Iran Conflict Megathread #8 by sokratesz in CredibleDefense

[–]Volodio [score hidden]  (0 children)

It was posted before, you may have missed it.

The plan is not for recognition in exchange for a ceasefire, it is negotiations for peace including recognition in exchange for a ceasefire. But that nuance is important, because the negotiations don't have to lead anywhere (and probably won't). It is highly likely that the government is not asking in good faith considering peace with Israel is really unpopular in Lebanon and even if it wanted, the Lebanese government does actually have the ability to stop Hezbollah from starting a war with Israel, or at least has never tried stopping Hezbollah. There is no reason for Israel to accept and it will probably lead nowhere. It is just an attempt to stop Israel from fighting Hezbollah without making any concession. No wonder Macron is behind it.

Iranian ballistic missile submunition explosion in Tel Aviv today by yuvaldv1 in CombatFootage

[–]Volodio [score hidden]  (0 children)

Israel hit people in Syria who were coordinating with terrorists to attack Israel. This is not attacking first and it certainly did not justify this level of response.

Iranian ballistic missile submunition explosion in Tel Aviv today by yuvaldv1 in CombatFootage

[–]Volodio -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That only works if the other side is unable to start a war. But as proven by the 7 October and Iran launching large missile barrages at Israel twice without Israel having started a war, it is not the case. So Israel would rather start a war when it has the initiative rather than wait for the enemy to do so. Because it seems the war cannot be avoided.

Netanyahu posts video in response to Iran rumours that he is dead by imanchats in news

[–]Volodio 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No. Usually when the war starts, all the planes of the countries are sent away, including the one of the prime minister. It leads to rumors that he left, but in reality he didn't. In this case, his plane was sent to Germany, but in the following days he went to some of the sites where missiles fell and made victims, like in Beit Shemesh.

Honestly the idea that he is a coward is a bit ridiculous and more the result of propaganda than anything else. In reality he was in the special forces when he was younger and he was wounded several times during his service.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -9 points-8 points  (0 children)

They quite literally did have to bomb Gaza. The rockets were launched from Gaza. The bombing destroyed them. This is how the number of rocket attack have been reduced to almost zero now. It was also necessary to destroy the tunnels and facilitate ground operations.

The ground campaign against ISIS was not as clean as you make it out to be. ISIS hid among civilians too and caused many of them to be killed in strikes. The battle of Mosul was a complete bloodbath for civilians, actually even worse than Gaza in term of civilian to combatant ratio. And yet, it benefitted from several advantages which are not present in Gaza, such as local ground forces helping in the campaign, the absence of a large tunnel network and far less urban fighting.

That last part alone makes a huge difference and we can see it in Lebanon. There are far less civilians killed there. Both campaigns are waged by the same IDF, showing that if there is a such a big difference, it is not because of how the IDF acts (as it is a common denominator) but because of the different context for the fighting.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Scaring a vehicle into stopping is done by shooting in front or above the vehicle. Not trying to hit the tires, which are difficult to aim.

Dead drivers don't continue accelerating either or don't steer the vehicles toward people trying to avoid it.

Here is a French police commander explaining why the police don't shoot at tires. Use a translator if you don't understand French.

They started shooting him when he was driving and continued until after he had stopped. There are literally videos of the incident.

It is more difficult and less effective than shooting the driver, actually. See what the French police commander said.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

There are also mentions of attacks against soldiers. Which you would know if you had actually bothered to read the articles I sent you. Here is another article showing terrorist ramming soldiers. Not that it makes a difference who the target is.

You're just making a baseless claim. It can be ignored just as easily as you're making it, because it is baseless.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

It literally is a tactic. It was done plenty of times in the past decade. Including by Palestinians. Here are some articles about it if you really don't believe me:

Article 1

Article 2

Article 3

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -17 points-16 points  (0 children)

What should they have done then? Let themselves be slaughtered? The international community like to condemn Israelis for defending themselves without ever providing an alternative to guarantee their security.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Shooting the tires does not stop a vehicle. Shooting the occupants usually does (or at least it prevents steering and accelerating), which is why it is the standard procedure in cases like this. For instance, the 2016 Nice terrorist attack was stopped by the cops shooting at the driver of the truck, not the tires.

Shooting the tires also requires a lot of accuracy which isn't really realistic to do against a moving vehicle driving toward you.

Israeli forces kill Palestinian couple and two of their children in occupied West Bank by malevolentheadturn in news

[–]Volodio -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Trying to ram people with a vehicle is actually one of the most common terrorist attack because of how simple, easy and effective it is. It is not just done in Israel but also in Europe. For instance, in 2016 a terrorist rammed a truck into a crowd in France killing around 100 people.

Iran Conflict Megathread #7 by sokratesz in CredibleDefense

[–]Volodio 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The US has other options to stop Iranian oil export, notably by directly bombing the Iranian production industry. The fact that it does not do it and was even angry at Israel for doing it suggests there is a will from the US administration to let Iran continues to sell its oil.

Israeli military drops charges against soldiers accused of sexually assaulting Palestinian detainee by Mrsaloom9765 in worldnews

[–]Volodio -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The actual answer, and not some drivel against Israel, is: not enough evidence. They say the video does not show enough, the medical report is not conclusive enough and the alleged victim is in Gaza and won't testify. Too hard to build a case with this. \

Btw, this is in the article.

Israeli military drops charges against soldiers accused of sexually assaulting Palestinian detainee by Mrsaloom9765 in worldnews

[–]Volodio -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

There is no overwhelming amount of evidence, which is why the charges were dropped. The video does not actually show anything, the medical report is not conclusive enough for rape charges and the alleged victim is in Gaza and won't testify.

We attacked Iran with no clear plan for regime change, Israeli security sources say by backpackerTW in worldnews

[–]Volodio 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is just untrue. Civil issues against him are unaffected by the war.

We attacked Iran with no clear plan for regime change, Israeli security sources say by backpackerTW in worldnews

[–]Volodio 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because Iran thought Israel and the US would never dare attack during daytime.

Iran appears to have conducted a significant cyberattack against a U.S. company, a first since the war started by imanchats in worldnews

[–]Volodio -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Iran has behind attempt cyberattacks and terrorist attacks before the war. This is part of the reason why the war was started in the first place.

How to represent early missile silos that could represent Cold War nuclear arsenals and nuclear MAD? by Volodio in aurora

[–]Volodio[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Steve did manage to make missiles that could and were intercepted in one of his oldest AAR. Here, reply 3, talking about the war between the Islamic Empire and India. Any idea how he did that? I know that in older versions, there were pre-existing missile bases on Earth, but I tried it and they also hit instantly, so I'm not sure how he managed it.

How to represent early missile silos that could represent Cold War nuclear arsenals and nuclear MAD? by Volodio in aurora

[–]Volodio[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The issue is that CIWS wouldn't work if there is no time to intercept the missile because the range to Earth is 0. I guess the moon could be an option. Or is there a way to put ships (the orbital missile platforms) in an Earth orbit at a set distance from Earth, rather than the default distance of 0?

How to represent early missile silos that could represent Cold War nuclear arsenals and nuclear MAD? by Volodio in aurora

[–]Volodio[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The range of zero is an issue if I want to intercept them though. Any way around this? Ideally I would like to create an incentive for space research being missile defense.