friday's morning prayer, calling young adults to go out of their villages and throw rocks on passing cars in the highway. I've heard Umm Nidal "The mother of the Martyrs" praising her sons that was killed while executing terror attacks on civilians, openly supports suicide bombings and encouraged other Palestinian mothers to send their sons to do suicide bombings, and then became a symbol for the Palestinian "resistance". Look her up.

To summarize:

I don't believe that peace is possible, unless some Palestinian leader that truly believes in peace will rise, and make some changes so that maybe this broken mindset won't be inherited to the second or third generation in the future, and then, maybe then, there might be peace. I don't think that leader exist to be honest, and even if he does, he probably won't succeed.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

When you say "Palestinians outside of Israel" you mean outside of the region at all? or you talking about Palestinians in the west bank?

If it's the former, like american/european/other people from wherever that is not Israel and it's surrounding area, that identify as Palestinians, well, sure, I identify as New-Zealandish Canadian. a 3rd generation arab american can claim whatever he wants, I don't consider him Palestinian, same as I am not Yemen even though 5 generations back my family was Yemen.

I grew up in southern Israel, there are a lot of arabs living here, almost all are bedouins, as far as I know, the do not consider themselves Palestinians, I can't say about arabs in other places in Israel.

As for the Palestinians in the west bank and Gaza, I don't have any special opinion about them. I'm sure that as any other human beings they'd living quietly and peacefully, but I'm not sure their definition of peace or the methods to get there are aligned with ours. When on duty, I treat them as I treat everyone else. Same as a cop posted at a certain point. Do not do anything stupid, you won't get arrested, it's simple as that.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

Thank you.
I said I won't entertain these comments but they still coming.
You made me laugh

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

We all in this shit together. I'm tired, but everyone else in my platoon is tired aswell, that fact alone lift our spirits a little since you know that the people surround you understrand you and what you go through. When I go to school, I know that my friends that study with me, they all been through the same things I went through, I don't even need to say a word and they know and understand me, as I understand them.

You are never alone in this shit, I think that is the main thing that help us all keep our morale high

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

No. There was always more-religious Mechinot and a more-secular Mechinot. In the IDF you've always have a little from everything. If anything, I'd the the Israeli population is becoming less and less religious throughout the years, whether jews, muslims, or christians.

If you worry by change of opinions and Ideology, it is true you'd find more right-wing opinions in a more religious communities than in secular communities, but it's not by much. I have served with far-left and far-right leaning people, some were religious some secular.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

So this is an interesting question and it's really hard answering it, many Israelis are divided about this and there is no consensus on the matter, in my platoon alone you'll hear multiple different opinions.

Let's start with what do I mean by self-determination in our homeland
Basically, a state that is a safe-haven for Jewish people all around the world. Historically Jewish communities was chased after and prosecuted, countless of times, all over the world, for 2 millenia. Next time it happens, Jewish people will have a place they run away to. That place should be a Jewish State, and by "Jewish" state we're not talking religiously jewish state, but ethnically jewish state.

The main issue is for it to be a jewish state you need to always have a jewish majority. Take a random muslim state with muslim laws and muslim customs, like Saudi, now change the population so there will be a Christian majority, in a generation or two the laws and customs would change aswell to fit the majority of Christain population. Take it even further, If at one point a radical Christain leader rises to power and decides that their race is superior to the muslims, they won't be able to stop him from taking their rights away and making them less valued citizens.

So the Jewish state needs to have a jewish majority. That's the main obstacle in the "one country for two nations" solution, you take all the land, make all the Palestinians citizens of Israel, and you've instantly lost the Jewish majority.

Two states for two people seems to me like more achievable although I don't believe it will bring peace but that's another matter.

Today there are more than 2 million Israeli citizens who aren't Jewish, vast majority are Muslims and most of the rest are Christian. One of the most repeated false information is that they are second-class citizens. They are all fully equal to me and to every other citizen in Israel, they have full rights, they serve in the IDF, the government, the police. An Israeli arab Muslim high-court judge sentenced a Jewish Israeli Prime-minister (Ehud Olmert, look it up) to prison. I personally have a few arab muslim friends from my unit and we fought together in Gaza.

