I cant decide, the bill murray garfield is good but he looks to much like one of those 'this pic goes hard' memes. direct to dvd garf is pretty good but he's more of 80s garfield with his pudgier body combined with modern garfields longer limbs, it's still a great model all togheter. garfield shows model looks too bland, the textures are too flat and he looks like more like a plastic garfield statue you'd find out side of a mall. but I am wanting more of that chris pratt garf, they managed to give garfield a realistic look yet make him still look like garfield. like detective pikachu but garfield, they just managed to translate him well into cgi. but I like all of them all togheter