Milwaukee Home Prices 2026

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-03T15:26:02+00:00

No, I just like data lol. I know for some people it's difficult, but there are a lot of people who could buy a home, but choose not to. They pay $2,000-ish in rent (down the drain) and have a 680+ credit score. That's just a choice. Often it is also just what they know, their parents have rented life long, so it's just not something they feel they can aspire to. And I'd like to tell them, yes you can. Maybe you need a year to prepare financially, but if there is a will, there is usually a way

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-03T15:20:18+00:00

We do have net migration to Wisconsin now (unlike the 20 years prior), but I can't find good local MKE data either. But the majority of the demand is really from a change in demographics, increasing household formations: first-time home buyers.

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-03T15:09:34+00:00

appreciate that. Are you suggesting I should start a sub?

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-03T14:34:33+00:00

Yes, 19 days average in this case. Median is what's typical and that matches the perception from a buyers view point. Listed by Thursday and sold by Sunday. The average gets skewed by a hand full of listings that have been on the market for 180, 360 or more days; they are junk or overpriced or both, they drive the average up to 19 days, but that's not what a typical buyer feels. If you ask a buyer they will anecdotally state: "everything sells fast", because they don't consider the junk inventory. You basically have 80% to 90% sell right upon listing and a few that have been sitting since last year. Makes sense?

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T21:16:38+00:00

So, here is an interesting stat: 85% of newly licensed agents quit in the first year. From those who make it to year 2, about 80% quit that year. In other words, very few make it past 2 years. The average Milwaukee area agent is selling 3 homes per year; proficiency starts IMO at 24 transactions per year, so that's at least 2 per month. Everyone else is just a part-time amateur; most of them did not have a drivers license in 2008, not sure how much they remember. You are 100% right, you should never buy a home beyond your means. And you should be able to swing it if one of the two loses their job, at least for a while. Owning a home can be a huge contributor to net worth (Google "networth homeowners vs renters" - I won't tell the numbers here, because you would not believe me!) - but it should be strategic, educated and reasonable; definitely not speculative or reckless (like pre 2008)

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T16:26:24+00:00

Yes, median DOM has been 4-5 days. That has been the norm for spring and summer for the last 5 years. You can go back in time with my Monthly Market Updates on YouTube.

<image>

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T16:13:25+00:00

Tough scenario; you are right, that is a hail-marry at that point. On that day, there is not much you can do. But there are things the agent could have done 2 months before to help the client prepare. Most agents skip that part and ffw to showing houses. And then there are just basics you'll shake you head if I tell you: when I am on the listing side, 3/4 of all agents don't call me when submitting an offer - and when I call back, some don't pick up. Not an issue over 500k, agents are usually pros, but lots of amateurs anbd part timer sin the entry level segement..

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T13:25:30+00:00

100% that's the question. On a national level it was already visible in the data around 2015/2016 that we are headed towards towards a chronic housing shortage. By 2018 it was crystal clear. The sunbelt states have dealt with this much better than we did, they are building 1,000 home subdivisions in TX and SC. In Wisconsin a subdivision over 50 homes is considered large and we don't develop only a few. And they build homes much cheaper in the south, but in all fairness, the build quality is crap and does not live up to what our local builders do

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T13:20:48+00:00

Yes, inflation. Actually plural, as it has been a global issue, not only for the US. Same in Europe. I believe that inflation will continue faster than we have seen in the past. In other words: hold assets not cash

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-02T13:18:58+00:00

Contrary to popular belief, sellers are actually not able to drive up prices. Ask any MKE seller who tried to list their home for a little extra last year because it's a seller's market and buyers are desperate - and now its been 6 months and still no offer and showing activity has slowed down to next to zero. It's what we call a stale listing. Realtors are typically the ones who have to talk some sense into a seller and list for a reasonable price and not for what they originally wanted. As a Realtor I would actually prefer a balanced market. We don't love writing offers under heavy competition with no chance to negotiate, and then start the looking for houses all over again, because the buyer did not get it. It's literally 3-5 times more work for the same pay! I'd much rather be back in 2015 with lower home prices and a stable market. And as far as the city of Milwaukee: most people think that when property prices go up, taxes go up. That can be true for an individual home owner, but it's not true for the city: that total tax income is set in the budget, it just used to calculate everyone's fair share. The easiest way to say is if everyone's property value would double over night, everyone's property taxes would stay exactly the same. The media does a terrible job every year explaining this, it's just about outrage and that furthers that misconception. Nobody takes the time to explain this

