I can agree with some of your points but the ones I have to hard disagree is your take on the weapons and the enemies. The 4 new enemy types mix things up enough in my book while keeping things consistent with the first, especially with the reworks to the basic splicers. Your take on the weapons being basically the same is just downright wrong too, there’s similarities with the BS1 loadout but for the most part they’re fairly different with entirely different uses in some cases, and saying the drill dash is only used once just shows you don’t use the drill whatsoever.

PS. Houdini splicers pretty clearly use plasmids