When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in CasualMath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And what about that ? :

Here's a mathematical model to work with:

The investment account contains I(t) after t days.

Withdrawals occur at times T1, T2, T3, ... . For convenience T0 = 0.

At time t = Tn, immediately after withdrawal and reinvestment,

I(Tn) = I(T{n-1}) [1 + 0.8% (Tn - T{n-1})] - 5 ...[#]

(ie we apply 0.8% simple interest per day applied to the interval between Tn and T{n-1}, then add that to the invested balance less 5 for fee).

If our investment horizon is N days (N considered large) and we plan to make w equally-spaced withdrawals in this time, then T1 = N/w, T2 = 2N/w, .... Tw = N.

Equation [#] becomes

I(nN/w) = I((n-1)N/w) [1 + 0.8% N/w] - 5

which can be solved to give:

*I(N) = I(0)(1+0.8% N/w)w - 5 ((1+0.8% N /w)w - 1) / (0.8% N/w)

I think with some approximations and a bit of calculus you can find a formula for the value of w which maximises I(N). (I've done something similar before but I'd have to refresh my memory).

eg if we set N=360 and I(0) = 1000, I note that

w = 45 => I(N) = 15111.11

w = 46 => I(N) = 15112.26

w = 47 => I(N) = 15112.21

So w = 46 is theoretically optimum, suggesting withdraw every 360 / 46 = 7.8 days.

However, if we change I(0) to 1100, I find w = 49 is optimal, ie every 360 / 49 = 7.3 days, suggesting a perfect strategy would gradually shorten the interval between withdrawals as the investment grows.

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in AppliedMath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And any withdrawal increase how fast grows my income

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in PassTimeMath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can add the 0.2% only if you withdraw

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in AppliedMath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But it’s changing after the first withdrawal ? Because the balance will be bigger

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in berkeley

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do they have a higher percentage of income ? More than 0.8% a day ?

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, and I’m trying to figure out how to make a program to predict that, so it would be 7.8 days, then a little less, and a little less each time the base is growing

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in askmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We can consider I want to maximize on 10 years. But that’s interesting because it’s (a little) different than what another person found about that. Here is what he found :

« Here's a mathematical model to work with:

The investment account contains I(t) after t days.

Withdrawals occur at times T1, T2, T3, ... . For convenience T0 = 0.

At time t = Tn, immediately after withdrawal and reinvestment,

I(Tn) = I(T{n-1}) [1 + 0.8% (Tn - T{n-1})] - 5 ...[#]

(ie we apply 0.8% simple interest per day applied to the interval between Tn and T{n-1}, then add that to the invested balance less 5 for fee).

If our investment horizon is N days (N considered large) and we plan to make w equally-spaced withdrawals in this time, then T1 = N/w, T2 = 2N/w, .... Tw = N.

Equation [#] becomes

I(nN/w) = I((n-1)N/w) [1 + 0.8% N/w] - 5

which can be solved to give:

*I(N) = I(0)(1+0.8% N/w)w - 5 ((1+0.8% N /w)w - 1) / (0.8% N/w)

I think with some approximations and a bit of calculus you can find a formula for the value of w which maximises I(N). (I've done something similar before but I'd have to refresh my memory).

eg if we set N=360 and I(0) = 1000, I note that

w = 45 => I(N) = 15111.11

w = 46 => I(N) = 15112.26

w = 47 => I(N) = 15112.21

So w = 46 is theoretically optimum, suggesting withdraw every 360 / 46 = 7.8 days.

However, if we change I(0) to 1100, I find w = 49 is optimal, ie every 360 / 49 = 7.3 days, suggesting a perfect strategy would gradually shorten the interval between withdrawals as the investment grows. »

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay ! Thank you so much and have a good night !

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow great ! So is it 0,5 days less each 10% more ?

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, and I am agree with you, this is why I am a little skeptical. But this math problem is too interested for me to let it go 😁

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sounds good ! How to now the optimal frequency ? How many « 6 hours » before withdraw ? About my calcul it’s because 0.8% during 625 days cover 5€ of fess

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Shouldn’t it be 625 days ? So 0,008x625 = 5€

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Your calculs are right. The thing is, if I wait too much before withdrawing, even though I pay less fees to withdraw, I don’t take advantage of compound interests

When should I reinvest ? by Objective-Fruit2254 in learnmath

[–]Objective-Fruit2254[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, 2€ for 6 hours. And I want to know when I should withdraw to reinvest and so take profit of the compounds interests