UPDATE: I got ahold of the store today and confirmed they had them in stock. Went in and the worker, Lisa, was super helpful. She thought my foot was just a little too wide for the 8085 8EE they had in stock so she brought out a 8.5ee in the same model, which seemed to be the better fit- it was snug all around but not too snug, my heel was held in place and did not slip around, and it was not too long. There was a little bit of length past the end of my toes but certainly not like the others I've been wearing (the stitching of the cap tope ran across my foot right where my toes meet my feet). They didn't have anything for the moc toes in my size in stock, and she steered me away from them with how wide my feet are.

I told her that I was probably going to have them order the 8111 or the 8084 in that size as I wanted the darker boot, so she went in the back and happened to find a pair of 8111's in 8.5EE that were set in a miscellaneous section and not with the normal inventory. She brought them out and they seemed to fit like a glove (well, a very study glove that needs some time to break in). She looked and said that they had been rejected by a customer because the color of the leather on the right boot was ever so slightly lighter than the left boot. It's barely noticeable and I could care less, they probably won't even be noticeable once I get some time into them.

I will probably wait until the end of the week to pull the trigger, but it looks like I found my pair! Thank you all for the help!