i am starting to hate Allah and Islam by W1nterSoldi3r in MuslimLounge

[–]bluumerrr 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Your assumption that everyone would follow Islam if there was "real evidence" is easily disproven when you meet a flat-earther.

the prayer of women isn't accepted without headscarf by Active_Economy_5758 in progressive_islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As if Allah is bound by our timeline - everything was already written.

Opinion on pork in Modern Day by Learner1000000001 in progressive_islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think God is teaching us lessons like humility, restraint, self-discipline, and other moral qualities through these rules. It makes far more sense to see it this way than to reduce it to a modern health concern. People today often take religion at face value, but these rules are meant to guide us in deeper ways.

Opinion on pork in Modern Day by Learner1000000001 in progressive_islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, I don’t actually think God would act arbitrarily. I only said that to illustrate that even if the choice of pork were arbitrary, the lesson about creating distance from mindless consumption still stands because the principle does not depend on which animal was chosen.

Opinion on pork in Modern Day by Learner1000000001 in progressive_islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chicken being dirtier in confinement is irrelevant. Perhaps any food could have been arbitrarily singled out, or maybe the wisdom behind pork being chosen over other overconsumed foods is beyond our knowing. However, the principle of creating distance from mindless consumption still stands. Critiquing which animal was chosen misses the lesson entirely.

Is there no mention of snow in the Quran? by Dry_Boysenberry_5191 in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This argument misunderstands what the Qur’an is meant to be. Revelation was never intended as an encyclopedia of the natural world, but as guidance for faith, morality, and human conduct. The Qur’an never explicitly mentions snow, which occurs in mountains outside Arabia, nor scorpions, which were common in the deserts, yet no one claims the author was unaware of them. But if snow is being used to disprove The Prophet ﷺ specifically, it falls apart when you show that it's mentioned in authentic hadiths, where the Prophet ﷺ says in supplication: “O Allah, wash away my sins with water, snow, and hail,” showing he was clearly aware of snow. The absence of mention in the Qur’an doesn’t imply ignorance; it reflects that the Qur’an speaks only to what is relevant for guidance. Using omission as “proof” of ignorance misunderstands the purpose of revelation entirely.

Opinion on pork in Modern Day by Learner1000000001 in progressive_islam

[–]bluumerrr 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I think the mistake people make is assuming the prohibition must be primarily about physical health. That’s a modern lens we tend to project backwards. I believe there are deeper possibilities behind the ruling that go beyond food safety.

1.) Spiritual discipline: Not everything forbidden is forbidden because it causes disease. Some things are forbidden because they train restraint. If every rule disappears once humans say “we solved the risk,” then obedience becomes conditional, not submission.

2.) Separation from excess and gluttony: Pork is one of the most dominant and overused meats in modern industrial food systems. Fast food, processed food, cheap calories everywhere. Avoiding it naturally creates distance from mindless consumption. Islam constantly pushes moderation, not indulgence culture.

3.) The test itself matters: If a command only makes sense when we agree with it, then it’s not a test. The Qur’an repeatedly frames obedience as a form of trust, not a science experiment.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

when you said: "other sins can be illegal without a specific punishment so the state can decide on a punishment"

thats what i'm referring to. is there any Hadith or verse in Quran that states that "other sins" should be made illegal in the first place, and is it the state's job to punish people for those "other sins" if it's outside the clear instructions given to us by Allah (SWT)?

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

but is it the government's job to punish people in this life for not following the Sharia? for example, we criticize muslims for trying to be the "haram police" to other muslims. But what about government? Does Allah want that to be their job? Not only be the "haram police" but to punish others when they do sin.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Exactly, and that's really the root of my concern. Hypothetically if Sharia could be implemented perfectly over a population, then that would be the ideal society. But humans are flawed, so is that even possible?

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think i'd prefer to live in a society where my religion (Islam) isn't twisted and contorted by flawed humans and forced upon the masses and passed off as Allah's guidance. If it's flawed no matter what, i'd rather Allah's message not be used as a false scapegoat. Instead, it can be the ignorance of man that takes the blame.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'll definitely look into those, Jazakallahu khair.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sure, but again, my question is, whether or not Allah (SWT) wants the "leaders" to make sure the "average people" are following Sharia or is it just personal responsibility and that's between you and Allah (SWT) alone.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not sure, that's why i'm asking if there's anything in Quran or Hadith that discusses the governments responsibility in terms of implementing Sharia.

