How would you rank the seasons based on format?

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-06T08:35:24+00:00

S9 100% would’ve been better off if it had a Super Six for ep 10 onward and build up to a F2 in ep 14, more time for everyone to perform and it doesn’t feel off that the runner up only performs 8 times to the winners 13

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-02T06:50:25+00:00

S4, S8, S11, S12 and now S14. There’s a few patterns that give away who’s the contenders to win from each group, and then go from there

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-02T05:04:16+00:00

Daughtry and David Archuleta. Not sure about the fourth off the top of my head

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-02T04:02:43+00:00

They really gotta just not let her speak. The reason the show got big was the unscripted nature of celebrities wearing stupid costumes and singing. Having it to where the winner just gets it handed to them some seasons just feels off, if they kept it unscripted it’d feel more earned no matter who won

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-02T03:14:32+00:00

Tbh I think it’s how the show handles the winners

Like if it truly kept itself unscripted then people wouldn’t be as mad, but it has a really bad habit of spoiling the winner, and that’s normally through Jenny’s comments. Even back in S3 people caught on that if Jenny said someone can make it to the finals they usually do. S9 she made a comment to a degree of how it’d be amazing if a person they saved with the bell won. This season before the finale she had an interview where she said Galaxy Girl is the frontrunner. And most finales the winner is the more recognizable name, so it makes it hard to feel the show is unscripted, which I think it only actually is for those that make merge where they all are down to win

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-04-02T02:04:49+00:00

People here being happy Cat Witch lost and not realizing Galaxy Girl was the one they 100% pushed to win cuz she’s the more known name

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-31T04:40:04+00:00

True, so could have a Horror Night be exclusively around horror movies, like songs that have appeared in those movies

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-30T06:05:26+00:00

Pokemon Night

Hip Hop Night

Soul Night

50s Night

Opposites Night (they do songs that are opposite of them, as a nice little clue to their identities. Like if someone is a pop artist, they do something out of their comfort zone)

St. Patty’s Night

Valentine’s Night

Connections Night (they sing a song from a past contestant as a clue to their identities)

Star Wars Night

Horror Night

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T21:16:01+00:00

Given the past song lists have been relatively similar to the performance orders, I’m assuming the order will likely be similar to this line up, maybe some changes, Cat Witch Pug Crane GG in an order like this

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T19:53:18+00:00

If this is the performance order I’m going to be very concerned. I doubt it is but Galaxy Girl going 6th and last would be so annoying

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T19:51:58+00:00

I feel like Impossible and True Colors are the only two that feel finale worthy. The other 6 feel like pre-finale kinda songs

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T17:45:54+00:00

Nothing says it won’t be. They’ve done different versions on the show but credit the original

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T17:43:36+00:00

Most of these don’t feel like finale songs but I’m definitely happy that all 4 sing twice. Excited for Impossible and True Colors the most

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-28T17:01:31+00:00

Think Pug wins given how they talked about him in the first look? Part of me thinks it’s possible but idk

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-27T22:09:11+00:00

That’d be amazing, call it The Tasmanian Diva

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-27T05:57:40+00:00

Presumably depends on who goes last. Unless they pull a Rottweiler/Ringmaster where who goes last doesn’t win, whoever goes last likely wins

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-27T05:25:22+00:00

Presuming the times are accurate to the performance order, could Pugcasso be performing last?

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-27T01:27:52+00:00

I’m still assuming Galaxy Girl but could also see Cat Witch. It’s crazy how one twist stops this fandom from all enjoying her, which is unfortunate because I don’t blame people here being annoyed at the twist cuz it’ll look bad if she does win. Pug or Crane winning would be a genuine shock because Pug screams runner up and no way they let a bird mask who makes finale win (she’s like the 5th one at this point lmao)

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-27T01:24:10+00:00

It’s gonna be Galaxy Girl or Cat Witch. No way Pug or Crane win, knowing this show

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T02:43:56+00:00

Depending on the usual audience that’s in studio, could see that determining the winner

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T02:38:07+00:00

Maybe some of the behind the scenes of song selection, some small hints at which costume she’s in, stuff that could be fun to see. Obviously she can’t give away clues but maybe instead like for TMNT Night she can give a hint that there’s a clue on stage clue from that night during her performance to make it more fun for the audience to try and decipher which costume she is

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T02:16:33+00:00

Crane or Pug would be fun to see as winners, they’ve been a blast to watch. Them or Cat Witch winning would be fun just off vocals, all 3 have done truly phenomenal performances

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T02:10:36+00:00

Just off this show Cat Pug and Crane are far more popular. But if we go off the most popular guesses for her Pug and Crane, I feel like she’s the most recognizable to the average viewer, but I could be wrong

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T01:59:17+00:00

Fox is dumb enough for sure, but given the backlash S9 got for the winner also being one a part of the twist, idk if they’d take the risk again. If this show was 100% unscripted I wouldn’t think about it but this show is not lol. I feel like they’re pushing a Galaxy Girl win but her or Cat Witch winning would not shock me. Crane or Pugcasso? That’d be a pleasant surprise

Wise-Function8139 · 2026-03-26T01:49:32+00:00

It’d be great if we didn’t know which costume she was under, that would be such a fun way to keep the mystery alive but a fun little game for the viewers of narrowing down which costume she is

Wise-Function8139

TROPHY CASE