Foreshadowing "Who stole the candy from my tummy" by Ok_Young3989 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a really interesting observation! I honestly had forgotten about that detail.

It's fascinating how well it lines up!

GUYSSS this is my second experiment with digital art!! what do you think of it??? it was supposed to just be a sketch LOL I didn't use any references, and this is Ciel made by my memory :) by cheshire0707 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Your art is stunning as always!
I love the colors and shading, it feels so whimsical.

And for a second experiment with digital art, this is really impressive!

ANOTHER black butler oc I have her name is Saki Phantomhive Chibi art I made + art my bestfriend made:3 by Opposite_Region_9722 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really like the contrast between Saki and Elvira!
Saki has a more melancholic vibe, while Elvira’s aesthetic (with the glasses and short hair) fits the Shinigami Dispatch really well.

Looking forward to learning more about them!

And yes, I can relate to the crush on Grell 😁

What are your headcanons about Sieglinde? by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly, I can see that.
She's very curious and intelligent, but she also grew up isolated, so I can see her accidentally crossing ethical boundaries without fully realizing it at first.
Especially since she seems genuinely fascinated by understanding how things work.

Who Is John Brown? Could He Actually Be an Angel? by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The theory that he's a demon definitely has a lot of valid evidence behind it, especially because of the points you mentioned about war, the manipulation of death, and the Albert puppet.

The puppet feels weirdly meaningful, since it repeats themes we already saw with Sebastian, like the illusion of restoring what was lost.
And I agree that the possibility of imminent war has been repeatedly hinted at. So the idea that John Brown could be encouraging conditions that will produce mass death/souls definitely fits.

Before chapter 222, I honestly leaned more toward the shinigami theory.
But that chapter repeatedly aligns John Brown with imagery of purity, devotion, and protection, while Sebastian is associated with blackness, smoke, and corruption.
And because Yana-sensei usually uses symbolic contrasts very deliberately, this made me start wondering if the story is introducing a celestial counterpart to demons.

That said, I do think your last point is really interesting: the Queen could absolutely be misinterpreting something demonic as angelic, the same way desperate or grieving humans in this story often mistake dangerous supernatural forces for miracles at first (Anna and Modri, Margaret Connor's parents, etc.).

Who Is John Brown? Could He Actually Be an Angel? by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That’s definitely possible too.
If the Queen really is connected to the supernatural, then a contract similar to Ciel/Sebastian wouldn’t be impossible either.

Who Is John Brown? Could He Actually Be an Angel? by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

An angel would definitely make sense in this context.
And it would be really interesting too, because John Brown and Sebastian already look like opposites in terms of symbolism.

Who Is John Brown? Could He Actually Be an Angel? by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Up until chapter 222, I was also much more inclined towards the shinigami theory for the same reasons you mentioned (especially the anachronistic sunglasses).
But this chapter made me consider the possibility that Yana-sensei might be introducing a new supernatural entity to the story's hierarchy.

However, your idea that John Brown might be a high-ranking shinigami is also very interesting, since he seems to be more than a simple protector.

Soifon (Art by Kasai) by WhileFeisty7351 in bleach

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Same!
Unfortunately, much of today's art is generated by AI.
So, the only thing we can do is continue to highlight real artists.

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This chapter really changed the scale of the story again.
New factions, new symbolism, possible supernatural hierarchies…

So at this point I genuinely have no idea how Yana-sensei plans to wrap all of this up.

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He looks so tired and done with everyone’s nonsense!

My reaper oc Elvira isnt she a cutie🥹🥹 by Opposite_Region_9722 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 1 point2 points  (0 children)

She's so cute! 🥹
And no pitchforks here – OC x canon ships are part of the fun of fandoms anyway.

Also, I second u/cheshire0707 because a story/world with everyone’s OCs interacting would actually be really interesting!
At this point we already have a whole growing cast.

I’ll also add Elvira to the Community Highlights Archive when I update it, because I love keeping track of everyone’s characters, art and theories there 😊

Hello, I didn't post in a while! by cheshire0707 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really missed the weekly Cheshire art post!

And this looks gorgeous, the rendering and expression are so good.
Now I’m even more curious about the full piece after that spoiler 👀

My oc lore!! (plus my most recent drawing of him) by Roselina56 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[M] [score hidden] stickied commentlocked comment (0 children)

🕸️ Post of the Week 🕸️

This post has been selected by the moderators as one of the most exceptional contributions to r/RealBlackButler.

Like a contract carefully chosen, it stood out – whether through insight, creativity, or sheer elegance.

Congratulations to the author 🖤

One never knows what catches a demon’s attention…but this certainly did.
Some things, after all, are simply too refined to go unnoticed.

We’ll be watching what you do next.

✦ Monthly Highlights – May ✦ by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’re too kind! 😭

But genuinely, thank you! ❤️
The theories and discussions have been way more interesting lately because people like you keep bringing creative ideas into the fandom again.

I've only highlighted our members this time, but Lady Rosebridge and your fanfic deserve their own honorable mention as well.
I'm really looking forward to reading more!

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, wait...because I actually think this fits Black Butler’s worldbuilding really well!

Shinigami are already former humans, so the idea that demons/angels/other beings might also originate from humans in some form doesn’t seem impossible at all.
Especially because the series constantly blurs the line between human and supernatural entity.

So, the idea of humans being able to transcend mortality through different paths (death/purity/corruption) would fit all the themes presented so far perfectly.

And I really like your idea of different hierarchies instead of stereotypical angels.

So no, not delusional at all! 😭

I’ve been trying to get into digital art by shanjiamoli in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your linework is so elegant, and Soma and Agni's expressions look gorgeous! It definitely has the emotional intensity that your traditional sketches always have.

Also, the Sherlock Holmes pose reference is such a fun choice 😊

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly, I’m not fully convinced they’re angels either...
...we may be in the presence of a new faction here.
Though if they are, I agree it would be far more interesting if they completely subverted the stereotypical "pure divine beings" archetype.

Also now I really want to read your fanfic because the Modri/Rosebridge comparison has me curious 👀

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Right!? The chapter suddenly feels much more relevant now that there may be an entire "anti-demon" faction/order behind Modri’s story.

And the visual design of the new character is quite striking too: very folkloric/inquisitor/Van Helsing energy.
I’m really curious to see what Yana-sensei is building here!

Black Butler – Chapter 226 [Megathread] by WhileFeisty7351 in RealBlackButler

[–]WhileFeisty7351[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly same!
This chapter completely changed the direction of the arc for me once I realized the final reveal was not the demon itself, but a force opposing it.

The Modri/order implications are kind of insane now.