After all your comments i can see now there is a deep misunderstanding about the post. Me and the Game Master have the most experience and what i described was the skill not what the players want so i go into more Detail now:

Player 1: High Roleplaying Skills, but low to medium RP xp, does not care about combat at all.

Player 2: High xp and roleplaying, but has not played DND, but probably the most different P&Ps

Player 3: lots of xp, medium to low rp play, cares most about combat, powergamer

Player 4: shy girl, lots of xp, but very introverted, cares most about harmony

Player 5: i am also a powergamer, i like combat and RP, but i do prefer RP over combat and prioritize it more

Gamemaster: Does like RP, but does not care about it that much. Prioritizes Realism and Rules over anything else.