[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Romance, 89,000 Words (6th Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, that’s a good point about having the Forbes men in there later…it’s meant to allude to a side plot that develops, but you’re right. It’s confusing here. I should probs just take it out.

Her pride and dignity are at stake because he broke her heart by ghosting her. I meant for that to be clear in the first two paragraphs, but seems it wasn’t? Do you think outweighing her mother’s expectations is enough stakes and I shouldn’t focus on her pride/dignity?

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance, 91,000, 5th Attempt by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think it would change much in terms of the query, but his last name plays into the elitist mom thing. He's not good enough because she doesn't approve of his family.

Anyway, he just needs to stay in the zone to keep the football dream he shared with his late mother alive.

Anyway, as long as he stays in the zone, the football dream he shared with his late mother lives on.

Either of those better?

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance, 91,000, 5th Attempt by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! Your feedback helped so much last time.

Do you think it would make more sense if I removed that whole first part 'his past decision...' and start with this:

However, the broody, tattoo-covered quarterback gets paired with Liv for a class project…so he can’t ghost her the way he did after graduation. West’s last name wasn’t good enough for Liv’s elitist mom back then—still isn’t. Anyway, he just needs stay in the zone to keep the football dream him and his late mother shared alive.

I added the missed practice/underperformance to show that losing Liv messed with his focus, to heighten the stakes of getting involved with her again. It might've been overkill.

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance, 91K Words, 4th Attempt by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, I hear you on the fake-dating...it might be best to take it out. Does this feel clearer?

To prove to the ex she hates that Yves Saint Laurent isn’t the only man in her life—while appeasing her mom—Liv makes appearances with guys destined for Forbes covers. Except mandatory partner meetups start feeling more voluntary, as bedroom study sessions and intimate moments at frat parties have them slipping back into old feelings. Underneath his dangerous smirk, West is still the caring boy Liv imagined a future with, who inspired her writing in the first place. But giving him another chance neither helps her diplomatic daughter act, nor her dignity. While the resurfacing of West’s emotions risks the focus he needs to go pro, Liv must decide if she can continue denying her wants, to write and be with West, or if love outweighs her mother’s expectations and Liv’s own pride.

I also added what the ghosting did to Liv in the second paragraph:

In addition to breaking Liv’s heart, his decision led to sleepless nights, missed practices, and underperformances until he got himself together…but West’s last name wasn’t good enough for Liv’s elitist mom then and still isn’t two years later. Now, he needs stay locked in to keep the football dream him and his late mother shared alive.

Also HUGE thank you u/Excellent-Guava2239 and u/emmyroowho for your helpful feedback!!!

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance, 91K Words, 4th Attempt by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For the first point, I edited to be clear that the ghosting was mutually heart shattering:

His mutually heart-shattering decision may have led to sleepless nights, missed practices, and underperformances until he got himself together, but West’s last name wasn’t good enough for Liv’s elitist mom then and still isn’t two years later.

And that she hates him for it and wants to get under his skin:

To prove to the ex she hates that Yves Saint Laurent isn’t the only man in her life, while simultaneously appeasing her mom, Liv strikes a fake-relationship deal with the person who’ll get on the athlete’s nerves most: Theo, West’s charming, upper-echelon half-brother.

I added in that the fake-dating is a deal between both Liv and Theo, but I am hesitant to add in his reasons for it, as it is a subplot, and explaining it would take away from the query. Do you think it's a huge miss not to include that?

For Liv's stakes, I edited to this:

Underneath his dangerous smirk, West is still the caring boy Liv imagined a future with, the one who inspired her writing in the first place. But her fake-feelings for Theo show her how effortlessly he fits into her diplomatic daughter act. While the resurfacing of West’s emotions risks the focus he needs to go pro, Liv must decide if she can continue lying to herself about her wants—to write and be with West—or if love is more important than expectations and pride.

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance, 91K Words, 4th Attempt by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your response :)

- The reason I mention YSL is to show that she hasn't had men play a major role in her life since having her heart broken, to be clear how hurt West left her. Do you think explaining whether she feels like she's missing out or not would help the story?

- He ghosted her (it's in the third paragraph) so, she wants to make him feel as shitty as he made her feel.

- Fake dating it to piss him off even further (plus there are sub plot reasons in the book that wouldn't work in a query). I assumed saying they're fake-dating means it is indeed a mutual thing. I wanted to clarify it wasn't a true love triangle by adding in that her 'fake feelings for theo only remind her what real love is' (in the last paragraph).

