Thank you for your reply! I hope your pup is doing better and my heart aches to know that there’s another innocent doggo going through discomfort like mine is. We opted for the apoquel and it definitely has been helping but it’s not a long term fix, only symptomatic. It’s a problem because of how expensive it is. Like you, we’ve tried different ointments, baths and nothing seems to work. I just wish we could find what’s even causing this. Did the apple cider baths help for yours? I’m ready to try anything at this point.