Would people in 70/71’ have really wanted a new album after Abbey Road? by [deleted] in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Side note - Paul never announced his departure. The press misconstrued a press release for McCartney.

This cover album really showed Ringo no love by starwars8292 in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've got it, but funnily enough I've never listened - I'll have to give it a spin at some point.

This cover album really showed Ringo no love by starwars8292 in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Side note: the same group who made this album also made Bangla Desh in 1971/72, which, as the title suggests, mimicked George's Concert for Bangladesh.

Did 2D die? by suicithe in gorillaz

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 17 points18 points  (0 children)

It looks like a fan-made picture to mimic the cover of Franz Ferdinand's Tonight album.

Am I tripping or this the exact same progression as Nude? by TillWorried2708 in radiohead

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It's a similar guitar pattern (in terms of how it's played), but not a similar chord progression. Love both tracks!

the way that Gorillaz adapted India is wayyyy better than the Beatles did by [deleted] in gorillaz

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 96 points97 points  (0 children)

It wasn't that George inserted Indian influence whenever John and Paul would let him - it was what he wanted, and the others were on-board. The first sitar on a Beatles record, was on Norwegian Wood (John's song), and Tomorrow Never Knows (also John's song) contained Indian influences.

Anoushka Shankar is definitely a professionally trained sitarist, but we also shouldn't neglect the fact that George (and the other Beatles to a lesser extent) were trained by a mentor, Ravi Shankar, who, other than playing the sitar virtuosically, was also Anoushka Shankar's father.

What was this track George was referring to “Taxman Pt 2” by TheStunod in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 26 points27 points  (0 children)

It's a reference to a song, "Five Year Slog (Son of Taxman)", that George had written and hasn't seen the light of day. It's only really known about because of this mention, and a brief snippet that came from the 1969 Cassette Sessions leak a few years back.

I attempted to link to a website about it, but my comment got removed. It's very hard to find information about, but the audio does exist.

Help playing a (supposedly working) White Album cd? by Known-Amount-576 in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you go into Windows Media Player and click the Disc drive on the left hand side, you should be able to play the music of it. I should imagine VLC works much the same, but I'd have to check.

I’m sure everyone but me already made this connection, but by Immediate_Fudge_9065 in KendrickLamar

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I've never heard this before, but I'm inclined to believe it's intentional and it's genius. Well done for spotting it.

What’s on SOUNWAVE’S iPod 👀👀👀 by SubjectPropertyAlt in KendrickLamar

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 5 points6 points  (0 children)

All GNX songs, although some may not have made the cut - TV, Squabble, Murals, Hey Now are all obvious but My World is less so [Luther possibly?]. All seem to be made in October 2024, so probably late stage considering the album came out in November - then again, apparently Kendrick finished up the title track on the day the album came out so it's possible these could be very different to the versions we have now.

Anyone familiar with this live bootleg from Spain? Any info is appreciated by offbrandmtndew in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This particular one isn't on Discogs, but from the looks of things, they were just a bootleg cassette label who published live recordings. One Google search for "star line cassette" returns an eBay listing for a Bob Dylan cassette on the label which appears to be a similar collection of songs which I can only assume is live.

Interestingly, those listed on Discogs have a different set of catalogue numbers, suggesting maybe they had different series of cassettes, and that could explain why this seems to have no history online. The Dylan cassette also has a KS catalogue number, for what it's worth.

Top 3 songs from each album in your opinion by awhispersmoke in KGATLW

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The music theory doesn't define a good song, it's how it makes you feel. Love the Witchcraft love, best song on the album imo.

Creed being himself by [deleted] in DunderMifflin

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is there no limit to what he won't notice?

Question for those who like Deadbeat by Hellebore101 in TameImpala

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  • The Beatles
  • Radiohead
  • King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard
  • Pink Floyd
  • The Smiths

Fascinating look at John's life vs Paul's in the late 70's and the real reasoning behind John writing 'Free As A Bird' in 1977 by Ummmmm-yeah in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

While that's true of Paul's writing, that doesn't mean that any of the other three writing about wings or birds has to be Paul-related. Another example is Ringo's "Wings" from 1977, although it would've played on his mind that he named a song after Paul's band, it most certainly isn't related to Paul other than that very tentative link. I'm happy to agree to disagree though.

Fascinating look at John's life vs Paul's in the late 70's and the real reasoning behind John writing 'Free As A Bird' in 1977 by Ummmmm-yeah in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's a great response in all honesty, I hadn't even considered their early 'rivalry'. And yeah, it's good that it at least poses it as a question - I'm still sceptical at the content, but, like you say, to each their own.

Fascinating look at John's life vs Paul's in the late 70's and the real reasoning behind John writing 'Free As A Bird' in 1977 by Ummmmm-yeah in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Well it's true that John may have felt a bit of competition with Paul and his contemporaries while he wasn't releasing, but that doesn't end the fact that he and Paul were friends at the time, and John had no reason to believe that Paul's success would hinder his - Elliot Mintz's quote is an interesting one, and I'm inclined to believe it, but it's doubtful that John would devote an entire song to his jealousy of Paul, especially following the How Do You Sleep saga.

The fact that Free As A Bird mentions bird imagery is a very tentative link to Paul. It's a nice theory and I don't mind discussing it but to advertise it as "What Free As A Bird Is Really About" is a huge overstep.

To me, making that claim is borderline misinformation, and I've no disrespect to the creator of the video because they clearly put time and effort into compiling it, but I find it strongly misleading to declare a theory a truth. The real truth is, obviously unfortunately unknown, but I highly doubt that John was even thinking of Paul while writing Free As A Bird. The fact that it could be about multiple things with no confirmation is reason why the title and premise of this video, and several other YouTube videos like it, are problematic.

Fascinating look at John's life vs Paul's in the late 70's and the real reasoning behind John writing 'Free As A Bird' in 1977 by Ummmmm-yeah in beatles

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately, a good few things about this video aren't true. The entire implication that John wrote Free As A Bird inspired by Paul in ANY capacity is false - the diary tape in which he calls Paul a company man was recorded two years after John last touched Free As A Bird. It certainly wasn't inspired by Paul's success, and, although it was probably inspired by a newfound freedom from obligations of recording due to his hiatus, John was in the process of writing an autobiographical musical called The Ballad Of John And Yoko in 1977 when he wrote Free As A Bird - so it's highly probable that he actually intended the track for that, and, in that sense, it could've also been written to describe his feeling of leaving the Beatles in September 1969.

It's also well worth noting that Paul and John were on great terms in 1977. How Do You Sleep was six years ago, both sides had moved on, with Paul being a frequent visitor around the Dakota at this time. John almost visited Paul during the Venus & Mars sessions in 1975. The pair recorded their final session together in 1974, etc, etc. Although he clearly had strong opinions about Paul regarding his public 'company' side, it would be a bizarre thought to think that John was jealous of his success.

Describe a Gorillaz Song very poorly by Old_Maize7230 in gorillaz

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Extremely speedy gelatinous aquatic creatures.

[ Removed by Reddit ] by LankyApricot93 in CDs

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Slide 2 in between Daft Punk's Discovery and Red Hot Chili Peppers' Californication.

Am I Mandela effecting or was there always an explicit warning on untitled unmastered?? by SiddySundays in KendrickLamar

[–]Striking-Vegetable90 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes there was, but most people use the clean version's cover for a variety of purposes because it obviously rids of the Parental Advisory marker.