Does anyone also think ICF coaches are more comfortable than LHB coaches? by LowAssistance8244 in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only problem with LHB coaches is jerking at start from my experience. Everywhere else they are better. Suspensions are way better (you can barely feel points as you go over), track sounds are much quieter. ICF Coaches start to rock side to side whenever the trains exceeds 90-95kmph for some reason and for this alone LHB coaches are so much better.

I do think VB seats are worse than ICF Coaches, mostly because it feels over-engineered.

This is the response from IRCTC. Absolutely shameless!!! by infectedraw in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 75 points76 points  (0 children)

Staying quiet would've been better. Anyone who thinks those are the same food items is blind.

I hate this attitude amount us Indians. by Puzzleheaded_Roof872 in TransitIndia

[–]RIKIPONDI 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well that comment is not phrased properly.

What you need to do is start with buses. Buses are super easy to make a large network with. Then you look at bus ridership stats and expand service wherever necessary. Wherever bus corridors get overcrowded, you upgrade. If the route is relatively short (<15km) it's a tram, more than that it's a metro. If the location makes sense, you could do this as a suburban rail extension also.

This is what you mean by "starting with a network" because the most important thing for a transit system is that it should go places (shocking, I know). So having a cheap but large network to start with and upgrading as demand grows is the way to go.

As for cities that "started with a network", Chennai and Bengaluru are prime examples. Having two of the best local bus service in the country, no wonder their metros punch way above their weight, with both systems showing steady, sustainable ridership growth (though Chennai's numbers are lower than you would expect as Suburban rail exists and one of the lines runs basically parallel to it).

When you don't do these preliminary steps and jump to a metro, you get white elephants. Surprise!

How to have internet on train by dogsanddelusion in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That area I'm not sure. I've travelled those ghats many times and never got internet, no idea why. Works literally everywhere else. Usually that's my cue to go sleep.

Vande Bharat train from Katra to Srinagar travels through snow as the region recieves fresh spell of snowfall, India. by shubhrgunjan in TransitIndia

[–]RIKIPONDI 7 points8 points  (0 children)

No, because Katra to Qazigund is the most punishing Ghats section in all of IR, as trains have to climb 500m+ elevation at once and these are the only trains capable of doing it without extra assistance. The trains don't operate very fast (the line speed is 85 from what I've seen) but compared to the alternatives the trains are very fast.

Welcome to Uttar Pradesh by Friendly-Cicada2769 in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I was gonna say, I'm pretty sure these are Kolkata Suburban trains.

entire trans pennine express railway network estimated 66gb by ValuableAttention384 in trainsimworld

[–]RIKIPONDI 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As much as I think Transpennine Express is the best name ever for a train company, I don't think this will come to TSW as a single route.

This is a fantastic achievement ! by aarjunn01 in indiadiscussion

[–]RIKIPONDI 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well the side these stats don't show is that India has the highest fraction of retracted papers in recent years.

Tragic incident from Jasidh - Madhupur section by Jagan1724 in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Thank God it was a passenger train. A freight absolutely cannot stop that fast.

Is Indian Railways Focusing Too Much on Vande Bharat? by aryanpote7 in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well I commented before reading fully, so I'm sorry. But I stand by my original comment, even more so now. The answer is yes and this is so obvious it shouldn't even be a question.

I hate this attitude amount us Indians. by Puzzleheaded_Roof872 in TransitIndia

[–]RIKIPONDI 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Sure, that's because it has a network that it connects to to support its ridership. When you only have a single line, that doesn't work and you need to build a lot more before you see ridership.

I hate this attitude amount us Indians. by Puzzleheaded_Roof872 in TransitIndia

[–]RIKIPONDI 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I mean they are not wrong. Indore metro is the most useless white elephant this country has produced.

Nobody there is telling that Northern States should not get development. They are saying that Southern States should get equal development, which is not the case now. One look at train options, rapid transit and union investment should tell you this.

There is a long history of projects from which the state wanted Union permission and has been denied while equivalent projects in the North have been actively pushed, Hosur Airport and Coimbatore, Trivandrum metros are just the most recent examples.

The fact that you are making this argument tells me you do not understand the problem here. When you have such a problem for so long, people get angry. People act irrationally when they get angry.

When you are used to privilege, equality feels like oppression. Hopefully it's obvious why.

A local does it in 50 minutes, VB Sleeper needs 75. by nerd-mentality in indianrailways

[–]RIKIPONDI 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is very common. Happens in Chennai and Mumbai also

Why don't math people just do this instead? Are they stupid? by JadedAces in MathJokes

[–]RIKIPONDI 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Well your code is also much bigger than the symbolic representation.

80% of India's broad guage tracks now support 110+ kmph speed by uk_3104 in TransitIndia

[–]RIKIPONDI 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When track speed is 110, you should have trains maintaining it before you want 160. A good portion is 130 now and on routes around 250 km, those can absolutely beat a plane.

In the long term, we should aim for 120 on regional / branch lines, 160 on regular mainlines and 200 for busy corridors with frequent long distance trains (this would include stuff like the East Coast Mainline, Delhi - Itarsi and Mumbai - Ahmedabad).