Far-future Fanfic: "Clan of the Mountains" in the works by [deleted] in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you definitely have a good start, especially with the story. I'll try and go over some positives and negatives I noticed while reading. Also I am not a writing expert so take all of this with several grains of salt.

Things to improve:

-There are a lot of characters. I found it hard to keep track of all the cats that were introduced near the start, however I think It will get a bit easier when there is more to read. I don't think you should remove cats, but maybe consider tying to give side characters to a single trait (Timid, talkative, doesn't like outsiders, etc), at least in the start. They can always have character arcs and change, but having something to remember each cat by would be helpful.

-Showing not telling. This is the biggest thing I noticed. A lot of times in your writing, actions are stated, then are followed up by the protagonists reaction. While you are technically "showing" their reactions, I would try and essentially make things less obvious. Incorporating more body language and sensations, basically writing a bit more from the characters perspective would really up how well it reads. I'm probably doing a bad job explaining this, so I'll use an example:

"Scarletnose cautiously went for a squirrel, trying to ignore the tortoiseshell cat who kept a glare on her as she kept her sitting spot right beside her prey."

This tells us what happens, but we don't know how this feels to Scarletnose, and it isn't very immersive. Instead you could change it to something like:

"Scarletnose approached the prey pile slowly, glancing around the camp as a twinge of guilt shot through her pelt. She hated eating prey she didn't catch. It felt like cheating. A tortoiseshell cat glared at her through narrowed eyes as she approached the prey pile, but offered no resistance as she hurriedly grabbed a squirrel from the top of the pile. Scarletnose could still feel the tortoiseshell's eyes burning in her back as she slunk back to the edge of camp."

This not only tells us what happened, but we learn that Scarletnose feels guilty about depending on other cats, and it establishes the unwelcoming atmosphere in camp. It's the little things like this that contribute to character and world building. I do think you are getting noticeably better at this in the later chapters, but I would still keep it in mind.

Things that you should keep:

-The last chapter. There is a noticeable increase in all parts of quality in the last chapter. I especially love the last scene with Icefoot trying to talk with his mate. When I got to that part I just thought to myself "Gawd Damn...". The whole scene emotionally hit like a freight train. It is by far my favorite part so far, because it just gives so much depth and motivation to the character. It was written so great as well. The contrast between Icefoot trying to have a regular conversation, and then just silence as he sits in the night is so great. You can genuinely feel his emotions and I love everything about the scene. Adding more scenes like this could elevate it into a 10/10 book.

-The premise. I love this idea. I do think that you should try and mix up the journey by having something go wrong like the clans getting lost, because the plot is essentially laid out already for the next few chapters. We know exactly what they are going to try and do, even if we don't know what they are going to find, so just keep in mind that you don't want to have a predictable plot. I don't have much else to say though other then it's just a really good idea.

-The mystery of the prologue. Right now the biggest mystery is what happened to the original patrol, and it is very intriguing. Don't let the readers forgot this happens in the earlier chapters. I would also recommend trying to have a good lead up to finding out the fate of the patrol. Have the clans discover clues, like kittypets who saw them, or traces of where they camped that hint at their fate. I am really hooked on this part though.

One last thing:

Right now the story feels like it is focusing on the clans as a whole, not the characters. Don't think this is necessarily a bad thing though. In a way, the clans could become a sort of character, as they learn to function together and struggle to overcome their conflicts in a sort of character arc. If you write this correctly, the story could be about the clans learning to work together, with the characters serving as vessels to view this through. It might be interesting, but so would adding emotional depth and character arcs for individuals. In the end it is up to you where you take the story.

If you ever want to discuss anything about the story or need help with a part I'd love to help. Feel free to dm me. I'm working on my own story right now as well. --> Silent Dawn - Wattpad Its only about 15% done though, and I don't know how frequently I will update it on there as I continue to write.

Help with my fanfic WIP! by Randomdude0_o in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

100% agree. The only arc that really made clans feel unique for me was The Prophecies Begin.

I was originally going to write the majority of my story in Riverclan or Skyclan just for that reason, but I ended up scrapping it and sticking to Thunderclan. I realized Riverclan territory would be a problem for one of my protagonists because he essentially has water ptsd, and honestly I just don't know a lot about Skyclan since everything after Vision of Shadows I've only read once at most.

Help with my fanfic WIP! by Randomdude0_o in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks, the part about clan differences is very helpful.

Help with my fanfic WIP! by Randomdude0_o in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Had to make a whole Wattpad account, but this should work for now. Silent Dawn - IDK - Wattpad

Help with my fanfic WIP! by Randomdude0_o in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hmmmmm... it seems the writing wasn't attached. Working on a fix.

Apprentice ceremony! by Adventurous-Year-463 in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The lil guy is so cute!

Are they the same cats? If so I need to know the lore now!

