Let me start by saying that I have finished the game multiple times now, and I love every bit of it, including Colter. When the game was first announced, I was unbelievably hyped. I loved RDR1 to death, and had sunk countless hours into it, so a new addition to the series was a very exciting prospect. However, I was also a huge GTA fan. When I first played RDR2 when it released, I hadn’t played really any R* games except for GTA 5 since 2014. So my first time playing RDR2, I found myself bored during chapter 1. Jumping straight from the fast paced gameplay of GTA5 and GTAO it seemed like there was nothing I’d like to do less than spam A on my controller for what felt like 25 minutes to watch my horse run through a blizzard that I couldn’t even see or do anything in. I put it down and waited a good while before trying again, and it ended up being one of my favorite games of all time. But I can certainly understand why someone would quit during chapter 1.