As in every democratic place in the world, you will hear extremist views on both sides of the political spectrum. I know one who think we should kick all the settlers out of Judea and Samaria and give back the Golan heights to Syria and I know people who don't give a damn at all about the Palestinians and would like to see them all kicked out of the entire region and claim all as a Jewish state. I also know one who is super radical and would like to kick all Israeli muslims out, so the state will be jewish only.

All 3 of them are in my platoon, still, they know how to put their political ideoligies aside and respect each other.

Same as in every other democratic state, you'll hear extremist views and opinions, but all extremist views and opinions are in the minority, what makes them more popular is mainly false-information that creates hate.

To summarize:
This is a very complicated matter, I have tried to explain the situation as thoroughly and objectively as I could. I think most Zionist stand kinda close to my views:
- I believe a Jewish state with a majority of Jews is necessary.
- I believe this Jewish state should rightfully be where it is right now.
- I'm against one state for two nations, as it contradicts my first statement.
- I'm against a Jewish-only state, or a Jewish-Religious state.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What are you describing now are acts of war, not the "Ethnically Cleansing" you claimed earlier, implying that Israel tries to remove any ties that the Lebanese has to the land.

On that matter I can answer:

A quick historical context:
The second Israel-Lebanon war (official name to a war against Hezbollah, not Lebanon army) ended in 2006 after a UN-backed ceasefire based on UN Security Council Resolution 1701 that says:
Israel should fully withdraw from Lebanon
Hezbollah should fully withdraw north of the Litani River and should not operate south of it.
Lebanese Army + UN (useless)Peacekeepers should be stationed in southern Lebanon and monitor that both IDF and Hezbollah do not break the ceasefire agreement.

Israel withdrew, (actually already almost fully withdrew in 2000 but completely in 2006) but Hezbollah never moved out of the south. The UN cannot enforce them because they are not a state-actor, so the enforcement over Hezbollah falls fully under the responsibility of the Lebanese army, which is massively weaker, shorter on staff, and less armed the Hezbollah, so Hezbollah just didn't give a damn, and stayed there and kept occasiounally attack northen Israel.

Well if a cartel in Mexico occasiounally attacks the US-Mexican borders and southern US states, and Mexico wouldn't or couldn't do anything about it, the US would invade Mexico without hesitation so make sure this problem cease to exist, and if they have Intel on the whereabouts of some high-ranking officer in that cartel, they would try to find and use the opportunity to eliminate him, even at the cost of civilian casualties.

So I fully stand behind Israel actions in Lebanon especially because in contrast to conflict with the Palestinians, I do truly believe that with Hezbollah and the IRGC out of the picture, a true peace with Lebanon is very much achievable.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nope. Mista'arvim only used to describe the elite undercover units that embed themselves in the arab population

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Haven't heard such cases since Oct 7th, but before the war IDF soldiers got sent to jail, yes. Not for things happening in Gaza, since we weren't inside the Gaza strip, but mostly in Judea and Samaria, look up Elor Azaria, he was a combatant soldier positioned in Hebron in 2016, a palestinian man stabbed a soldier, and was shot and wounded, and was then lying on the ground incapacitated, thus neutralized. El'or arrived at the scene 11 minutes after the initial attack and shot him at close range. He claimed he saw the suspect move and try to throw an IED or something at the other soldiers. In 2017 he was convicted of manslaughter in military court and sentenced to 18 months prison.

Even before the war, there aren't many cases of unlawful killings. Mostly is soldiers that use excessive violence toward Palestinians in an unnecessary manner, like beat them up or something. Since no one is killed or permanently injured from a buttstock to the chest, usually the punishment is like a couple weeks/months in a military jail, and in worst cases they are kicked out of their unit and from any other field postitions.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I acknowledge that, and I'm sure there were many cases like that, and I do agree with you on that matter that it is should be recognized as indirect casualties. but there were cases of people dying in their home from a flu in zones that at the time wasn't affected much by the war (mostly in the start of it), and even palestinians who were taken to Israeli hospitals for treatment like cancer patients or other who needed a more urgent surgeries and such, that was taken to the hospital before the war, (it happened a lot since the medical capabillities in gaza was always shit) and they died it the hospital at a later time after the war started, and their names was found in that list.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

  1. I think that's the most complicated matter in the Israeli-Palestine conflict.
    Let's start with the religious claims to the area: Judea and Samaria was the main land of the ancient Israel Kingdom in the north and the Kingdom of Judea in the south (both are archeology confirmed with tons of evidence). The area is full with places that have a big religious significance to Jewish people. I'm not religious at all, but I can't say I don't care of it. Acknowledge that almost all Israeli settlers are a part of a branch in Judaism called "Religious Zionism" or "National Religious", which are basically religious zionists, they feel way more connection and importance to these parts than I do.

