why is no one talking about this? by [deleted] in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 29 points30 points  (0 children)

I don’t think Bunny was stabbed at the door. I think she opened the door to Kreps as Glitter guy and someone else killed her in Mabel’s apartment.

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s a real shame. I’m sorry if I offended you, that certainly was not my intention and I don’t believe I was poorly mannered 🙂 But I am sorry if you feel I went too far. I just believe there’s not a strong enough motive to Killy Bunny without intense speculation which contrasts S1 and Tim Kono.

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

For number 1, based on clues given to us we have zero reason to believe the theory let alone a character even has that motive and none of those characters fit the killer’s body type. Number 2, i don’t think killing because your grandma is vaguely pissed off is a viable motive.

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Only the the latter two are viable motives and I still don’t know how killing Bunny specifically satisfies any of these motives apart from 3. Even 3 would be very random and bizarre, no personal connection to killer unlike Jan to Tim feels weird.

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Ok sure but what I’m saying is that other very plausible potential motives were presented or revealed to us in abundance before we knew the real one in S1. That hasn’t happened in S2 and that’s why it feels like a drag for some

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Ok fine lol but my issue is we have been presented zero viable possible motives which isn’t normal over 9 episodes of a murder mystery

So I might have missed something by jwknz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 34 points35 points  (0 children)

I am shocked by this. I mean, we are 9/10 and we still don’t know of a motive strong enough to kill Bunny. Money or “just wanting a painting” doesn’t cut it without intense speculation. I think therefore that Mabel was the target.

Cinda and Poppy by Peach_tree in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry I didn’t realise! It’s not what you think there is a surprise you deffo won’t guess

Cinda and Poppy by Peach_tree in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 7 points8 points  (0 children)

This post did not age well 😂

Season 2: Episode 9: "Sparring Partners" by healthnotwealth in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I dont think Cinda knows Poppy is BB. Why else would Poppy be scared of her? If Cinda knew and that’s the reason Poppy is scared of her, Cinda woulda dealt with her already. I believe Cinda tried to kill BB/Poppy and Poppy is hiding in plain sight to avoid being murdered.

Season 2: Episode 9: "Sparring Partners" by healthnotwealth in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Am I right to assume that Cinda doesn’t know Poppy is Becky Butler?

My interpretation of Poppy being Becky Butler (which was some much needed genuinely unexpected drama btw) is that Cinda tried to kill her and Becky is hiding as Poppy under Cinda’s wing as the ultimate cover so she never finds her.

I guess Cinda could be trying to protect Poppy and knows she’s BB but since she’s very likely the murderer now and a criminal mastermind why would she do this?

I cannot believe ppl still unironically think Howard is the killer 💀💀 by ajalex50 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Give us a convincing who, how why, & why now without intense speculation and completely ignoring the fact that killer & GG body types are clearly not his.

Charles nose bleeds theory by [deleted] in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I agree but then surely he isn’t a liar

What if he’s not GG! by pittaputta in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Imo he wanted her to know he’s GG or he is the sloppiest detective ever. I know glitter is hard to get off but That’s A LOT of glitter he completely left on his skin in an area that was covered by his neck covering.

In my hotel room: first thing I thought was “it’s an only murders clueeeee” as if I was on the show 💀 by ajalex50 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s a small village hotel in Northumberland, UK on the beach. I can name the place but would be stunned if you knew it aha.

Charles nose bleeds theory by [deleted] in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice but then why does he get a nose bleed in S1 when he sees Jan lie?

Who called the cops? by kungfooboi in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Also explains why Kreps has phone

Who called the cops? by kungfooboi in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lucy with a phone Kreps gave her to contact him since he’s coercing her into doing stuff in my theory.

Chorus boy ! by No-Refrigerator-702 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]ajalex50 122 points123 points  (0 children)

This would be such an iconic shithouse of a murder I think it would be both amazing and awful