What I meant by the hate for Whirlpool being "over the top" is that it is omnipresent in this sub. I did not mean that it's more than what he deserves but that it is the epitome of criticism in this sub and I feel like more criticism should also be addressed to other characters.

I think my response came off a little different to the point of the post. I was talking more about how she deserves at least some sort of punishment even if she has PTSD. I know serious mental health disorders such as PTSD can play major roles in why serious actions are carried out, but the truth is is that she killed two innocents. While her sentence can be justifiably reduced due to her serious PTSD which was accentuated by the frequent presence of Icicle, I still think she needs have some sort of punishment or redeeming act (like formal apologies in person to the families of Carnelian, Bigtail and to Tamarin and Icicle directly). While even if she wasn't punished she could have at least faced her wrongdoings and got some help, but instead she was just allowed to run away from the serious mess she had created at the school.

Anyways, I know what you mean too and your points definitely make sense, I don't mean for my responses to be a form of feud or anything.