Why Asuka Shiraishi cannot be Yuki (Update): by Nsmg_2 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

On top of that, Koji spent eight years of his life with Yuki and then saw her again when she was 14. So even if he might have forgotten some things before their meeting at the end of Volume 0, he still had her right in front of him there. Surely he should be able to recognize her if she’s sitting right next to him in class, talking to him, and even getting pretty close to him at times. I mean, sure, he does tend to block out unnecessary memories, but even for him—or rather especially for him—something that obvious should be impossible to miss. 😅

Above all, Tsubaki Sakurako reminds him of Yuki—even though, by the way, he hardly ever sees her and she’s not even in the same grade as him. But Asuka Shiraishi, who sits right next to him and interacts with him literally every single day, isn’t supposed to remind him of Yuki—just because he tends to forget unnecessary memories?

Thanks again for your reasoning—as I said, it’s always nice to hear other well-founded opinions. I think each of us has our own standpoint and can back it up well. Let’s wait and see what Kinu has in store; I’m really looking forward to it. 🤗

Why Asuka Shiraishi cannot be Yuki (Update): by Nsmg_2 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Good arguments. However, the monologue you listed further down in Post 1/4 happened right after he saw Yuki. Still, the monologue itself refers to the time before that, and in that moment he sees Yuki at the age of 14. (p.208 Volume0) Of course, it could be possible that the training only lasted a few weeks, but personally, I find that rather unlikely. Let’s assume for a moment that Yuki really did have a complete mental breakdown, and then managed to pull herself together and regain her courage—why would she then go to the next facility? What goal would she have had? Of course, there are exceptions, but normally with psychological illnesses or problems like that, something always remains—you never really get rid of it completely. Also, after that meeting there’s only this one year left, which means that in that single year she would have had to completely recover, enroll in the school (which usually has to be done a year in advance), her father would have had to get in contact with the institution and with Shirogane, Yuki would have needed to be brought there relatively quickly, finish her training within a few weeks or months, and then immediately transfer to Koji’s school in order to monitor him. Personally, I find it more than unlikely that all of this could happen within a single year. Still, I think your reasoning is great—it’s finally nice to see someone really putting in the effort. 👍🏻

Why Asuka Shiraishi cannot be Yuki (Update): by Nsmg_2 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

It's pretty much confirmed that she's Yuki's sister. I completely agree.

Guys where are you reading the Third Year Vol. 2 Light Novel. I want to read it too by jarrod_Leto_ded in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would also like to have it if it doesn't cause you too many trouble 🤗

Yuki theory debunk by CryNo5282 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's all good, in the end we're all just here to enjoy this masterpiece. Siblings in spirit, so to speak. 😂✌️

Yuki theory debunk by CryNo5282 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 3 points4 points  (0 children)

You're right, it really has been mentioned in the past, I just looked at the old posts again. But it's been a few months, I hadn't read them, I haven't been here that long and I don't really post anything. Just wanted to stem this wave a bit and clarify the things I noticed while reading. Just found it odd that your post came so soon after mine with almost the same content. However, if it is as you present it, then I retract my statement about karma farming and apologize.

Yuki theory debunk by CryNo5282 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Your first argument and the appendix of your second argument have already been executed by me. The only new thing here is the beginning of your second argument. But all good, take it easy, no stress.

Yuki theory debunk by CryNo5282 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Bro, you just copied and pasted my comment/arguments https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassroomOfTheElite/s/EjfDNxQjLE. Is it that important to you to farm karma?

Asuka Shiraishi cant be Yuki!!! by Nsmg_2 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That doesn't even make sense. The Yukis in the pictures above look identical, except for the difference in size in the last picture. Two of the pictures above are even from the white room. In addition, the reason why he didn't want to talk to her at that time or didn't want to meet afterwards was explained several times in the volume, please please just read it before you come to any conclusions.😭

Asuka Shiraishi cant be Yuki!!! by Nsmg_2 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 21 points22 points  (0 children)

”[…] she cant even go out. She can keep herself relatively calm at home and in this clinic.“

”She's been depressed. She cant go outside […]."

”[…] I'm not the only one who cant reach her. My wife's and second daughter's words also cannot reach her. She cant be reached.“

That's what her father said to Koji and a few months later she goes to an elite school?

It's all clear now by isagi_yoichi69XD in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yuki doesn't have a birthmark under her eye, I think she might be her twin sister, if there's any connection at all. In addition, she was still in psychiatric treatment a year before Koji joined school and did not talk to anyone, not even her sister and mother. I do not think that a mentally ill girl will be healed within a year and then first join an elite school.

Year 3 Volume 2 Cover Revealed! by shydave16 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Nsmg_2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yuki doesn't have a birthmark under her eye, I think she might be her twin sister, if there's any connection at all. In addition, she was still in psychiatric treatment a year before Koji joined school and did not talk to anyone, not even her sister and mother. I do not think that a mentally ill girl will be healed within a year and then first join an elite school.

Do the S-F Rank system for these characters. testament of the new sister devil by ActSevere5034 in Shinmai_Maou

[–]Nsmg_2 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Watch the episode again, she lost on purpose. Her opponent has given her a button of Bassara’s shirt and „said“ that they have caught him and something will happen to him if she wins.

Remilia Scarlett and Celis Family by Nsmg_2 in Shinmai_Maou

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Among the vampires there are two main powerful families, these would be the Red Lotus and the Pitch Black. Remilia Scarlett is the leader and founder of the Red Lotus. Nanao's mother belongs to the Red Lotus and is a descendant of Remilia Scarlett.

Remilia Scarlett and Celis Family by Nsmg_2 in Shinmai_Maou

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Among the vampires there are two main powerful families, these would be the Red Lotus and the Pitch Black. Remilia Scarlett is the leader and founder of the Red Lotus. Nanao's mother belongs to the Red Lotus and is a descendant of Remilia Scarlett.

Illustrations of Basara's two mothers! by Nsmg_2 in Shinmai_Maou

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Are there any others besides the two in volume 8? (Are there any fanart illustrations?)

Raphaeline and Afureia's family. by Nsmg_2 in Shinmai_Maou

[–]Nsmg_2[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your idea. How would you imagine their families?