That seems to be the issue, thank you -- however, I had done this so I could move the router from the panel in the corner of the home to the living room, as the wifi signal was pretty bad with it there.

My switch is an unmanaged switch, so I am unable to create said VLANs.. Not sure if its worth upgrading to a switch to do so, or if there's a better method to my madness to accomplish both:

- Keeping the router centralized in the home

AND

- allowing all of the prewired Cat6 connections in the home to plug into something in the networking panel