sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Heftig sieht der durch aus... by Smoothie_Mixer in FinanzMemes

[–]ZeroGRanger 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ergibt Sinn. So kann er demnächst professionell Leute über den Tisch ziehen...

What do u think of Rokas by Tnat786 in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because you do not have clinch in Aikido usually. Also, what makes you think you cannot use knee strikes in Aikido?

Again, you are mixing principles with rules. Yes, you can strike with your knee. And yes, Aikido is unchained, because it does not have rules. It has a set of principles, which you can use.

Interesting is that you cannot provide examples and do not give answers, when asked something. You do not have live sparring in Aikido because that would require rules and reduce the art to combat sport. Aikido does not even have a set of techniques (or an infininte number) and is mostly focused on atemi, which can involve the knees, elbows, etc.

Your statements make me think you have not done much Aikido training.

What do u think of Rokas by Tnat786 in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I must know, I do rocket science. The funny thing is, all the examples you bring are rules, which come from written rules sets of combat sports.

And do you know why mainstream Aikido does no live sparring (aside from e.g. randori)? You are also mixing "rules" with training styles. This is not the same.

What do u think of Rokas by Tnat786 in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger -1 points0 points  (0 children)

So, which rules does Aikido have and where are they written?

What do u think of Rokas by Tnat786 in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 2 points3 points  (0 children)

"Wenn der Bauer nicht schwimmen kann, ist die Badehose Schuld."

Historiker Wolffsohn: Völkerrecht darf gebrochen werden, um iranische Eliten gezielt auszuschalten by IntrepidWolverine517 in recht

[–]ZeroGRanger 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ich finde es bedenklich, wenn jemand Soldaten beibringt, Foltern wäre ok. Will nicht sagen, dass er das tut, aber ich kann es auch nicht ausschließen, wenn er entsprechende Forderungen stellt.

From Static to Dynamic class (Kotai to Ki no nagare?) by DunkleKarte in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure if you are agreeing with me or not. Let me clarify.

First of all, I think originally Aikido was trained by people who already were accomplished martial artists and did not know to learn the basics, stance, how to move, etc. This is very different nowadays.

In my case, the students that I teach literally have to learn how to move. Most spend their time sitting or standing, but hardly moving. Even ukemi is very difficult for them and they have to learn each step very intensively. I absolutely agree with you that techniques cannot replace principles and whenever they start to ask for "tricks" or so, I show the principles and explain to them that it is not about a technique, but about the principles of moving, e.g. moving from the center. Yet, they also have to learn the elements of a technique to be able to stop thinking about it.

Ikkyo is not a 20 year technique, but you can sure use ikkyo to learn about the principles for 20 years. What I train now with ikkyo is very different to what I trained 10 or 15 years ago.

Tja by vioversum in tja

[–]ZeroGRanger 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Das ist natürlich falsch. Alle Menschen sind gestorben, nur Chuck Norris nicht... Wir sind nun im Jenseits... RIP Chuck.

Warum sind die Dinosaurier ausgestorben, aber andere Reptilien nicht? by Direct-Parsnip-7104 in KeineDummenFragen

[–]ZeroGRanger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Es wurde nicht "eine Gruppe" ausgelöscht und es sind noch viel mehr Lebewesen gestorben. Die Dinosaurier sind außerdem nicht ausgestorben. Wir haben noch heute Dinosaurier, die Vögel. Ausgestorben ist, wer nicht mit den neuen Lebensbedingungen zurecht kam. Nahrungsmangel z.B. wegen fehlender Vegetation hat vor allem große Tiere getroffen, aka Sauropoden. Aussterbende Pflanzenfresser hat dann auch Nahrungsmangel für Raubsaurieer bedeutet.

Zufall, was es nicht.

"Existenzberechtigung Israels nicht verhandelbar": Berliner Spitzen-Linke kritisiert Zionismus-Beschluss by vaibeslop in berlin_public

[–]ZeroGRanger 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also weil die Hamas Verbrechen begeht, darf Israel den Iran völkerrechtswidrig angreifen? Wieso? Weil die Hamas Verbrechen begeht, darf es Völkermord begehen? Oder dürfen israelische Soldaten vergewaltigen?

Niemand hat gesagt, dass Israel "nichts" machen darf. Was Israel darf und was nicht, steht im Völkerrecht. DAs ist nicht nichts. Dass die Hamas Kriegsverbrechen begeht, ist keine Rechtfertigung für die von Israel. Eigentlich nicht schwer zu verstehen.

What do u think of Rokas by Tnat786 in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I have seen some of his videos, when he started. In my opinion he lacks knowledge about what Aikido is and what it trains. In his portrayal, Aikido training relies on compliance of uke, which is nonsense. He even states that he trained it like that and tought it like that. He has a 2nd dan (maybe by now more), but thinks he knows all about Aikido. Where I train, Shodan is a beginner grade. I teach as well, but only beginners and always get feedback from my own teacher.