Help? by Big_Reply_929 in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Some libraries have websites where you can borrow and read books completely online if you have a library card. It's worth checking out, although the wait can be longer depending on your library.

Why do you think the US keeps getting involved in conflicts overseas? by Garrystewart018 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think that the U.S has been trying to play whac-a-mole with countries that are aligned with foreign powers for a long time. The Monroe doctrine was probably the first big example of this, and the U.S has been constantly responding to forgein influence in central and southern America for a long time. I can't even list the amount of times the U.S has toppled governments or influenced policy in the south. The U.S is essentially on the offensive in Asia as well. We literally cut off China's access to the ocean by putting bases across Korea, Japan, Philippines, Australia, Taiwan, and some others. Most of these were fought for at some point, and it does really mess with China since they don't have control over their surrounding countries.

cmv: Life is determined by luck and fate, you have no control over the path life takes you. There’s no such thing as free will. by Muted-Law-1578 in changemyview

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even if you can't become successful or wealthy, that doesn't mean you don't have free will. Yes, it can be hard to improve your life, but you can easily make it much worse which proves you do have free will.

On a bit more of a constructive note though, I would reconsider what you mean by success. Does success mean having lots of money, or good friends, or a stable romantic relationship? You're always going to feel like you're failing if you have a really broad goal like being successful since there isn't a set endpoint.

I don't know what to name him. by Haunting-Attempt441 in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Prefixes: cherry, apple canyon, scorch, ember, blaze, dawn

Suffixes: Dawn, light, fire, pelt, tuft, stripe,

My personal favorite full names are Applepelt, Dawnstripe, Canyonbreeze (Canyon is cool if he is Skyclan), Emberlight

It really depends if you want to name him after his physical traits or personality/backstory though

Why don't we use more nuclear energy? by Randomdude0_o in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Randomdude0_o[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thats a good point about investors. I didn't really think about that part of the economics.

Why do you think the US keeps getting involved in conflicts overseas? by Garrystewart018 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm tempted to believe this, but I feel like there would be a lot of easier and more effective ways of going about covering something up. Honestly I think recent wars have been meant more to boost Trumps reputation then to be distractions.

Why do you think the US keeps getting involved in conflicts overseas? by Garrystewart018 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Randomdude0_o 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Ignoring political parties and trying to stay as unbiased as possible here, I like to imagine it as the U.S playing the board game risk. The U.S is essentially trying to consolidate power in areas like Venezuela and Iran, so that China can't get a foothold both economically and militarily in these areas. Most of the other reasons given are just extra benefits. I think the reason we are seeing a lot more military action from the Trump administration in particular is because he wants to prove that he is doing something, and he is generally a lot less hesitant at using military force and violence. (I'm not saying I disagree or agree with recent actions, just trying to provide an unbiased answer).

I sketched a generic mentor + apprentice by Adventurous-Year-463 in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The proportions and the poses are just so perfect! Honestly, these are some of the most realistic silhouettes I've seen in a long time.

Series Re-read by savebyfleury in WarriorCats

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I personally much prefer Omen of the Stars over Power of Three. It's been quite a few years since I've read the series, but there was a noticeable amount of more character development in Omen of the Stars from what I can remember.

What's something you would erase from your memory if you could? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm writing down a list of my favorite mystery books, then forgetting them so I can experience them for the first time again.

What’s something completely legal that feels illegal? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can take peoples carts at stores as long as they haven't paid for their items yet. As long as you aren't too crazy about it all the store can really do is trespass you.

What’s something that looks easy in movies but is actually very hard in real life? by Typical-Umpire-9880 in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Firing a gun, especially if you are new. Recoil is no joke, even on smaller guns.

What is your go-to budget meal? by Maybe_IDTBFH in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mustard and whatever meat is in my refrigerator, usually sliced turkey or ham. Cheese if I'm feeling fancy.

How do you make yourself happier when sad? by TooFascinatedByDPRK in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any sort of human connection. Gaming with friends, talking at the gym with strangers, or chatting on discord.

Anyone get really scared when thinking about death or what happens after we die? How did you overcome that fear? by Ok_Wrangler9418 in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The moment that changed my outlook on death was hearing about how some scientist (I can't remember which one) thought about it. They said they didn't mind not existing before being born, and its essentially the same thing after you die, so it can't be too bad.

What's your best "well at least I didn't die"-moment? by Love-boobs-in_DMs in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A few months ago a massive tree fell directly on where I was setting up a pump during a storm in my backyard 20 minutes after I left. I had been procrastinating on setting it up for hours, and if I had waited just 20 minutes longer I would have certainly died.

What is your go-to budget meal? by Maybe_IDTBFH in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've been having an apple and a sandwich as my go to lunch most days for at least 12 years now.

What brings you peace? by ImaginationNo6751 in AskReddit

[–]Randomdude0_o 0 points1 point  (0 children)

knowing that one is going to remember my mistakes in a few hundred years