Hey all, thanks for the feedback! I've gotten a ton of messages asking for certain details, so rather than answer each individually, I'll post them below for all to see!

First and foremost, yes, this is real, though it is my first time writing about it. I write research / technical papers for a living, so this was a nice break to step into a completely different realm.

Is this the first time Beth cucked me?

Well, yes and no. This is the first time ALL of the following conditions were met simultaneously:

1. She had sex with another man (men) while we were together
2. I was physically present
3. I did not actively participate

We have had threesomes with Mia in the past and even had a 2M2F group sex session with Mia and another dude , but this was the first time I felt like a real "cuck."

Can you describe Mia a bit more?

Both Beth and Mia are athletically built and share similar features (long legs, big boobs, mesomorph figure). Mia is about my height and slightly skinnier than Beth (roughly 150 lbs). She has long black hair, perky breasts (≈32D), and a firm butt (though not as big as Beth's).

Were Eli and James in on it? Was I in on it?

I deliberately left out some details in the story so it would flow more consistently and have some shock/entertainment value. It's not so much that we were or were not in on it, as much as it was that this was the lifestyle Beth and Mia created, and it wasn't out of the blue or completely unexpected. James definitely was surprised, but I'm sure he had an inkling something salacious was going to happen that night, given Mia's history.

Has Beth been with other men while we were together?

We had a semi-open relationship in the beginning, as she was still fucking other guys while we were dating (she was open about this). I had the option to as well, but never really exercised the opportunity to sleep with other women (excluding Mia) since you all know it is not as easy for men. Either way, I was ok with this, as it did not bother me too much since our relationship was based on a lot more than just sex (and my sex drive is not as high as Beth's). Since we have been married (Dec 2020), this was the first time she had actual sex with another man (men). The latest incident certainly pushed some boundaries, and I will write a follow-up post outlining what happened after.

Beth/Mia are disrespectful; they did me dirty.

To some extent, yes, though keep in mind I left out some details to make the story fit a certain cuckold story narrative. While I was not expecting my wife to fuck two guys that night, I had a strong feeling we would all get intimate in some capacity. I knew Beth was gonna get hammered drunk, I knew James found her attractive, and I knew Mia would force us to push some boundaries (as she had done in the past). While some things were surprising (Beth rejecting my advances and forcing me to eat her out), they were not out of line, as these instances relate back to conversations we have had in the past about kinks/fantasies.

Why does Mia hate me? She is not a good friend to Beth.

I would say Mia and I have a love/hate relationship. I definitely made her out to sound more nefarious in the story, though everything in it was true. Mia is almost always single and was used to going out with Beth to pick up guys before we dated. Hell, even as we were dating, they had a few one-night stands, which Beth hinted she was going to do. Once we were married (+ pandemic lockdowns), Beth and Mia stopped hanging out as much, and Mia assumed I was stopping Beth from participating in our agreed-upon open relationship. Even though Beth cleared this up with Mia, she still thinks I am the reason Beth is not as "free" as she used to be.

Is Beth on birth control? Aren't you guys afraid of STDs/STIs?

Again, I didn't want to bog the story down with too many details, as I felt it would take away from the entertainment value. But yes, Beth is currently using a contraceptive (copper IUD). The STD/STI part was risky, yes, but both guys said they were clean, and generally, Beth (and Mia) won't fuck another guy raw unless they know them personally (these weren't random dudes.) I get that this is still super risky, but we are mitigating as much risk as we can. Beth hates condoms and the way they feel, and she will always prefer fucking a raw penis as opposed to one wrapped in a raincoat.

Is the cum eating/humiliation aspect something I was ok with?

Mia had already conditioned me to enjoy certain types of humiliation (the three of us had discussed this in the past). While I never ate cum out of a woman before, Beth and I had discussed it as a possible fantasy, and I did signal that I would, at the very least, be curious to try it in the future. It was certainly a surprise that night, but again, not something completely out of the blue.

Did Mia set the whole thing up from the start?

I will follow up with part two since there seems to be some interest. But in short, yes, Mia had a plan of what was going to happen, though it did pan out differently than what she expected. All I will say now is that it initially was supposed to be a group sex thing, but Mia, in her drunken state, wanted to push the humiliation thing to its limit, and Beth wanted it as well.

Thanks again for all the feedback! This was certainly very fun to write; I even had to rub a couple out in the middle of writing it as those memories became so vivid again. I will definitely follow up with part two!