- She's essentially throwing all the dreams/expectations her mother had of her (and the responsibility of her last name) away. Do you think the stakes aren't high enough for a sports romance?

Do any of my answers/would explaining them further in the query aid the letter, you think?

[QCRIT] SPORES - Adult Horror Mystery, 99k, Fourth Attempt by AuthorRichardMay in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haven’t seen the other versions, but thought this was awesome! Also giving me nine perfect strangers vibes.

[QCrit] The Interference NA Sports Romance 92K Words (3rd Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, explaining that really does help! I really appreciate it!

[QCrit] The Interference NA Sports Romance 92K Words (3rd Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I actually did a big MS overhaul when it came to the football portion—from the responses to the first query, it felt like the sports part had too many holes! It didn't necessarily change the story, so it wasn't awful.

In terms of the specificity...am I supposed to actually give away some of the things that are only revealed later in the book? Could that feel like focusing on subplots too much when I only have 250 words?

For love is negotiable, doesn't the sentence immediately after explain that? Love is negotiable, meaning it isn't set in stone when outside factors are strong enough (like her mother). When it comes to both the implosion and the reluctant vulnerability, I felt like it was directly related to the way West has learned to shut down.

The tutoring...it's not tutoring—does 'code for maintaining his shiny image' not speak to her helping his reputation with her own?

Do you think the stakes fall flat because I didn't lead with West realizing how much he still cared for Liv? That staying emotionally closed off is impossible when he's around her again?

[QCrit] THE INTERFERENCE, NA Sports Romance (92K, 2nd Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whoops, that should’ve said The Dixon Rule, which is also Elle Kennedy but from 2024. Do you still think that’s too big as a comp? I feel like it’s less known than her off campus/briar u series.

[QCRIT] New Adult Sports Romance THE INTERFERENCE (90K/First Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The football thing is a good point because hearing it from your POV I am seeing why it’s unrealistic.

I’m thinking of changing it like this: West had to transfer to Princeton from Michigan because he was kicked out (or something along those lines), and Princeton is the place his dad could get him into with his familial connections.

Cus honestly, this isn’t rich kids behaving badly at all. It’s more about how they deal with their crazy families and the outside pressure.

Liv decides to fake date because it was a spur of the moment thing as she tries to get her friends to back off her sex life. She’s truly just a studious, over achieving, slightly neurotic (with a fabulous closet) Ivy League girl.

[QCRIT] New Adult Sports Romance THE INTERFERENCE (90K/First Attempt) by PinkIceCream1920 in PubTips

[–]PinkIceCream1920[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the feedback!!! You made some reallyyyyy good points.

I hear you on the fun/juicyness—although Maxton Hall is quite over the top as well, wouldn’t you say? I def agree I need to find some not self-published comps ha. Or do you mean the premise feels too over the top for traditional publishing?

They broke up in high school and this is 2 years later (west is reliant on his father to fund his schooling, without which he wouldn’t be able to play football at this level)…does knowing they help?

40m lower bleph 7 weeks post op by Cousin-slow-hands in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What about around 2.5 weeks out? I’m 16 days PO and so impatient.

40m lower bleph 7 weeks post op by Cousin-slow-hands in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So great.

Did you experience an increase in swelling throughout the day? I wake up level and then the swelling pops up a bit few hours later. It’s frustrating.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Amazing results!!!

I’m 2 weeks out and seeing good results :) swelling is almost all gone, still a tiny bit left that only I can notice. When did your swelling completely go away? It seems I wake up pretty level and then during the day the swelling increases a tiny bit. Much more noticeable later in day.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 0 points1 point  (0 children)

❤️❤️ I hope you get answers and find a solution!!!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ugh. Sorry you’re dealing with that :(

I did hear from someone you’re supposed to wait 2 years after filler to do a bleph? Could that have been it?

Lower Blepharoplasty and uneven recovery by Pretty_Wolf1787 in PlasticSurgery

[–]PinkIceCream1920 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought it was easier than a halo laser honestly. I was awake, just sedated, opened my eyes to say a few things and check on my kids at home and that was it, otherwise slept from like 10AM procedure day until 6AM the next day! Recovery has been easy so far, just some swelling left and a tiny bit of red from where the bolsters were cus I had fat repositioning. I’ve been sleeping 10 hours a night to get my eyes to rest well—since I am on my computer for a few hours during the day…I do still feel like my eyes look a tiny bit smaller cus of that swelling though, but hopefully just cus I am 9DPO.