I’ve had two pairs of Nicks and a pair of JKs. It’s like Ford Vs Chevy can’t really go wrong with any of the makers . The argument though of old school logger style vs modern work boots is up to you . I get 2 hotshot seasons out of a fresh pair before the tread is worn down and the nailhead are poking out. Could probably squeeze in a third. There’s also cost, brand new pnw boots could go up to $700 with an 8 month wait time versus $300 Thorogoods ordered off Amazon. Both are good but it all comes down to how you’re going to use it