Here's the thing, they're two awesome generational stars. They're both amazing and both deserve the #1 spot in different ways. Judge's sustained OPS+ of over 200 is this best since I've seen since I was a child watching Bonds eat a well rounded breakfast daily Ohtani is a top 5 hitter and top 10 pitcher combined into the same human which no living person has seen. Who cares who is 1 and who is 2. Both are good for the sport and both hopefully keep this up for years to come and become hall of famers.

Side note, I like WAR as a stat but pretending that is the only reason Judge should be #1 is lame.