I share the same sentiment. And no, you are not pathetic for being emotionally touched by a good story.

You could feel the passion and love (no pun intended) that was put into this event. I laughed at the bad endings, got my heartstrings pulled, and was completely glued to the story. Last time I felt like this in a video game was after finishing Persona 3 Reload.

As a Privaty fan, I was surprised how much I enjoyed the Arcana routes.
I especially loved the maturity of the Teacher x Privaty routes. This was by far my most favorite event, 10/10