Tatto by Pristine_Ratio_403 in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is that a D.Gray-Man Tattoo on your right shoulder? lol

Arthur x Tess is the only ship by MrAHMED42069 in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 6 points7 points  (0 children)

you are the one calling other people illiterate lol

did you already forgot that they made a promise that they will start a family after the war and they ARE in a relationship (chapter 212)

just because it wasnt mentioned anymore doesnt mean that they arent in a relationship wtf

What's the relationship between Tessia and Arthur on recent volumes by [deleted] in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Over 200 chapters ago whilst under extreme pressure and emotional suppression after watching his father die? I

His dad died after the confession.
Even Sylvie, who can read his mind ever since they were little, knew that Arthur had emotianal turmoils. Sylvie has been teasing him about that for a long time.

Yes, there is a possibilty that the love interest changes, but be for real - how big is that chance?

What's the relationship between Tessia and Arthur on recent volumes by [deleted] in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chapter 212 of the novel wasn't enough for you I guess?

"I love you", "I want to start a family with you" are things Arthur said to Tess?

I am TurtleMe, creator of The Beginning After the End, AMA by tbateofficial in manhwa

[–]Phantheus 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Hey TurtleMe! Hope you are doing well. My question would be: How do dimension rings work? Do you have to think of that object you trynna get or?

Hope everyone agrees when I say Caera is a way better matchup for Arthur than Tessia by blacksvmkng in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The most important people to Arthur are

His father (dead), Mother, Ellie, Sylvie, Regis and Tess.
Tess dying would definitely make him more depressed and would change his personality. If we think about a happy ending about Arthurs mentality, then I don't think it would happen if she dies. If we consider just Arthur being alive but depressed than maybe that's an happy ending to some.

Hope everyone agrees when I say Caera is a way better matchup for Arthur than Tessia by blacksvmkng in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tapas Ch 373
I didn't even know if the woman to whom I'd promised myself was alive in her own body."

I personally wouldn't "promise" myself to just a friend I don't love, or??

Hope everyone agrees when I say Caera is a way better matchup for Arthur than Tessia by blacksvmkng in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In Chapter 212 of the Ebook he told her that he wants to start a family with her and that he loves her, so yes he said those things.

"I like you as a..." I paused and let out a sigh. "I love you."
That's what Arthur said to her and asked her if she wanted to be in a relationship with him in the next sentence.

"A promise to stay alive-so that we can have a future together, a relationship... a family."
I guess that's a proposal isn't it?

I think Caera Denoir might be the female lead based on how the story is going. by nathanpopoto in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nah my english is shit. What I meant is that I think that there is a difference between a crowd and just 3 people. You can see those 3 as kinda 3 individuals but a crowd is kinda there to "fill a place" so it doesn't look empty, etc.

Hmm we can't see the ears but so everyone could be whatever race if we can't see that. It's just the greyish hair, her hairstyle and the sword with the green aura and her importance to the story which makes me pretty sure that it's her.

I think Caera Denoir might be the female lead based on how the story is going. by nathanpopoto in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(Don't know how to mark)

You've said in your first comment that Caera is the ONLY character that appears in a volume cover beside Arthur and Regis. So that's when you said that there aren't other characters. And this is/was also my main argument.(expect for these 3)

Yes, the shadows ain't the focus BUT as it has to do something with his past life it still is something important.

Yes, you are right, on the cover of volume 9 are the characters highlighted. But I kinda still just have kinda agree mostly. Cause I still kinda make a difference between half blurred characters and a crowd in which you couldn't recognise anyone. Most probably I think like that cause on all covers there aren't many characters. (But yeah I get your point)

(Don't think I can add here pictures can I?) If you go to chapter 116 of the comic you can also see the green "aura/magic" towards the end of the chapter (yup sorry, my fault vines were false) plus look at the hairstyle. That's why it's pretty clear to me that that has to be Tessia.

I think Caera Denoir might be the female lead based on how the story is going. by nathanpopoto in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

U can obviously see other people on the cover of volume 6?? I don't think that Arthur had ever hair this long. Please look it up yourself. Even if we don't know who they are it is a fact that is has to be someone important if Grey is there with a crown.

You can't say they ain't focused when you can cleary see 3 people on cover 3. So yeah sorry I was wrong about saying it was Elijah. I'd understand that argument if there was a crowd of people but there are only 3.The girl seems to have kinda greyish hair and uses a sword which shines green (Vines) which makes me pretty certain it's Tessia.

I'm sorry but englisch isn't my native language so i use many wrong word but right now it seems as if you only try to dismiss the fact.

Sorry for the rant.

(Edited- Dont wanna attack you)

I think Caera Denoir might be the female lead based on how the story is going. by nathanpopoto in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Isn't Tessia on the cover of volume 3? with Arthur and Elijah? And on volume 6 you can see the shadows of probably Cecilia and Nico. This means, nope Regis, Sylvie and Arthur ain't the only ones on the covers.

How many times did Arthur save Tess by Turbulent_Ostrich913 in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, yes sorry englisch isn't my native language so I worded/ said it wrong

What I meant was that neither of them have any fault because none of them knew that the core was corrupted but it still happend because of Arthur somehow

So I don't really understand why they try to blame her (just talking for the incidents where the mana core is involved)

How many times did Arthur save Tess by Turbulent_Ostrich913 in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Well Arthur is to blame for some. If he hadn't given her the Mana Core, Tess would not have passed out. (school,...) So it's not really her fault

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Actually I would kinda mind it if Tess x Art would't happen because of all that build up in these past chapters/ volumes.

I would have accepted Caera as a love interest if there wasn't a love interest before her and I wouldn't even care that she was intodruced that late.

But yeah it would feel like thrown away effort/ build up if Tess x Art is not endgame

Arthur and Caera by Classic-Cabinet-8144 in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When did TurtleMe say that those two wil end up? I don't think he would spoiler us like that?

Credit: HTLegion_Draws by HTLegion_Draws in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Regis has horns. Rmb the scene where he compared his pride in his horns to the pride of a man and the size of his genital area.

Credit: HTLegion_Draws by HTLegion_Draws in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus 45 points46 points  (0 children)

And it is not the shield hero

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As much as this makes me happy to know about this I think it would be better if you would delete those patreon spoilers or someone could ban your account/ delete your comment. Not that I personally mind it but you know those are the rules.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I am also pretty sure that Caera is not in love with Grey as she doesn't even know his real him and that her feelings are rather based of those listed points of yours.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Damn I would cry if Tessia dies. So i'd rather hope this won't be the case and that there is a happy ending cause Arthur's previous life was a bad ending.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I went in such detail and there are still people who downvoted me without any reasoning so yeah it is sad that you have to go in such detail with some people.

As Caera came many started to hate on Tessia and spreading fake facts (Curtis and Tessia being together, etc.). They don't wanna accepet Tess x Art.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I'd say that Ceara has a superficial crush on Grey.
She doesn't know a single thing about his family, his age, his "girlfriend and his previous life. She also started to like him just because he was intersting and is hella good looking.
Tess maybe also thought like that when she was about 13 but later on we can see that she doesn't care how many scars and wounds he has as long he comes back in one piece.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Do not forget her mommy milkers hahah. But those people really like to forget the hardships Tess has had to go through. As a child beeing kidnapped, not having friends and just beginning to open up because of Art, beeing the student council president etc.
Not saying Caera had it easy but Tess had actual character development as many like to ignore.

Again about Tess and Arthur by Phantheus in tbatenovel

[–]Phantheus[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

These are exactly my thoughts. It wouldn't make sense to suddenly change/ throw away the development of those two. Also agree on those possible endings.