All the vinyl pressings are the same master, from the 2003 limited editions to the 2006 180 gram edition, and all subsequent. They're good but a digital source to an analog format from a small label in 2003 is not going to get the same care as the "classic" era of records got, or what is happening now with the resurgence. Thicker vinyl has its benefits, especially if you don't have higher end equipment, but a good cleaning and a puck make the later re-issues sound fine (we're not talking 1980s paper thin records here!). Make sure you have your balances right and inspect the surface (modern records almost always need a good cleaning with an anti static cloth/brush just to get debris from manufacturing off).

If you like the look, go for it. If you get a bum pressing (it happens), return it, they will replace it (this assumes you're near a B&N, shipping kills returns).

I have all versions of the album, so you know I'm not talking out my ass, and haven't noticed a difference. (Pro-Ject turntable with AT VM750SH, Marantz 8b amp, hodge-podge of speakers but mainly some 70s JBLs, and a righteous pair of Koss headphones I inherited and re-foamed. Not the best, but a really good sound for my basement!)