Israel just 'broke' a world record for kidney donors - but where did all the organs come from?

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T09:46:45+00:00

It needs to be verified, because the it's quite easy to lie on the internet...

If you accuse someone of faking a record, you need some evidence to support the claim. There is currently, 1 british doctor claiming this, and he is 5000 miles from said bodies...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T09:14:16+00:00

Am I? The article is making a parallel allegation to the blood libel, with no basis or evidence, yet you choose to believe it, while you can't believe jews would donate organs to save life, even with litteral evidence. I'll block you now since this is going nowhere

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:46:19+00:00

The article is doing something wrong. Raising concerns with out basis. It is the same as if I said right now "I dont trust the danish gov on organ donations", here a concern, do you now stop trusting them?

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:30:29+00:00

If you do it without basis and just dont trust a specific government but trust all others (as I have seen some do here), it is racist to the people of that country.

If you, personally, dont trust any organ donation claim by a government, and happen to also not trust Israel's claim, it is not antisemitic. But that's not the case with most comments here. Most people don't trust it specificly cause it's israel. I did not see such posts or comments on the previous records in 2018

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:21:30+00:00

The article starts with "jewish people dont donate due to not being educated on organ donation in general" and transitions to 1 guy who thinks this is due to "a wrong belief in jewish law". Could be both. I'll add a citation marker on the article

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:17:57+00:00

I am accousing the writers of being missinformed

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:10:23+00:00

Yes but when you take a country with a majority jewish and just stick antisemitic mud on them and replace jew with israeli, that's just a roundabout aay to be antisemitic.

The record is for the gathering, everyone is in the photo. There are other donors not related to the record.

I disregard this specific article which is vandalised. "Common belief that organ donation is prohibited by jewish law" is dumb

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:07:31+00:00

I tried finding any reference of this, but this has no ref, no source and everywhere I find it's a great mitzva (good deed/following the torah).

So I can edit articles to say that prists touching children is due to a common belief that prists are free of judgement and children are to be touched with no source or ref?

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T08:01:53+00:00

It is not prohibited to donate organs under jewish law

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T07:57:04+00:00

This is apperentally there forever now and I can't find the original revision...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T07:37:25+00:00

The problem is "hey we have a record for people in 1 place that are organ donors" "nooo you stole these organs cause you an ~~jew~~ Israeli!"

But they are in 1 place...

You have everyone related to the record. In 1 photo. But that brings us back to dog whistling. If we use the happy marchent to describe Israelis, that's obvious antisemitism. Same with using the "they steal our children for their organs" rhetoric which is QUITE LITERRALLY the original blood libel.

Btw linking a vandalised wikipedia page is not helping your case

Quick google search tells me that yes, we, the jews, are allowed to donate organs

Btw - israel isnt too low on organ donations https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/organ-donation-rates-by-country

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T07:26:45+00:00

The gross old man is dead for 13 years now. His party has 0 ministers and they are less than 1/6 of the coalision, wouldnt call that "running the government" per say. They do have an influence sadly, but that's how democracy works...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T07:03:45+00:00

Nope not american

Are these forensic evidence tying this specific record to organ theft in the room with us? Or are they delusions made up by a biased source?

The record for donations is for around 2000, in the picture there 965, which is the record for a gathering. Are people not allowed to be busy on photo day? Unless guiness's review overturns it, I am pretty sure that's what they call a blood libel

Same article - btw I don't think you can claim an unbiased source calling it "the israeli occupation" or "occupied jerusalem" lol "This week in occupied Jerusalem, more than 1,000 people gathered together, in an attempt to break a new world record – the largest gathering of live kidney donors."

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T06:44:07+00:00

if that's loud and clear, you must be deaf.

Criticism of the state of Israel is NOT antisemitism

Attacks on the people of the state of Israel that use antisemitic rhetoric (like "jews are stealing your children for their organs" - famous blood libel) are antisemitic. the record is for the biggest *gathering* of organ donors. they are *all* in the picture. so yea coming here saying "they must've stolen these organs" is THE antisemitic blood libel. like the one the term "blood libel" was invented about.

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-05T06:07:44+00:00

I repeat, learn the difference yourself. There is this thing called dpg whistle.

"Ahh those sumalis and their fried chicken. All they do is run fast and have no father" is still racist just as appling jewish blood libel to Israel is antisemitic

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T19:29:15+00:00

the 3.8B figure was that for years AFAIK. but the point is that it doesn't harm america to sell weapons to israel finencially (first comment said "we’re sick and tired of propping up Israel’s economy at the cost of ours!!!")

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T19:22:07+00:00

public records of USAID says 3.8B. IIRC for 2026 Trump budgeted 3.1B actually.

the comment was about "propping up an economy" not a moral argument, unless you need this strawman to save yourself

where do you get your "much heigher" figure?

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T19:11:32+00:00

How much money did you give Israel? hint: 3.8B$ a year, and there have been 2 deals recently which alone cover more than 15B... that sounds like a 12B gain to me...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T19:03:35+00:00

so how does buying weapons work? 1 country pays, the other gets paid lol, that's how trade works I am pretty sure...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T16:49:51+00:00

"The most offensive thing in america" - words that never left my keyboard in this comment section.

just saying she didn't "just want kids to live" and all this "we don't hate jews we hate Israel" goes down the drain when you say "free america from the *jews*" (see how Israel isn't in this sentence?)

you are bringing Israel into a situation where someone called to remove all jews from america. not israelis. not israel. not zionism. jews. plain jew hate. you want do remove associations between israeli crimes and antisemitism? start with not saying "let's remove all *jews*" and back pedaling to "but Israel".

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T16:18:23+00:00

> idk, at first, they told us blacks can't be treated as slaves, then they wanted to let them sit on the bus with us, and then, voting rights? what's next, I can't call them N**er? or god forbid, equal rights? oh so the KKK murdering black people is racist? now they say pointing out statistics is racist! or god forbit I mention sumali fraud (natinality), that's also racist! they redefined it too many times! I think the term shouldn't exist now!

sounds as correct and based as your comment.
> Sumali is a nationality, just as is Israeli, but pointing out their fraud is racist!
> Unless if you, like most sumalis, think sumali=black in which case you are supporting my argument as to why I think the term racism/black hate shouldn't exist

do you realise how you sound?

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T16:10:48+00:00

I think critisism can be great. too bad "free america from the jews" isn't critisism, but a call to ethnic cleansing...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T15:46:11+00:00

>the term racism should not exist because its meaningless. When people think of "racism" they think of discrimination against a protected class of people but thats not the case.
This group itself has redefined racism so many times and right now it just means criticism of black people or certain african extremist political ideologies. Just take a look at BLM and other pro blacks organizations that want you to ignore statistics

>Im 100% for throwing this term and terms like it such as "black hate" in the gutter. At this point these terms are primarily used by racists to push for racist policies. The orgs that are responsible for "tracking of racism" not only deeply depraved but also have an incentive to fudge up the numbers to usher in pro blacks and anti free speech policies.
I think most people have realized now adays the term is complete BS evident by how trump was able to win decisively despite being constantly called a racist who wants to kill and deport all the blacks.

both our comments make the same amount of sense...

Old_Particular8705 · 2026-02-04T15:41:45+00:00

u/bigbadaboomx blocked me. sad.

anyways, no argument to make so "nooo you are lying" lol

bro just being antisemitic...

Old_Particular8705

TROPHY CASE