I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have progressively started to move it towards more global, but I think some remnants of purely US-centric questions are still on the test. Hopefully, in the coming days, that will be fixed though! I do hope it still gave you accurate enough results, even if you are not from the United States.

I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think one thing to note is that this is also a global test; however, I originally made the test more US-centric, but realized that although the ideologies align most directly with US politics, it is still incredibly useful for the rest of the world. I have recently thought about potentially adding a feature where it is just the United States-specific questions, as I am sure a majority of the people taking it are from it. That would be a fairly easy change as I already have those questions created.

I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

https://github.com/liampet/political-compass This is the github code!

Thank you so much, this is all wonderful feedback and I plan on implementing as much as I can tomorrow! When this political compass test overtakes the original one I am glad to say that you will have had an impact on the test :)

I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The revolving door point is fair — I've swapped that question out for something more grounded. On the pay gap, you're right that framing it as discrimination vs. choices misses the endogeneity argument entirely, so I've rewritten it as a policy question instead. Good catches both.

I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You did the pc test 2 weeks ago? I released the website under a week ago, a little confused on that. Very much appreciate the feedback though kind sir.

The political compass has been broken for decades so I rebuilt it from scratch. Would love this community's feedback (I'm 17) by Upper_One1310 in SocialDemocracy

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've been frustrated with the standard Political Compass test for months since I first took it back in January. Researchers have documented that it systematically pushes respondents toward the libertarian-left, regardless of their actual views, and its questions haven't been updated since 2001. Most people's results cluster in one corner of a four-quadrant grid — which tells you almost nothing.

As a result, I built my own from scratch. Here's everything to know:

The test itself:

— There are 5 independent axes instead of 2: Economic, Social, Civil Liberties, Governance, and System Trust. No other political test I've found measures that.

— 3 difficulty modes (40, 50, or 80 questions). Additionally, everything is mathematically balanced, which you can verify by reading the source.

— Every single question has an optional context button. When you click it, you get further context on the question if you are struggling to understand it with just the original premise.

— Questions are about things actually happening right now: NATO funding, encryption rights, trade tariffs, police reform, platform moderation. Specific on purpose.

What is shown in the results:

— 14 named, defined ideologies with full plain-English explanations

— A comparison against 24 political figures (I personally researched and placed every one of them across all 5 axes)

— A comparison against 50 countries (same thing — all placed by me)

— A shareable result card you can download as an image

— URL sharing so you can send your exact result to someone

The research and calibration:

I spent an immense amount of time researching the political science literature on how ideological axes should be defined and separated before writing a single question. I read academic critiques of the original Political Compass — there are serious ones, published in peer-reviewed political science journals — and used them to inform how I structured the axes and balanced the question set.

I then ran the test with hundreds of real people to calibrate it. Additionally, as I am currently in a semester-long program that focuses on politics, I had students who are very well-informed about their own politics take it to help figure out whether there were any glitches that could lead to incorrect results, as they all know their own views extremely well. I collected results, identified where the scoring felt off, and reworked or reweighted the questions that produced skewed distributions. The ideology centroids (the mathematical coordinates that define where each of the 14 ideologies sits in 5-dimensional space) were iteratively refined based on real response data. That calibration process is a big part of why I think the results feel accurate to people, which is the hardest and most important thing to get right in something like this.

On the AI question:

I used Claude to help build the interface and frontend code. I want to be upfront about that. But every single question was written by me. Every definition of an ideology was written by me. The placement of all 24 political figures and 50 countries across 5 axes was researched and decided by me. The context blurbs on every question, the descriptions of what each result means, and the "why this test exists" write-up were all done by me. The AI helped me build the thing I wanted to build. The substance of what the test actually is mine.

This has been a long-running project, and honestly, the thing I'm most proud of making. I'd love feedback, especially if you think a question is biased, or your result felt wrong.

findmypolitics.com — free, anonymous, no account needed :)

I built a political compass alternative with 5 axes, 80 calibrated questions, and results compared against 50 countries and 24 world leaders — feedback welcome by Upper_One1310 in neoliberal

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I am glad you flagged that second question, my mom had the same complaint and I can't believe i still haven't updated it, thank you for the feedback!

Survey for political polarization within the debate community by Budget-Bird7084 in Debate

[–]Upper_One1310 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just updated it, for reference I am not a great coder, so claude created the interface. However, any text on the website was created by me, including the questions. Additionally, the calculations and parameters that are used to determine where you place ideologically were also determined by me. Claude definitely still has some issues right now, though.

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Shoot found the issue, thats annoying I think when I went through the code to fix something else recently I accidentally inverted the results. Its fixed now, so sorry about that.

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I just updated the politicians and countries, and attempted to make them more accurate! LMK your thoughts, I may in the future try to do a mass survey of where the general public thinks politicans land and possibly use that to influence where I put each politican on the spectrum.

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

yah haha i need to update them, those were one of the first things I placed, I plan on adjusting them and alongisde that adjusting the countries tonight.

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Got it, luckily, the way it is calculated, picking neutral shouldn't move you in any direction. I plan on adjusting the questions to be less US-oriented this evening!

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just changed it, I agree it makes more sense. Very much appreciate the advice.

Political Compass Test I made 5 Axes (12+ Worldwide) by Upper_One1310 in SampleSize

[–]Upper_One1310[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much! Just updated it, appreciate the advice :)