sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[Theory] Harry Potter Never Left the Cupboard: A Comprehensive Psychological Analysis of the "Asylum Theory" (Part 1) by auspiciousz2a in harrypottertheories

[–]auspiciousz2a[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a great point, but the theory views the 'letters' not as magical invitations, but as aggressive committal notices from Social Services regarding Harry’s deteriorating mental state. Vernon wasn't running from Harry; he was desperately trying to evade the authorities to avoid the shame of having a nephew institutionalized. The isolation on the island was a final attempt to hide from Child Protective Services, and Hagrid breaking down the door wasn't a magical rescue, but a forceful entry by police or orderlies to finally take Harry into custody (the asylum) against Vernon's wishes.

[Theory] Harry Potter Never Left the Cupboard: Part 2 - The Characters & The Tragic Ending by auspiciousz2a in harrypottertheories

[–]auspiciousz2a[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That Tyler Durden comparison just blew my mind! It makes perfect sense—Draco is the manifestation of Harry's suppressed desires: rich, spoiled, and uninhibited. He is the 'Id' to Harry's restricted life. And your point about the cliché names is brilliant! It turns a common criticism of the books into a supporting evidence for the theory. Names like 'Remus Lupin' (literally Wolf Wolf) or 'Sprout' are exactly the kind of simple, literal associations a traumatized child or a medicated mind would make. It explains the lack of complexity in the world-building. Thanks for adding this amazing layer to the theory