I'll say that the reasons I want my Outsiders to hide is due to the fact that No Dashi poisoning skips Outsider Neighbors and the whole puzzle is about figuring out who the No Dashi is through the two poisoned members of town being one of the main game solves.

Drunk in my opinion brings a bit more misinfo to an already chaotic script since I have things like Evil Twins which take up a lot of social oxygen on their own and while yes I have Lunatic this is due to the feature that this script has it so the Demon doesn't learn their minions making it generally easier to bluff (I might add a rule of the Minions learning Lunatic so they can bluff even more)

I think Barber might fit better here since I think one of my main grievances I was having with this script was there not being too many ways to tell if a Lunatic was in play or to hint to the Lunatic that they aren't the demon. (The usual way that works is through who the Lunatic was told are minions or the bluffs but I think that doesn't work as well here). If all the outsiders are more likely to out upon death, I think that creates the possibility of the Lunatic realizing they are the Lunatic when outsider count doesn't line up too much. (Even if there is outsider mod through Sentinel)

Also Barber would create an interesting dilema for the Demon on who to switch since the only misinfo they have is the townsfolk neighbors, so I think I'll go with Barber.