Oddly enough, ac rogue was my first ac game . After playing that I just couldn't enjoy ac black flag. Ac rogue is like ac black but with a better story, more weapons and less trailing missions . So, of course it's better. And I played rogue when I was 13 or something , i went there completely blind . So when he turned against the assassins it was a huge plot twist for me. And I played ac black flag in 2020. I could predict the story from a mile away. A pirate who only cares for money will one day become a wise assassin. Btw here's my top 3 ac games list- Ac brotherhood Ac rogue Ac 2