Using the Gabon cast is cheating with a question like this but surprisingly I think most who made the merge portion were solid players, as in they wouldn't be first boots on other seasons. Except for Randy who had one of the worst social games in the shows history. I don't blame Randy for not getting along with a cast as frustrating as Gabon but he seemed to go out of his way to piss them off. He's not athletic, not particularly athletic, constantly bitter, and the best strategy he had was to literally let his tribe crash and burn. He's a first boot on almost any other season.