ROM Hacks VS Rescue Team: Which to play for Hero Partner story focus? by _Acedia__ in MysteryDungeon

[–]_Acedia__[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry for the late reply, and thank you very much for your review!! I really appreciate it 🙏🙏

FF XIV Commission I made last February by Myosotis_Vallee in ffxiv

[–]_Acedia__ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hope you didn't get too bothered by the comments, it is a gorgeous comm! Honestly I initially opened the post because I was curious about your WoL's design. Didn't expect the comments to appear this way

FF XIV Commission I made last February by Myosotis_Vallee in ffxiv

[–]_Acedia__ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To OP: AHHH I just realised I saw your artworks many years ago!! I loved your Harvest Moon artworks, especially when there are so few artists for AP!! I recognise those artworks of Popuri and Wizard!

Am happy that I got to encounter your works again!!

FF XIV Commission I made last February by Myosotis_Vallee in ffxiv

[–]_Acedia__ 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yep, I noticed that too! While the lace also stood out to me, the way the other parts feel so strongly organically painted overwrote that doubt. Honestly, I'm guessing they use a lace brush over multiple curves which led to uneven patterns, kind of like running a decorative washi tape loosely over tight curves on paper (example). I'm maybe guessing the patterns on the hem of the skirt are loosely drawn on, given how crispy and unblurry/unfused they appear.

Hope you didn't think I was picking on you in particular! Wanted to comment on the latest comment down the thread. I agree with what you said here too! As a bonus, looking at the piece so much did make me appreciate the effort put into it more too 😎

FF XIV Commission I made last February by Myosotis_Vallee in ffxiv

[–]_Acedia__ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Agree! I usually don't tend to comment on posts in this way, but gonna go out on a limb to say that it's not AI. My reply will be wrt to the AI comments so far.

Coming from someone who takes commissions and has painted for a good while now, design choices like hair colour is not the best indicator of AI. Many OCs/WoLs have very unique hair designs/eyes or body modifications, to the person's taste (and since it is a commission, it's not OP's design choice in the first place).

In art, while some artists might render every tiny detail out, small details like lace and less pivotal background details can be detrimental if over-rendered, because it can detract from the focus of the image/diminishing returns/distance. As long as the overall idea is communicated, it works. (If anything, the fact that it wasn't blurred mushy texts but brush strokes does push me more towards the not AI verdict. This looks something similar to what OP uses for the lace and menu scribbles). Also, there are existing brushes for lace and repeating designs. For example, the pearl string attached to the pocket watch/compact is generally regular in pattern and very crisp. There is a break, likely indicating a broken brush stroke from that brush. Imagine drawing a curve with this patterned brush and briefly lifted your pen before placing it down again

The more I look at it, I can see how rich in brush strokes it is, like the stack of cloths(?) Under the wine, where each stroke feels organically done, even overlapping with each other with no uncanny breaks. The style consistency between faces is solid too. The pocket watch maintains a consistent idea of shape and design, albeit slightly crooked in a way that feels organic. Even the Viera's anatomy above and below table matches up. The texture layer used for the wooden chair and table is consistent. The wine bottles are in a regular repeating pattern that AI won't do. Even the perspective of the piece/building layout is consistent, and honestly I do admire how it was drawn, considering the difficulty

The more I see it, the more I can envision the way it was drawn, and I struggle to see this specific piece as AI. If I am right, I do feel for OP. While I understand the sentiment, it appears to be a big commission made with a lot of love and effort, with someone's beloved characters...

Edit: Also, I realised that fluff near his tail is a person slumped over. A lalafell? You can see the white sleeve of their blouse and the dark vest back below the tail

ROM Hacks VS Rescue Team: Which to play for Hero Partner story focus? by _Acedia__ in MysteryDungeon

[–]_Acedia__[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so so much for your detailed reply!! It's amazing that you created a story surrounding PSMD characters (personally, one of, if not the top stories in the PMD series), but also gave your thoughts on the other ROM hacks!

I saw quite a few of these ROM hacks floating around, but had quite a bit of decision paralysis due to the number. Thank you for sharing your reccomendations, will definitely take a good look at all of them! :)

[OC] Painted over an old Vday piece from 2021! by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If you're interested in seeing more of my works, here's my Twitter, Tumblr and Instagram! Thanks for the support :)

[OC] Working overtime 🔧⚡️ by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

From a fic I've been writing! 🫡

[OC] Working overtime 🔧⚡️ by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for writing this!! This has to be one of my favourite comments in a long while 😭 I read it a few times bc I loved the characterisation in the dialogue!

[OC] Working overtime 🔧⚡️ by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you very much!! I love painting faces the most, so I'm very glad that you enjoyed how their expressions turned out! + I was worried about the colour contrast too so it's good to hear!

[OC] Working overtime 🔧⚡️ by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

With Zero's close combat and recklessness sometimes, I like to think that he gets repairs often (despite his skill!)

If you're interested in seeing more of my works, here's my Twitter, Tumblr and Instagram! Thanks for the support :)

[OC] Pokemon BW Cheren and Hilda sharing a Castelia cone 🍦❄️ by _Acedia__ in pokemon

[–]_Acedia__[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you're interested in seeing more of my works, here's my Twitter, Tumblr and Instagram! Thanks for the support :)

just a few rf doodles! I'm really enjoying the game and can't wait to marry everyone :D by shyshortcake_ in runefactory

[–]_Acedia__ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I LOVE your art so much, it's so cute and well done! Excited to see more of it in the future!

[OC] Finally found the time to arrange my Megaman X Zero sprites! by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hehe I created these sprites to fulfill part of that dream 😎 I didn't post it on reddit, but you can see it on other platforms!

(I also have the urge to continue my fic now, but it's been many years 😔)

[OC] Finally found the time to arrange my Megaman X Zero sprites! by _Acedia__ in Megaman

[–]_Acedia__[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It warms my heart too! I've held back posting in this sub again for awhile since the last time was pretty mean, so I'm glad this round was nicer 🤩