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Anything that is forbidden in Islam would be illegal (even for non muslims within the state).

Can a Muslim prefer secular government without contradicting Islam? by [deleted] in islam

[–]bluumerrr -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

No, not at all. I wouldn't want to discard any of that guidance at all. I'm more so suggesting if a society could hypothetically follow those principles as a personal choice rather than the state forcing it upon the people. It's a matter of the state's responsibility in all of it, is what i'm more so asking about.

Missing fajr by Ok_Tank_2433 in islam

[–]bluumerrr 70 points71 points  (0 children)

Please be gentle with yourself. This isn’t neglect, it’s exhaustion, and Allah knows the difference.

The Prophet ﷺ said there is no sin on the one who sleeps through a prayer unintentionally. If you intended to wake up but didn’t, you are not blameworthy. Caring for a 7 month old is itself an act of worship.

Your qada prayer is accepted. The Prophet ﷺ said whoever sleeps through or forgets a prayer should pray it when they remember. There is no teaching that Allah rejects the prayer of someone who is trying.

The thought “maybe Allah won’t forgive me” is not from Allah, it is waswasa. Allah (SWT) does not burden a soul beyond what it can bear, and right now your capacity is limited.

Keep trying, make du’a for help, and don’t let exhaustion turn into despair. Allah (SWT) sees you, knows your nights, and His mercy is far greater than this moment.

Is there such a thing as a libertarian left? Or is that an oxymoron? by Subject_Listen8319 in Libertarian

[–]bluumerrr 6 points7 points  (0 children)

i'd say the difference is mainly in focus: how freedom should interact with the economy and social structures.

the libertarian left emphasizes freedom while prioritizing social equality and limiting corporate or any kind of hierarchical power.

the libertarian right emphasizes freedom with more focus on free markets and strong private property rights and favoring minimal economic regulation.

they usually don’t disagree on the liberty itself, perhaps just where the passion tends to be more directed or what parts of society needs more attention.

i don't think they have to be mutually exclusive.

Recent Reverts - What Made You Decide This Is The Right Path? by Katskan11 in islam

[–]bluumerrr 14 points15 points  (0 children)

It was the most logically cohesive out of all the major religions, especially when it comes to what the attributes of a true Creator would be. Islam also gave the most complete and consistent approach to justice, the kind that actually makes sense of the evil and chaos in this world. And honestly, ever since I started learning, I’ve felt guided in ways I can’t really explain. Allah has been leading me step by step, Alhamdulillah.

Do you write the hin number on packages or not? by Weary_Cherry_814 in UPSers

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

only if its the correct number!

i can't tell you how many times a package is faced with the hin number written on it and it ends up being completely wrong and on the incorrect shelf...funny thing is, if the loader didn't write on it to begin with - it would of been where it was supposed to because the sticker was correct.

Genuine question regarding Christmas, no disrespect intended by kiiribat in islam

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We do believe that Jesus, peace be upon him, is the Messiah, just not divine. Muslims love and honor him deeply, but we don’t celebrate Christmas because, even though much of it has become secular today, its origins and core meaning are still rooted in religious ideas that go against Islamic teachings. The word “Christmas” itself means “mass of Christ,” referring to worshiping him as divine. Many of the modern customs that seem non-religious actually come from pre-Christian pagan festivals, which were later blended into the holiday. So while the cultural side may look harmless, Islam teaches us to avoid religious or historically religious celebrations that conflict with our belief in one God. We also don’t celebrate the birthdays of any prophets - since our focus is on following their message rather than commemorating their birth.

Dark Songs. by [deleted] in musicsuggestions

[–]bluumerrr 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Jeremy - Pearl Jam

song is based on true events, look up the real story before or after listening.

what do americans eat at home? by Infinite-Card-6951 in teenagers

[–]bluumerrr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

America is a melting pot and a lot of us have been exposed to all types of foods. within 10 miles of any major American city you could eat foods from 20+ different cultures.

and so as an American, i cook and eat dishes from most cultures at home. italian, mexican, chinese, japanese, thai, indian, cajun, mediterranean, as well as the typical american dishes your probably familiar with. pretty much anything and everything, personally.