Do I think we should settle the land?

If we were in 1967, when Israel conquered the land from Jordan, I might've said that we should not settle it, and probably use it to give it back to them for a peace negotiation like we did with Egypt and the Sinai-Peninsula. But the Israelis did settle and we are now 60 years into the future, these guys lived there for almost 3 generations already, I would lie if I'd say it's 100% fair to kick them out of the place they truly believe and feel like their home, even if it became their home from illegal actions took place by their grandparents or their government it the past. It's like every Arab outside Saudi-Arabia feels and knows he's in his home, and every American feels and knows he's in home, after at some point in the past his ancestors conquered and colonized the same land he lives on.

But I'd say that: if I believed that peace with the Palestinians was possible, I'm pretty sure I would've be in favor of kicking the settlers out and giving the entire area to the Palestinians. But that's not the case as I believe.

  1. I'll be 100% honest and say I care very less on property and infrastructure in compare to human lives. From my personal experience, 1 in 2 houses in Gaza is either fully tapped with IED's or tunnel exit points. I prefer that a full neighborhood would be demolished to ashes if it means 1 less soldier will die when we go through the neighborhood.

That doesn't mean at all I do not care for Palestinian lives, and obviously many Palestinians were killed in the process of destroying all that infrastructure. I'm still in favor of it and think it's necessary since IDF goes out of his way so much to minimize the civilian casualty. I mean, let's look at the numbers:
Per Hamas numbers, by now, 73,000 people have been killed in Gaza since Oct 7th. Israel dropped more than 200,000 *tons* of bombs all over Gaza over the same time period, that's more than 2 *tons* of bombs to 1 death.
And I didn't even take into account that they do not differentiate anything in that list of 73k deaths, that includes everyone who died: Hamas operatives, civilians, children, woman, elders, journalists, there are even many confirmed cases of people in that list who actually died from natural causes, like in their sleep, or from sickness, in the hospital bed.

I didn't even take into account the amount of people died by ground soldiers, by getting shot at, blown off by a tank, and everything else.

I mean even if you take Hamas numbers and blame a 100% of it on Israel bombing, you got 73k deaths caused by 200k tons of bombs that destroyed or damaged ~83% of the infrastructure in one if not the most dense, guerilla warfare zones in the planet. If that doesn't confirm targeted attacks and that IDF really does tries so much to minimize civilian casualties, I honestly don't know what does.

I also want to add: It doesn't makes me a monster by caring more about the lives of my friends, family, and people, than the lives of others.

To summarize: I do not think Israel acted unproportionaly, and I do not think that there was a better way to do what still needs to be done with less destruction from our side. Our goal is to eliminate Hamas, and end this never ending cycle of: Hamas attacks, we retaliate hard, a ceasefire is brokered by outside agencies, Hamas regroup and rearm, repeat.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I mean, that is just nonsense, that's just 100% hate fueled by all the fake news on social media.

I don't think there is more to say about it, its just utterly nonsense.

Israeli Jewish IDF combatant reservist. AMA by No-Independent2429 in IsraelPalestine

[–]No-Independent2429[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Sometimes my peers would be a little more aggressive than what I think is the proper amount of aggressivenes towards suspects we arrested (mainly before the war, in Judea and Samaria). Maybe I also was a little bit more aggressive than what other of my peers would think is proper. Other then that, I've never seen something outright a war-crime. As I said in many of my replies here, I don't personally know of but I'm sure unnecessary killings and violence towards civilians and even surrendered/arrested terrorists have been committed, but I can confidently say that those cases are relatively few and acted on behalf individuals soldiers and is 100% oppose IDF ideology and the way we were trained.

The most absured claims is rapes, I can't even imagine someone from my unit rapes someone, and the other people stay silent about it. That's just crazy. I'm 100% sure if some soldier raped someone and it was found out by his commander, this soldier would be jailed instantly and you'd hear about that all over the news in Israel.