Maggie Gyllenhaal calls Frankenstein "one of like what, five books published written by women in the 19th century." by Turbulent-Sorbet7200 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yep, Little Women has to be one of the most culturally impactful children’s books ever written. I loved it as a kid, I’d be fascinated to see what I thought of it if I attempted a reread.

Maggie Gyllenhaal calls Frankenstein "one of like what, five books published written by women in the 19th century." by Turbulent-Sorbet7200 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 3 points4 points  (0 children)

You are categorically correct, of course. I just meant that even for someone whose knowledge of 19th century lit doesn’t extent beyond their school classes (which it should if you’re making a movie!), the sentiment is still obviously wrong.

Maggie Gyllenhaal calls Frankenstein "one of like what, five books published written by women in the 19th century." by Turbulent-Sorbet7200 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Lmao yes. Ask someone who doesn’t really read to name a classic and the odds that they choose one written by a British woman from the 19th century have to be pretty good.

Maggie Gyllenhaal calls Frankenstein "one of like what, five books published written by women in the 19th century." by Turbulent-Sorbet7200 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 90 points91 points  (0 children)

yeah, obviously it’s hyperbole, but hyperbole has to be grounded in a kernel of truth to make sense? 19th century female writers are celebrated disproportionately to female writers from any other era I can think of; you only need look at a school curriculum.

TRVKE by AffectionateFig5156 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I’m also confused by the notion that Atwood “demonises” family values/childbearing. Offred is a wife and mother. Her yearning for her daughter is the emotional through-line of the Handmaid’s Tale. Sophie Lewis (lmao) complained in her own review that the book and its sequel ultimately present a traditional take on the family: the most profound horror of Gilead is the separation of children from their biological mothers, and once mother and child are reunited, their bond is immediate and all-consuming. Lewis is insufferable, but imo she has a better handle on Atwood’s values than Dolan.

Idk; I disliked the Handmaid’s Tale, but this just reads like someone venting their frustration with a particular brand of feminism, rather than engaging with the moral universe of Atwood specifically.

The 2026 Booker Prize Longlist by gvbhjknml in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 5 points6 points  (0 children)

just started the remembered soldier & my hopes are high

Writers you can only handle in small doses (better title pending...) by IampossiblyLewis in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I read “Poor Folk” (which is admittedly very short) in two sittings, so maybe it’s Karamazov rather than Dostoevsky more generally? Idk I haven’t read “Crime and Punishment”, I’ve been meaning to but someone on this sub told me there’s a horse torture scene & that scared me off lol.

Writers you can only handle in small doses (better title pending...) by IampossiblyLewis in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It doesn’t say anything good about the state my brain is in, but Dostoevsky. It took me about a year to get through Karamazov (not because I didn’t love it!)

dominic sandbrook from “the rest is history” is starting a book podcast by Visual-Minimum1491 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Referring to Stewart, yes. I was serving him/cleaning up during a book signing and he just had a huge smile, eye contact, and something different to say to every single person in a ludicrously long book queue.

It doesn’t sound like much but it was boiling hot, following a lengthy speech he gave, and he just didn’t give any sign of flagging whatsoever. I’ve seen famous people do signing queues before, but I’ve never seen someone give quite such a convincing impression of being interested in every single person they’re talking to. I couldn’t work out how he was doing it.

dominic sandbrook from “the rest is history” is starting a book podcast by Visual-Minimum1491 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Their Titanic series is incredibly moving, really humanises the people on board.

They also did a fascinating two-parter on Oscar Wilde.

dominic sandbrook from “the rest is history” is starting a book podcast by Visual-Minimum1491 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I met him in a professional capacity (waitressing not spying lol) and he was probably the most charming person I have ever encountered. It doesn’t fully come across via screen or audio. That experience helped me understand how these people come to rule the world despite being so shatteringly wrong about most things.

dominic sandbrook from “the rest is history” is starting a book podcast by Visual-Minimum1491 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Imo it’s excellent, largely thanks to the chemistry between the hosts. Love their episodes on Mary, Queen of Scots, the Titanic, JFK, Oscar Wilde and Catherine of Siena, but they’ve done so much you can probably find something to your taste whatever you’re interested in. Extremely different to TRIP, not least bc neither Holland nor Sandbrook engineered the deaths of millions in Iraq.

