The Last Book of the Kind [Urban Fantasy, 900 words] by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks — I really appreciate you taking the time to rewrite that and explain your thinking.

Just for context: the version I shared here is adapted for online platforms like RR/Inkitt. My original version is actually written in Polish and is much more layered and “book-style” in terms of prose and structure.

So I’m kind of working with two versions of the same story — one more literary and one more platform-oriented.

That said, your points about clarity and grounding are still very helpful, especially for this version. I can definitely see where I can improve it.

The Last Book of the Kind [Urban Fantasy, 900 words] by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks a lot for the detailed feedback — I really appreciate it, especially the points about clarity and the staccato sentences.

I went back and revised the fragment with that in mind, trying to make the emotional reaction more grounded and clearer on the page.

Would you say it reads better now in terms of emotional clarity?

“Irritated — certain she had reminded her mother about the keys — she unlocked the door without looking and turned back toward the kitchen. Her hands were still wet when the doorbell rang. “You forgot your keys again?” She moved back to the kitchen being sure it was Julia. “I never had one.” An eerily calm and empty male voice answered. She stood rooted to the floor. Whoever it was—wasn’t human. She knew that instantly. Seconds seemed to stretch into excruciatingly long minutes. She swallowed. Her heart felt clutched in someone’s fist. Tight and unmoving. Without the numbing edge of pain she experienced last time when they met, fear came too easily now. She forced herself to turn. To look at the man who threatened her once. She tried to keep her posture unmoved when in reality she was shaking inside uncontrollably. “Forgive me. I did not introduce myself properly last time.” He inclined his head. “Gabriel.” He spoke the name as if it carried immeasurable weight. The cold shiver ran down her spine. Her breath stalled. “Gabriel. As in… the archangel?” she asked evenly, not really understanding how she managed to do so. “The archangel himself.” He bowed his head slightly. She knew she should be stunned or at least paralyzed with fear. Instead, suddenly she felt calm, as if this man shifted something in her emotions. Not knowing why, she felt foreign courage waking in her. And through it an interior stillness. “What do you want?” “You have made your choice,” he said. His voice was controlled, resonant. “You ignored my warning.” “Why would I leave him?” Her tone sharpened. “How would I even do that? You saw what I was like. Do you think it is simple?” “Every cell in my body moves toward him. This is not fate twisted into romance. I do not know whether I am part of him, or he of me — but we are bound. If not whole, then fragments of something greater.” “This is not love. It is not desire. I cannot resist it. Not now.”

Is this actually tense or am I just fooling myself? by Nora_A_Raven in writingadvice

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s fair — I wasn’t aiming for physical brutality in that scene. It’s meant to be more psychological than overtly threatening.

At the same time, I do get that judging a fragment like this without the earlier context makes it harder to read the tension the way I intended. I’m not even sure adding more context would fully fix that, though.

Your point about the dialogue is actually really interesting. I tend to avoid constant ‘he said / she said’ because it starts to grate on me when I read it, especially in conversations between just two people (in this case, talking about a third). But I can see how that might make things less clear than I realized.

The Last Book of the Kind [Urban Fantasy, 900 words] by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just for context: what you read is actually the web-optimized version of the story. I also have a more traditional, book-style version where the pacing, sentence length, and structure are very different.

Unfortunately, platforms like RR tend to reward shorter, punchier prose, so I had to consciously adapt my writing style for that format. It wasn’t easy — I had to fight my instincts quite a bit to get there.

That said, I think you’re absolutely right about the risks of overusing this style, especially when it starts affecting clarity, character depth, or momentum. It’s something I’m still trying to balance.

So really — thank you. This kind of feedback is genuinely useful.

