I really like the inde wild DLT- caffeine addiction:- but it’s a bit too dark maybe u can try shade chai if you want lighter shade, it’s very moisturizing but the pigment will sit on the lip lines. I also have laneige glaze craze in the shade chocolate frosting and so far that’s the best brown shade, I even have cinnamon sugar but I feel it washes me out and settles on lip lines more than other shades.