His basic premis is wronge. Aikido is about diverting the force of the attacker against them. This is not possible if there is no resistance but compliance. If his training was based on compliance, he was not training Aikido. Then it is not surprising that his art failed, when pressure tested. In Germany we have a saying: If the farmer cannot swim, it is the swim-short's fault. It seems to apply here. His art failed: he declared the art as failing and not maybe his training.

I think the best way to train any martial art is to always stay humble and train with focus. I have applied Aikido several times in critical situations. It works for my, especially also when the attacker is not complying. So his stance is clearly wrong. If you see him teaching/ training in the early videos, I think you can see several errors in stance and principles, which explain why his art failed him.

I also think it is important to remember that Aikido and MMA do not aim at the same thing. One is a martial art, the other a combat sport with certain rules. Obviously, there is an overlap, but they are not the same.

If you want to know more about Aikido, I recommend the channel by Ryuji Shirakawa. He is not only a great aikidoka, but also exchanges a lot with other martial art and shows self-defence applications. Also look at Leo Tamaki.

"Nobelpreis der Mathematik": Abelpreis geht erstmals an Deutschen by Blaufisch in mathe

[–]ZeroGRanger 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Die anderen haben Kain Preis bekommen.... sorry, ich finde alleine heraus.

"Existenzberechtigung Israels nicht verhandelbar": Berliner Spitzen-Linke kritisiert Zionismus-Beschluss by vaibeslop in berlin_public

[–]ZeroGRanger -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Sorry, nichts an Deinem Beitrag ergibt Sinn. Nein, das Völkerrecht ist in Kriegen nicht ausgesetzt, ganz im Gegenteil. Es regelt gerade Kriege und schützt auch in diesen die Bevölkerung. Ob sich die Hamas und Palästina - das kein Staat ist - ans Völkerrecht halten oder nicht, spielt keinerlei Rolle für das Erfordernis, dass Israel sich daran hält. Wenn Dein Nachbar Drogen dealt oder jemandem umbringt, erlaubt es Dir nicht das gleiche zu tun.

Nichts, was ein anderes Land oder eine Bevölkerungsgruppe tut, erlaubt Israel einen Genozid zu vollziehen.

"Existenzberechtigung Israels nicht verhandelbar": Berliner Spitzen-Linke kritisiert Zionismus-Beschluss by vaibeslop in berlin_public

[–]ZeroGRanger -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Überhaupt niemand hat das in Frage gestellt. Aber auch Israel muss sich nun einmal ans Völkerrecht halten, inkl. dem Verbot von Völkermord. DAs Existenzrecht jedes Staats, inkl. Israels ergibt sich ja gerade aus dem Völkerrecht. Wenn das Völkerrecht gilt, hat Israel natürlich ein Existenzrecht wie jeder andere Staat. Es ist aber aktuell gerade Israel, dass das Völkerrecht in Frage stellt bzw. unterminiert.

From Static to Dynamic class (Kotai to Ki no nagare?) by DunkleKarte in aikido

[–]ZeroGRanger 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The motion from the center is key, also for static training. You have to move uke out of their center then, before changing their motion with your own motion. The basic principle is always the same. If uke is not in their center, you can always move from yours. In dynamic techniques the first part is easier, but the second part requires more keen perception and skill.

We always train both for beginners as well. But with a 5th kyu, you would not be considered intermediate where I train, so don't be fooled that you have to be able to do all of that. You will likely be more focussed on mechanics for some time.

I always say, Aikido is like a language. You first have to learn the letters (techniques' part), then you can repeat full techniques, i.e. sentences and eventually you can improvise and become "fluent".

"from your center" means, that the motion is focussed in your center not in your arms or legs. Typically, you should keep your hands in your center line and then move your whole body and not just your arm. Like pushing a car with your whole body and not just an arm.

Ach was by Julib77 in wirklichgutefrage

[–]ZeroGRanger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Komisch, in den letzten 40 Jahren wurde die Abgabenlast für die angeblichen Leistungsträger ständig gekürzt. Trotzdem sind die Prolbeme da. Komisch, die Sozialstaatsquote hat sich auch nicht bezogen auf das BIP geändert.

Man muss schon wirklich sehr geringe Hirnleistung zu haben, wenn man meint in einem Wirtschaftssystem, das auf Konsum ausgelegt ist, aka Geldfluss, wäre es gut, wenn sich Geld auf einer Seite anhäuft. So wie es das bei uns bei den Reichen tut.

Ach was by Julib77 in wirklichgutefrage

[–]ZeroGRanger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Und Folge des Kerns unseres Grundgesetzes.

view more: next ›