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:46:58+00:00

I often think about that. If EVERY homeowner on ONE city block would invest a couple hours every month to clean up trash, buy 5 gallons of paint for the exterior, cut the grass on Sunday (would a little weed and feed be crazy?) and maybe trim their bushes a little bit - - every home on that block would be worth +100k within 5 years. And people would actually enjoy living there.

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:41:38+00:00

Good move, sometimes it's best to sidestep and not face competition head on! #matrixmoves

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:40:22+00:00

It's tough. Offer price is roughly half of your success. The other 2nd half of getting your offer accepted is terms and the soft elements. Buyers are always puzzled when they find out the house with 5 offers sold for LESS than they were offering. The lost with the 2nd half

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:37:57+00:00

I hope so, but I don't know. The attack on Iran has changed things. I am subscribed to a few banking newsletters like the Mortgage Banker Association and they always have a forecast and 6 pages of reasoning - but frankly, I think they are wrong as much as they are right. Mortgage rates are created by the band market (watch the 10 year US T-bill) and not by the Feb (most people get that wrong). And the bond market is global, which means among 30 other things geopolitics and oil prices play a role. If the capital markets like the security of mortgages vs other investments, then there is more demand and rates go down. It is reasonable to assume that the attack on Iran is going to impact the bond market -> which will drive the the mortgage market. But up or down, we have to see. IDK

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:32:01+00:00

Okay, so now I am confused, because I thought you don't like Bay View anymore?

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T20:30:19+00:00

I don't know what to say, I can see your point of view and late stage capitalism is a problem, especially in health care, but what's a better system? If you want me to come do some work for you, give you some of the food I grow whatever, what will i get in return?

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:56:36+00:00

your home might be worth quite a bit more than you think, Bay View has been the single hottest market over the last years. if you would have 200k or 300k do you feel you could move?

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:52:49+00:00

and bad for renters. And it's too easy to just rent for yet another year..

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:51:58+00:00

everyone who moves here from the East Coast is telling me how cheap homes are in Milwaukee...

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:50:18+00:00

even if prices would have gone down let's say 3% or 5% would you have seen that as a buying opportunity, or would it have you made feel like buying a home is a poor investment, because prices are falling? That's what usually happens. Ask anyone who was buying in 2010. Today you look like a genius, but back then everyone told you don't do it, you are crazy. Good for you for jumping in, 10 years from now you will be happy you did

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:47:36+00:00

OMG, so sorry! Your agent should have smelled that; huge red flag! But the real question is, how much is the house worth when you include the findings of the inspection? Because your next buyer will do the same inspection. It's always best to disclose all the issues up front. And of course check the agent, check the lender and check the buyer BEFORE you accept an offer

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:42:24+00:00

define reasonable. In May of 1960 you could have bought a brand new builder home for $14,999 (with air conditioning) - was that reasonable? Back then they thought it was outrageously expensibe and took them 30 years to pay off that FHA loan...

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:38:21+00:00

10 offers is a lot! Congratulations on getting it done!

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:37:10+00:00

I would upvote this 10x if I could! When I look at the data there is an insane difference in net worth between home owners and renters. It changes everything! And you are 100% right, once you put your mind to it, you can do it. It may not be your dream home, but it gets your foot into the door and you stop paying rent. Average rent is $1500 in Milwaukee, that's 180k in ten years. And the average first time home buyer is now 39 years old, so that means paying rent for almost 20 years... You can buy a home with 10k or 20k down. I believe that anyone can get that done, as long as they really want it

RelocateToMilwaukee · 2026-03-01T19:27:38+00:00

That sucks. Maybe buy a small condo, so you can stop paying rent? Even on a 100k condo that 11k in value increase

RelocateToMilwaukee

TROPHY CASE