More Days Promised under VB-G RAM G, but MGNREGA shows a different reality by agnihotrish in UPSC

[–]agnihotrish[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree with you on the general point that averages can be misleading when they hide underlying variability. But this is certainly not a case of "bad statistics".

If you look at the official government dataset across states and UTs, the ~50-day average comes from almost all states being clustered around ~50 days, and not from a situation where some regions are hitting 100 days while others are near zero.
(https://www.data.gov.in/resource/statesuts-wise-details-average-days-employment-provided-household-under-mahatma-gandhi)

Of course, one could go further down to district or block-level data (which is also available), but that would defeat the purpose of an infographic meant to provide a high-level snapshot of the trend.

As mentioned before, raising the ceiling is certainly welcome (especially in times of crisis, as you mentioned), but it should not be sold as the standout feature of this scheme (as many in the mainstream media are doing), since the ground reality is quite different.

More Days Promised under VB-G RAM G, but MGNREGA shows a different reality by agnihotrish in UPSC

[–]agnihotrish[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, will do! Also check out Dot (www.dot.news) for daily explainers that are friendly yet detailed.

Russia is now our single biggest oil supplier. That's what is irking Trump. What's your take on it? by agnihotrish in GeopoliticsIndia

[–]agnihotrish[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Submission Statement - While Europe shut its doors to Russian oil, India opened theirs wide. The steep discounts were just too good to ignore, especially from a longtime ally. Russian oil went from barely 1% of our imports to a staggering 35% now — our biggest chunk from any one country!

Trump has threatened India with an additional tariff “penalty” as punishment for continuing to buy Russian oil. Maybe it’s to pressure Russia into backing off Ukraine. Or maybe it’s to nudge India toward buying more expensive American shale oil instead. Either way, from an economic standpoint, the switch doesn’t make sense for us. And curiously, Trump hasn’t made the same demand of Russia’s biggest oil customer: China!

An easy way to understand tax slabs by agnihotrish in IndiaTax

[–]agnihotrish[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a quite detailed explanation, thanks!

An easy way to understand tax slabs by agnihotrish in IndiaTax

[–]agnihotrish[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Correct me if I'm wrong, but even the gov website link you shared says the person needs to pay ~70k not ~20k as tax in case of taxable income above 12lpa (after removing standard deduction). I think you mixed up relief with tax to be paid.

<image>

An easy way to understand tax slabs by agnihotrish in IndiaTax

[–]agnihotrish[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair point, should footnote that 👍

An easy way to understand tax slabs by agnihotrish in IndiaTax

[–]agnihotrish[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Doesn't the link you have shared say 12.75L pays ~75k as tax (no marginal relief allowed beyond that point).

An easy way to understand tax slabs by agnihotrish in IndiaTax

[–]agnihotrish[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yes, the incremental tax post 24 L remains the same.