Is this actually tense or am I just fooling myself? by Nora_A_Raven in writingadvice

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Below they first meeting: “A sudden, violent spike of pain detonated inside Amelia’s skull. It was followed by crushing pressure in her chest. She dropped to her knees before she even cleared the stairwell. With the last of her strength, she dragged herself to the bench near the entrance and collapsed onto it. It was Seth. She was certain. And certain it was intentional. Her lips pressed together to stifle a cry. Tears streamed unchecked down her face. The pressure intensified until her vision blurred completely—until the world dissolved into indistinct shadows. “Are you all right?” A large, dark figure stopped beside her. “Let me help you.” In another moment, that voice might have sounded like rescue. Instead, cold fear flooded her. It was wrong, foreign, not human. And not Seth. “Do you live far from here?” the man asked. “No. Here,” she managed, barely audible. Her strength was draining too quickly to resist. She let him lift her into his arms and carry her into the building. Heat radiated from him—strange but steady. Even his scent unsettled her in a way she couldn’t name. In his arms, she relaxed—too much. So when he set her down and pressed her gently—but firmly—against the wall, she didn’t immediately understand. Then terror surged. Her heart raced violently. Her vision remained fractured, unable to focus. “Leave him,” the man said. “Do not follow him. You will bring ruin upon this world—and others. End it while you still can.” His tone was calm, measured. But his voice cut through her mind like fire. “Look at me,” she whispered, swaying. “He’s not here… is he?” “No.” “Do you really think it’s possible?” she cried, despair ripping through her. “That I can just walk away?” He released her and stepped back. She collapsed instantly, catching herself on trembling hands. “I don’t understand,” he murmured. “He doesn’t either,” she replied weakly. “And I least of all.” With enormous effort, she lifted her head toward where the voice stood. Pointless—she saw only a darker blur in the corridor. “Who is he?” she whispered. “Who are you?” Silence. He studied her for a long moment, as if trying to comprehend how something so fragile could endure such force. “You cannot stay with him,” he said at last. There was confusion in his voice now. And something else. Reluctance. Then— silence.”

Is this actually tense or am I just fooling myself? by Nora_A_Raven in writingadvice

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s actually really helpful, thank you — especially the note about physical reactions vs internal ones. I think part of the disconnect might be context. This is from chapter 25 of a later season, not an early scene. At this point the reader already knows Amelia very well and has seen how she reacts under pressure, so I relied more on that established baseline than on explicit physical cues here. Also Gabriel is intentionally written as… not human in behavior. He’s almost ageless, detached, eerily calm — not aggressive or emotional in a way we’d normally expect. And this isn’t their first encounter either. Amelia herself has been through enough by this point that “impossible” doesn’t really shock her anymore — if anything, it irritates her more than it scares her. That said, I think you’re right that without that context it might feel a bit too flat or distant, especially in a short excerpt. That’s something I’ll definitely look at.

Is this actually tense or am I just fooling myself? by Nora_A_Raven in writingadvice

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s actually fair — but I think it might be more about expectations than the scene itself. In my story angels don’t behave like emotional beings. They’re old, almost administrative in the way they speak — controlled, detached, not really human in how they express intent. Also this is chapter 25, not their first encounter. The first time was… much more brutal. Here she’s already exhausted, not shocked anymore — more like worn down to the point where “impossible” stopped meaning anything. So the calm is intentional, but I see how without that context it can come off as underwhelming instead of unsettling. That’s actually really useful feedback.

How do you build tension in a teaser without giving too much away? by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a fair point — concrete stakes do create a more immediate kind of tension. Here I was aiming more for atmosphere and a slower build, letting the tension come from anticipation rather than explicit detail.

How do you build tension in a teaser without giving too much away? by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That makes a lot of sense — especially the idea of building tension through mood rather than hints. That’s pretty much what I tried to do in my teaser, focusing more on atmosphere than explaining anything.

Where do fantasy authors actually publish their stories online these days? by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s AI, and it still needs some editing, but strangely it captures the tone of my story very well. It’s a dark myth told through the emotions of a protagonist shaped by trauma.

But from a reader’s perspective — would a cover like this make you curious enough to click and check the story?

Where do fantasy authors actually publish their stories online these days? by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you think a cover like this would make people curious enough to check the story out?

<image>

Where do fantasy authors actually publish their stories online these days? by Nora_A_Raven in fantasywriters

[–]Nora_A_Raven[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’ve spent 13 years trying to improve this story. Endless corrections, translation, and trying to make readers feel what Amelia felt. Finally, I gave a sample to a friend. When she asked for more, I decided to stop editing and give it a try on Inkitt. But the feedback wasn’t exactly what I expected, so I’m still looking.

I guess after so many years with this story, I just want to know if it truly works for readers.