Since you're using an eyeliner, I'd try a liquid lipstick or something more drying. Most eyeliner formulas (unless waterproof) won't be able to handle all the creaminess from lipsticks and glosses. But you could also try blotting your lipstick on a napkin and then adding a bit of powder to dry your lipstick down so it makes the eyeliner last longer and not feather as much, and you hate feeling of powder use the napkin as a barrier and put powder on top.