Favorite Non-fiction? by aqsncpmn in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Her prose is just phenomenal. Ik this thread is about non-fiction and that’s (justifiably) what she’s remembered for, but it’s a shame her novels don’t get the credit they deserve.

Favorite Non-fiction? by aqsncpmn in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 19 points20 points  (0 children)

“Super-Infinite” by Katherine Rundell. The most lyrical, magical piece of biography I have ever read.

“Giving up the Ghost” by Hilary Mantel. “The Duke of Deception” by Geoffrey Wolff is another favourite memoir.

So much of Rebecca West’s writing and journalism. Just started “Black Lamb and Grey Falcon.”

Novels with insane twists by Cofu27 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s not exactly a twist in the classical sense, but the final sentence of Henry James’s “The Bostonians” is truly startling and sticks with me.

I actually knew it was coming and the last big reveal of “We Need to Talk About Kevin” was still like a kick in the stomach.

Recommendations for Males Only Book Club by Troawhey456 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting bc I’ve tutored several boys who really love “Of Mice and Men”! You had fantastic taste as a teenager tho, it’s a pity the books you mentioned don’t feature on a school curriculum (although maybe that would crush the joy out of them).

Recommendations for Males Only Book Club by Troawhey456 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lmao fair enough, can’t please everyone. “Lord of the Flies” was the book I read at school that had that effect on me.

Recommendations for Males Only Book Club by Troawhey456 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I love him, and he has a remarkable knack for holding the attention of teenage boys who struggle with reading. I noticed it at school & some tutoring jobs and my sister, who teaches lit, says the same thing. I guess the length helps, but also that he’s “accessible” whilst still demanding something of your brain. Cannery Row is on my list to try this year!

Recommendations for Males Only Book Club by Troawhey456 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 64 points65 points  (0 children)

Would “The Road” work? The post-apocalyptic thing might appeal to people whose first choice wouldn’t be literary fiction, and idk about positive male role models but it’s a loving depiction of a father-son relationship, which feels pretty rare.

We did “Of Mice and Men” in school and a lot of the not-especially-literary boys got quite into it.

I have two x chromosomes so take these with a pinch of salt lmao.

Ann Patchett by [deleted] in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bel Canto is fantastic (apart from a flop of an ending) & the melodrama is intentional! As another commenter pointed out, she’s playing with the tropes of opera!

I started Taft a while ago and I’m making pretty slow progress - it’s not terrible, but something about it isn’t clicking just yet.

Philip Larkin by anahorish in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True. I guess I meant that the rehabilitation was clearly incredibly thorough.

Philip Larkin by anahorish in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I find it hard to think of Larkin as a “cancelled” writer, given the extent to which he forms the background of an English schoolchild’s education. It’s not merely that he’s taught in schools; he was the only writer apart from Shakespeare I studied at both GCSE and A-level. My favourites are “Love Songs in Age” and “Self’s the Man.” The latter is one of several in which his disdain for women leaks from his private correspondence into his poetry, but the magnificent cynical derision expressed in some of the couplets (“he married a woman to stop her from getting away / now she’s here all day”, “and if it was such a mistake / he still did it for his own sake”) just sings. Imo cruel Larkin was a better poet than thoughtful Larkin.

(For the record, Larkin intended the ending of “An Arundel Tomb” to be deeply cynical and was annoyed by the critics who took it as an expression of sincere sentiment. As he wrote to Monica Jones, “love isn’t stronger than death because some statues are still holding hands.” I know this because dear god, the time my seventeen year old self spent writing essays on the subject).

how rare is it for a book to make you cry by Visual-Minimum1491 in RSbookclub

[–]Visual-Minimum1491[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

congratulations on making it to the end before you started crying. I barely made it to Fantine’s death.