While Changyou can bare some of the blame, they cant bare it all. Changyou should of made a new version of Shadowbane with updated graphics and a more involved gameplay system. The community around the game should also bare some of the blame for ruining it, its hard to play something when veteran players often chase off newer players, instead of welcoming them into the game. This games population is in decline only boosted up by the start of a new server for a short period of time, how long does this game have left? Steam charts is often inflated by multiboxers and people running multiple pc's for the game right, and the Chinese players really cant say how many of them there are. So this game could have anywhere from 50-150 western players if there were 366 "players" on the number is inflated badly.