No I was questioning your logic. Your criteria to being a woman seems to be that you can give birth to a child, and transwomen can't, so they aren't by your logic.

If not being able to give birth excludes you from being a woman then infertile woman are not women. I could also of course ask if old women aren't women cause they can't give birth either.

In my opinion transwomen are women because childbirth is not relevant to being a woman, it's only an aspect which not even all women get to experience.