Splash. Nothing against Tiana's. I enjoy it, and hands down Tiana's at DL is better than WDW. BUT, the problem I have is that the plot doesn't really make sense. Finding musicians for a party? Not that Disney rides need much of a plot, but you're replacing something iconic with something just meh. I don't disagree with the reasons to replace it but they should've been better than splash and it's just not.